Multi-asset class trading more profitable than equities at, report finds

Rick Steves

“It’s perhaps unsurprising that first-time retail traders realized more profits from FX, indices, and commodities relative to single stocks in the last 12-16 months.”

Clients who trade for longer periods of time across a wide range of asset classes are more profitable than those who close-out positions immediately or trade just one specific market, according to research led by Senior Market Analyst Daniela Hathorn.

The new data compiled by the high-growth global trading platform only confirms this well-known ‘Lapalissade’. Still, and despite the higher profitability levels of a diversified trading strategy, just 15% of clients trade across 5 different asset classes.

The vast majority of traders (65%) trade between 2 to 4 different asset classes, while 20% of clients trade just one asset class, the report added.

Data was derived from the behavior of 100,000 active traders between May 2022 and April 2023 and found that clients who traded 5 different asset classes typically closed 60% of their positions with a profit. By comparison, clients who traded 1 asset class closed 48% of their positions with a profit, on average.

Longer, diversified trades in FX, Commodities, and Indices

The length of time traders keep a position open is highly correlated with profitability, the report concluded, pointing to an average of 44% of positions closed with profits when traders held them for between 30 minutes to 6 hours. These traders also used stop-losses more frequently. By contrast, clients who held positions for less than 30 minutes typically closed 41% of their positions with profits while those who held them for more than 24 hours closed just 39% of their positions with a profit. More than 50% of traders holding their positions for longer than 24 hours did not use stop-losses at all.’s first-time traders—defined as those clients who have recently opened an account with and placed their first trade— displayed a propensity for success when trading commodities, foreign exchange, and indices. First-traders were less profitable when trading equities. On average, clients who began trading for the first time with equities realized a profit in 46% of their positions. In contrast, clients who began trading with commodities realized a profit from 58% of their positions. The other two most profitable markets for first-time traders included FX and indices, with traders closing 56% and 54% of their positions with profits, on average, respectively. provides a wide range of educational support, including a free learning app, Investmate, to support new traders.

Daniela Hathorn: “Unsurprising that first-time retail traders realized more profits from FX”

Daniela Hathorn, Senior Market Analyst at, said: “The challenging market is hitting everyone at present, but one way to try and slow the tide is by diversifying your investments. It’s better to spread the risk across different asset classes, companies and investments than to pursue profits from one single area that could quickly go south. Our data clearly demonstrates how diversification can not only be an effective risk management strategy but also a profitable trading strategy during periods of market uncertainty.”

“High inflation, rising interest rates, and treacherous periods of volatility have defined much of the past 12 months – all of which have made for extremely difficult trading conditions. This may have encouraged retail traders to exercise caution with greater use of stop-losses and shorter trading times.

“We understand that trading can be a daunting experience for new traders. Sifting through the noise, honing your understanding of markets, and making sense of the news is crucial when you get started in trading. That’s why we prioritize education and learning to ensure that our clients have access to the best learning aids, explainers, charting, and analysis tools to help them make informed trading and investment decisions.

“It’s perhaps unsurprising that first-time retail traders realized more profits from FX, indices, and commodities relative to single stocks in the last 12-16 months. With rising interest rates affecting the cost of borrowing and future corporate growth, company earnings have been a mixed bag. Over the same period, however, commodity markets have shown resilience with oil and gas markets benefiting from rising prices while gold has remained the safe-haven asset during a period of heightened uncertainty. Across FX, ongoing global central bank activity provided ample opportunities for traders looking to capital on macro events.”

Read this next

Digital Assets

TYRION Advances Decentralized Advertising with Strategic Move to Coinbase’s Base Chain

In a game-changing partnership, decentralized advertising pioneer TYRION integrates with Coinbase’s Base Chain, marking a synergistic leap towards transparent, efficient, and innovative digital advertising solutions in a future driven by blockchain.

Institutional FX

FXSpotStream reports highest ADV in six months

Trading volumes on institutional FX platforms surged in September as traders increased their bets on central bankers’ policy with evidence mounting that inflation and economic growth are not yet losing momentum.

Digital Assets

Coinbase makes major push into Singapore with MPI license

Cryptocurrency exchange Coinbase has secured a Major Payment Institution (MPI) license from the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS).

Retail FX

Begin Your Trading Journey by Learning How to Use Trading 212

In the upcoming content, the process of getting started with Trading 212 is explored, from registration and choosing account types to the benefits of connecting with Traders Union.

Institutional FX

Cboe reports +10% increase in monthly FX volumes

Cboe’s institutional spot FX platform today announced its trading volume for the month ending September 2023, which showed resurgence in activity following two consecutive months of reduced trading volumes.


Muinmos integrates TConsult’s Investor Self-Declaration platform into client onboarding platform

“Given the increasing regulatory demands, our clients have eagerly anticipated this integration. Partnering with TConsult, one of the industry’s foremost tax experts, allows us to offer a comprehensive solution. By embedding digital tax certifications into our onboarding processes, we provide a more efficient, risk-mitigated approach to client initiation.”


TS Imagine taps Cassini Systems’ pre-and post-trade margin and collateral analytics

“Joining forces with Cassini allows us to offer a single, integrated system that provides in-depth analytics, streamlining operations for investment and risk management teams. This collaboration stands to significantly benefit our clients in the ever-evolving market landscape.”

Retail FX

XTB launches fractional shares offering in the UK

“The roll-out of Fractional Shares has made capital markets even more accessible for UK investors. Having observed the positive reception to our Fractional Shares in other European regions, we’re confident that this addition fortifies our competitive stance in the UK, positioning XTB as a go-to destination for a diverse range of investors.”


Baton Systems launches DLT-powered post-trade solution Core-Payments ahead of T+1

“With the transition to T+1 now just months away, and with regulators growing increasingly vocal around the need for greater settlement control and supervision, it is paramount that market participants ensure they are fully prepared to cope with any rise in settlement risk