Copy trading platforms may remain in regulatory limbo as MiFiD II is delayed

Rick Steves

Government authorities often lag behind the Forex industry as this particular business is well known for its disruptive innovation, sometimes taking years or even decades to set up a proper legal framework in touch with the new realities that continue to come to light. As the MiFiD II seems to be getting postponed to January […]


Government authorities often lag behind the Forex industry as this particular business is well known for its disruptive innovation, sometimes taking years or even decades to set up a proper legal framework in touch with the new realities that continue to come to light.

As the MiFiD II seems to be getting postponed to January 2018, one of the many regulatory issues urging to be addressed resides in copy trading and other similar services. These activities that, some say, stand in blurring lines between advisory business and broadcasting market content, are found to be considered as portfolio management services according to some authorities.

Despite having been around since 2005, since Lior Nabat’s Mirror Trader invention at Tradency, social trading platforms evolve and prosper with no clear insight of what will happen in the near future, risking a potential crackdown on copy trading. Compliance specialists have already been advising firms on how to adapt their business structure to be in consonance to requirements, particularly under MiFiD II.

For example, traders with no broker wanting to open an account at Zulutrade can now only open an account with Zulutrade’s broker, AAAFX, as the platform no longer affiliates to other brokers. At the account opening, they now add a MiFiD questionnaire to assess the client’s understanding of trading.

Other changes in “traders” performance page, connecting and disconnecting signal providers, settings page and ZuluGuard, as well as customizing the replication process and deposits/withdrawals were made to be in line to what compliance departments consider an appropriate reading of the MiFiD II rules. However, the postponement to January 2018 of these rules will keep the industry blindfolded until then.

The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) considers services providing copy trading, PAMM, MAM, and Expert Advisors as Managed Discretionary Account (MDA) operators and should hold an appropriate financial services license (AFSL) and comply with MDA requirements, such as a MDA contract with an investment program and statement of advice for each client.

In 2014, the UK Financial Conduct Authority first shared their view that allowing investors to trade by automatically copying another investor’s trades generally as portfolio or investment management.

“Typically, retail traders mimic the trades of other users through contracts for difference (CFD) platforms. These platforms integrate information sharing and social media with online CFD trading. We classify copy trading as portfolio or investment management where no manual input is clear from the account This entails standard regulatory obligations for authorized management”, said the statement by the FCA first published in 12 May 2015 and later updated in 29 January 2016. Exceptions to the rule exist when there is no automatic order execution.

“The client may take investment decisions rather than the service provider to buy or sell the individual investments. For example:

The trade signals are investment advice (or a general recommendation), and the client must confirm each recommendation before any order is executed or transmitted for execution on their The trade signals are fully determined by the client, who must set the detailed limits for each signal/order/transaction, such as the precise market conditions that will trigger a particular signal (e.g. purchase or sell instrument A when its price on market B reaches level C).”

The ESMA statement in 2012 pointed to the direction of regulation in Europe, sharing the opinion that a service that allows a client to choose one or more third parties that provide trading signals, and has the client’s authorization to execute orders (or transmit them for execution), such practices are to be considered as Portfolio Management.

Such interpretation might lead regulators to require either the operator of the platform or the customer’s brokerage to hold a Portfolio Management license. In case of platforms that allow manual trading, an Investment Advice license might be needed, unless the operator abstains from making specific recommendations, from promoting or solicit particular trades, and from ranking trades based on recommendation criteria.

Uncertainty, however, remains the keyword under MiFiD II. And while firms can redesign their business and make a real effort to comply to requirements, an unclear environment could remain until 2018.

  • Read this next

    Inside View

    Scalping or day trading?

    Among the many popular trading styles with both beginners and experienced traders are scalping, which allows you to extract small portions of profit from each price movement, and day trading, which aims to trade over a single day. In this article, you will learn what scalping and day trading are and their differences and peculiarities. Ultimately, you will learn what to look for to understand which trading style is right for you.

    Crypto Insider

    Unveiling Plasma Next: INTMAX’s Solution to Scale Ethereum with Stateless Layer

     INTMAX has launched Plasma Next on the mainnet α, a groundbreaking Layer 2 zkRollup, revealed by co-founder Leona Hioki at ETH Denver. This innovation offers scalability with constant costs per block, merging Plasma’s scalability goals with zkRollups’ security.


    Nuam selects Vermiculus for clearing system in Chile, Colombia, and Peru

    “We are proud to deliver a system that plays an integral role in the core of this historical merger, empowering one of Latin America’s most crucial markets with VeriClear’s state-of-the-art technology, together with our deep market expertise.”

    Retail FX

    Moomoo launches super app in Malaysia

    “As an investment platform connecting 21 million retail investors globally, we envision collaborating with exchanges, regulatory bodies, and partners in the visible future to become the gateway, connecting Malaysia’s investment products to global capital and investors.”

    Executive Moves

    FXPA elects Joe Hoffman as new Chair in its 10th anniversary

    “The opportunity to serve as Chair of the FXPA is truly an honor, and I am committed to upholding the exceptional work of a FXPA. Given the recent market fluctuations due to global tensions, inflationary pressures, shifts in monetary policy, as well as the outcome of the US election and the risk of recession, brings the potential for more FX volatility in 2024. I am dedicated to expanding the FXPA’s membership and I’m excited about collaborating with all members to echo the unified voice of the FX market.”

    Market News

    Eurozone Fights Stagnation Whilst Stock Indices Rally

    European stock markets are defying economic gloom as they continue to soar to all-time highs, showcasing resilience amidst broader economic challenges.


    Lisk Partners with Indonesia’s Communications Ministry to Boost Web3 Startup Ecosystem

    Discover the strategic partnership between Lisk and the Indonesian Ministry of Communications and Informatics, aimed at propelling local Web3 startups to new heights through comprehensive support and education.

    Executive Moves

    Admirals appoints founder Alexander Tsikhilov as CEO

    “Striking the right balance between sourcing new talent and developing and harnessing the strength and capabilities of our current workforce, is key to achieving our vision.”

    Executive Moves

    GCEX appoints Ignacio Corral and Helen Man to UK operation

    GCEX has announced the appointment of Ignacio Corral and Helen Man to its UK FCA-regulated operation based in London as the firm further expands its global business on account of increasing demand for its digital prime brokerage services.