Ripple CTO “chokes on Diet Coke” as SEC desperately tries to overturn court ruling

Rick Steves

The SEC said Bill Hinman’s speech was his personal opinion. He signed an affidavit stating just that. The court accepted that as the truth, which makes documents pertaining to that speech unprivileged information. The SEC, however, seems to be doing a full 180º.

The Securities and Exchange Commission has asked Judge Analisa Torres to wait until February 17, 2022, as the plaintiff prepares a motion for partial reconsideration of the Deliberative Process Privilege (DPP) ruling ordered by Judge Sarah Netburn.

The SEC wants to file a 20-page brief and submit more documents for the in camera review in support of the motion to reconsider the court’s ruling of one single aspect of the order: the drafts and emails in connection with ex-SEC Director Bill Hinman speech of June 14, 2018.

“The SEC is desperately trying not to have to turn over the documents to Ripple” – James K. Filan

The court granted Ripple’s motion to compel the SEC to deliver those documents based on the uniqueness and precedent-setting nature of the case and massive public interest.

“The SEC had two different routes to take in response to Judge Netburn’s DPP ruling. First, it could request that Judge Netburn
reconsider her ruling, or, second, it could have filed objections to Judge Netburn’s ruling directly with Judge Torres, which is basically an appeal. But both the motion for reconsideration and the objections have to be filed within 14 days of Judge Netburn’s original ruling”, attorney James K. Filan explained on Twitter.

“So what the SEC is doing is asking Judge Torres to wait until 21 days after Judge Netburn rules on the motion for reconsideration before the SEC must file its objections directly with Judge Torres. The SEC is desperately trying not to have to turn over the documents to Ripple”.

“I choked on my Diet Coke as I read this”

Also commenting on the SEC’s unexpected move was David Schwartz, Chief Technology Officer at Ripple Labs. “I choked on my Diet Coke as I read this”, sharing a photo of one specific paragraph.

“The SEC respectfully submits that these additional documents clarify the truly deliberative nature of the discussions surrounding the Speech across the SEC, and show that the Speech was not “merely peripheral to actual policy formulation”, but was in fact an “essential link” in the SEC’s deliberative process with respect to Ether” and other digital assets. The SEC  therefore seeks leave to submit for in camera review the entire set of the 66 documents…”

The whole SEC v. Ripple lawsuit has been baffling executives, law experts, investors, lawmakers, and some regulators ever since it started. This move opens a new chapter as the SEC seems to be looking to have it both ways.

A few months ago, the SEC’s attorneys argued Bill Hinman’s 2018 speech was merely his personal opinion in order to protect itself from Ripple’s attempts to make the fair notice defense stick. Judge Sarah Netburn accepted the agency’s statement as true and in her latest ruling, the court considered the drafts and emails regarding his speech as not privileged, thus ordering the SEC to deliver those to Ripple’s defense.

Now, the SEC is trying to argue that the speech was not “merely peripheral to actual policy formulation”, but was in fact an “essential link” in the SEC’s deliberative process with respect to Ether and other digital assets.

An epic 180º turn. We’re getting closer to the anniversary of the first time the court ordered the SEC to hand over those documents.

“Plainly not appropriate”, says Ripple

Ripple, as expected, filed against the SEC’s request to extend by three weeks the time to file a motion for reconsideration of Judge Netburn’s DPP ruling.

The defendants complained about the time lost since the SEC first refused to hand over said documents, almost a year ago.

“Defendants are entitled to review these documents to prepare their defenses to the SEC’s claims. Any further delay to allow the SEC to present new or additional evidence or to raise new arguments that are plainly not appropriate on a motion of reconsideration would only prejudice Defendants.

Given the SEC’s arguments, Ripple replied that a motion for reconsideration may not be used to advance new facts, issues or arguments not previously presented to the Court.

In the meantime, XRP Holders’ attorney John Deaton has already announced he will file a FOIA request to get his hands on Hinman’s emails and drafts as well.


Read this next

Retail FX

Belgium regulator blacklists FXP360, Appex Finance, and Wise-Markets

Belgium’s financial watchdog, the Financial Services and Markets Authority ‎‎(FSMA), has issued a warning against the unauthorized activities of multiple ‎ platforms that are offering investments in the country without ‎complying with Belgian financial legislation.‎

Digital Assets

MicroStrategy piles on Bitcoin, acquiring 0.90% of circulating supply

MicroStrategy, the world’s largest Bitcoin corporate holder, has further increased its holdings of the primary cryptocurrency. According to a recent filing, the company acquired an additional 16,130 bitcoins between November 1 and November 29, spending $593.3 million at an average price of $36,785 per bitcoin.

Digital Assets

Paxos gets nod to issue dollar-backed stablecoins in UAE

Stablecoin issuer Paxos has received preliminary approval from Abu Dhabi’s Financial Services Regulatory Authority to issue U.S. dollar-backed virtual currencies and provide crypto-brokerage and custody services.

Digital Assets

Flare Labs Begins Testing FAssets on Coston Testnet Paving Way for Non-Smart Contracts to Flare

Flare Labs has introduced FAssets on the Coston testnet, enabling the integration of non-smart contract tokens like BTC, XRP, and DOGE into the DeFi ecosystem.

Digital Assets

Philippine bars access to Binance, citing unregistered operations

The Philippines’ Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is moving to block access to Binance due to regulatory concerns, citing the platform’s operation without proper registration and authorization in the country.

Digital Assets

FTX cleared to sell investments in Grayscale and Bitwise funds

Bankrupt cryptocurrency exchange FTX has received approval from the bankruptcy court to start selling its stakes in digital trusts managed by Grayscale Investments.

Digital Assets

Nexo launches Dual Investment for yield earning and price prediction

“Dual Investment revolutionizes how users engage with BTC and ETH, offering a flexible, intuitive, yet sophisticated platform for predicting asset price movements, all while securing high yields.”


Aquis Stock Exchange goes live with cloud-based matching engine powered by AWS

“By running on AWS, the Aquis Stock Exchange is driving transformation across the capital markets industry while continuing to enhance the scalability, functionality and innovation that will benefit its members and stakeholders in an environment where security and resiliency are our highest priority.”


Options Technology certified as Microsoft Azure partner for Digital & App Innovation

“Securing our fifth Microsoft Solutions Partner status in less than 12 months is a testament to our commitment to innovation, excellence, and the highest industry standards. We are not only keeping pace with the evolving landscape of cloud technology but leading the way in shaping its future.”