CFTC wins case against broker for secretly taking other side of client orders in block trades

Rick Steves

“As we said at the outset of this case, the illegal use of inside or confidential information undermines confidence in markets and will not be tolerated.”

A jury in the Southern District of Texas issued a verdict finding Andrew Gizienski and EOX Holdings, LLC (EOX) liable for secretly taking the other side of their customers’ orders without consent 65 times and disclosing their customers’ confidential order information five times, in violation of CFTC regulations. The jury awarded $7 million in civil monetary penalties for these violations.

The same jury found EOX liable for both failing to supervise Gizienski and to create and/or maintain required copies of seven pre-trade communications. These violations will cost the firm $490,000 in civil monetary penalties.

In addition to the jury’s $7.49 million civil monetary penalties award, Senior Judge Sim Lake imposed a 120-day trading and registration ban on Gizienski. Judge Lake also ordered EOX to implement adequate policies and procedures within 60 days, and permanently enjoined both defendants from further violations of the CEA.

“Illegal use of inside or confidential information undermines confidence”

Acting Director of Enforcement Gretchen Lowe, said: “The CFTC is committed to maintaining the integrity of the markets and protecting customers. As we said at the outset of this case, the illegal use of inside or confidential information undermines confidence in markets and will not be tolerated.”

The trial was the culmination of an action the CFTC brought against Gizienski and EOX on September 28, 2018, alleging that the defendants misused customer information by trading on material, non-public information and disclosing confidential customer information to a favored client.

The financial watchdog was the main force against the defendants and presented numerous witnesses and documentary evidence, including instant message chats and trade data, to establish Gizienski repeatedly disclosed customer names and orders, and traded opposite his own customers.

The EOX Holdings case involved a firm that executed block trades of energy commodities for its clients. The CFTC alleged that the trader at the firm, Andrew Gizienski, improperly disclosed information about these block trades to other firm clients.

In EOX Holdings, the court identified three paths available to the CFTC to prove that the firm owed a duty of trust and confidence to its clients for whom it executed block trades:

  1. whether applicable law mandates the confidentiality of block trade order information;
  2. whether restrictions set forth in the rules of individual exchanges impose confidentiality on block trade order information;
  3. whether the financial institution and its block trading clients entered into confidentiality or nondisclosure agreements.

The court ultimately found that, in the context of commodities transactions, applicable law may mandate the confidentiality of block trade order information.

Read this next

Digital Assets

Bybit Unleashes Zero-Fee Revolution in P2P Crypto Trading

Bybit, the world’s third biggest crypto exchange by volume, has launched a zero-fee policy for its P2P trading, removing all transaction costs for buyers and sellers. This pioneering approach allows global traders to enhance their savings and profits without extra charges.

Fintech

ANZ deploys CobaltFX’s Dynamic Credit platform

“This new approach to credit management has helped eliminate carve-outs as well as reduce credit usage while improving our market access. This capability benefits our customers, counterparties, and the bank.”

Industry News

FINRA fines M1 Finance $850,000 for misleading ‘finfluencer’ activities

“As investors increasingly use social media to inform their financial decisions, FINRA’s rules on communicating with the public are especially critical. FINRA will continue to consider whether firms are using practices and maintaining supervisory systems that are reasonably designed to address the risks related to social media influencer programs.”

Institutional FX

Eurex launches a new first: STOXX Semiconductor 30 Index Futures

“Recent global uncertainties have prompted nations to prioritize the secure production and distribution of semiconductors. Consequently, our STOXX Semiconductor 30 Index Futures are reflecting the growing appetite for semiconductors as a new investment theme. We are seeing a noticeable demand from Asia in particular, as Taiwanese companies are well represented in the index.”

Fintech

Finalto doubles down on APAC region with oneZero curated liquidity from Tokyo

“We are excited to announce the expanded relationship with oneZero not only by using their Institutional Hub as a key component in our technology stack, but now by adding the Equinix TY3 data center to the LD4 and NY3 data centers. This exemplifies our dedication to providing our customers with cutting-edge technology options in accessing our wide liquidity and product offerings via a seamless trading experience.”

Retail FX

From Backtesting to Arbitrage: Practical Applications of AI in the World of Retail Trading

In this article, the industry leaders delve into the transformative role of AI in trading.

Digital Assets

FTX claim value soars to 92%, creditor sued for reneging on $58M deal

Attestor Capital, a London-based investment firm holding significant FTX bankruptcy claims, has initiated legal action against a Panamanian company called Lemma Technologies.

Digital Assets

OKX to remove Tether trading pairs ahead of MiCA

OKX, the world’s fourth-largest cryptocurrency exchange by trading volume, is discontinuing support for tether (USDT) trading pairs in the European Economic Area (EEA).

Digital Assets

Changpeng Zhao is back with new project post-Binance era

Changpeng Zhao, the founder and former CEO of Binance, hinted at a new educational project on Monday.

<