Crypto lending in the US at risk over BlockFi settlement, says SEC’s Peirce

Rick Steves

“Rather than forcing transparency around retail crypto lending products, today’s settlement may stop them from being offered to retail customers in the United States”.

SEC Commissioner Hester Peirce has stated her concerns over yesterday’s settlement with BlockFi.

While stating that a company taking in crypto from a wide range of investors and promising returns could implicate the securities laws in several ways, Ms. Peirce questioned if the the approach the SEC is taking with crypto lending is the best way to protect crypto lending customers. “I do not think it is, so I respectfully dissent.”

BlockFi will pay a total of $100 million, $50 million to the SEC and another $50 million in connection with state settlements for the same conduct.

“While penalties this size are intended to deter bad conduct, here there is no allegation that BlockFi failed to pay its customers the money due them or failed to return the crypto lent to it. BlockFi’s misrepresentations about over-collateralization are serious, but the combined $100 million penalty nevertheless seems disproportionate”.

Challenging path to onboard retail investors

The SEC Commissioner agreed that customers should get the information they need to assess the risks against the rewards and a self-regulatory or government regulatory framework make sense to ensure transparency, but the securities regulatory framework might not suit best for the terms and risks of crypto lending products.

“Applying the securities regulatory framework has consequences, some of which may be unfortunate. Rather than forcing transparency around retail crypto lending products, today’s settlement may stop them from being offered to retail customers in the United States”, said the Commissioner.

“BlockFi will not be allowed to take in any additional crypto from retail investors until the company has registered a new crypto lending product on Form S-1. Getting an S-1 to the point where staff will declare it effective is often a months-long, iterative process. When crypto is at issue, the timeframe is likely to be longer than it would be for more traditional filings.”

Even assuming BlockFi perseveres and prevails in the S-1 registration process, the firm must first leap through another regulatory hoop, the Investment Company Act.

Although BlockFi was fined for operating as an unregistered investment company, the company cannot register as an investment company since it issues debt securities.

It needs an exemption or exclusion from registration as a market intermediary, a rarely used exclusion with a challenging path to prove that it qualifies.

An alternative would be to work with BlockFi under the SEC’s Section 6(c) exemptive authority to craft a bespoke set of conditions that make sense in this context, said the SEC’s official.

Hester Peirce then criticized the SEC’s process which speaks volumes about its integrity as a regulator. “Inviting people to come in and talk to us only to drag them through a difficult, lengthy, unproductive, and labyrinthine regulatory process casts the Commission in a bad light and thus makes us a less effective regulator.”

She concluded by calling the SEC to do better at accomodating innovation as a company that tries to do the right thing should be met across the table by a regulator that tries to get to a sensible result in a reasonable timeframe.

Read this next

Institutional FX

Marex profit soars 70pct in H1 2022 on commodity boom

London-headquartered commodities broker Marex posted record revenues in the first half of 2022 as strategic investment across its global franchise has positioned the business to outperform in favourable market conditions.

Executive Moves

YourBourse hires 3 executives to transform development procedures

“Valter, Maria, and Sergey bring decades of experience in the FX industry to our company and I’m very excited how they will enable our ambitious growth plans.”

Technology

Baton adds OCC to collateral management network

“For the FCM community, this translates into ensuring money isn’t being left on the table. Our FCM clients are already using the Baton platform to move tens of billions of dollars of collateral every week.”

Retail FX

eToro buys US rival Gatsby to expand zero-fee trading offering

Israeli social trading and multi-asset brokerage company eToro has secured the regulatory nod to acquire no-fee trading app Gatsby as it aims to expand its business in the US.

Executive Moves

Genesis Global snatches CMO Jason Jhonson from metaverse company

The hire of Jhonson follows the announcement that Genesis raised $20 million in fresh funding from US banking giants, Bank of America, BNY Mellon and Citi.

Digital Assets

Celsius subsidiary GK8 integrates with Polygon while looking for new owner

“This integration affords our customers more agility in managing their crypto assets, which is key to creating new revenue streams.”

Digital Assets

BDO Italia audits Tether reserves to release monthly attestation

World’s largest stablecoin issuer, Tether has switched the accounting firm that audits the massive reserves that back its USDT token to BDO Italia, the 5th largest accounting firm in the world.

Retail FX

Libertex bags multi-year sponsorship deal with FC Bayern

Indication Investments Ltd, the operator of FX retail brand Libertex, has secured a lucrative sponsorship deal with German soccer giant FC Bayern.

Institutional FX

PrimeXM reports lower volumes for July as summer lull bites

PrimeXM has reported weaker trading volumes for July 2022, in line with other institutional and retail platforms that saw the activity of their clients dropped compared to a month earlier.

<