SEC v. Ripple: Lack of clarity admission is “gift from the heavens” for Ripple and XRP

Rick Steves

“I mean, you can litigate a hundred cases and never get a gift like this letter and I say it’s a gift from the Heavens because you know that the Commissioners could never comment on pending litigation.”

“Everyone in the XRP community (including myself) owes a debt of gratitude to Commissioner Pierce/Roisman for telling the truth, first and foremost, AND in gifting Ripple this letter from officials at the SEC. It takes bravery to do that, knowing it would be used against the SEC”, said attorney Jeremy Hogan on Twitter.

The lawyer was commenting on the recent statement from SEC Commissioners Hester Peirce and Elad Roisman in connection with the SEC’s settled action against Coinschedule. The document was included in a letter from the individual defendants’ counsel as part of their motion to dismiss the case against them.

“This is the best piece of evidence we’ve seen on the Fair Notice Defense thus far and it would be Exhibit Numero Uno in my Motion for Summary Judgment”. Mr. Hogan added.

“Imagine you are the Judge deciding whether Ripple had “Fair Notice” it was violating the law and you look in the file and see a letter from 2 out of the 5 SEC heads stating essentially that “Not only Ripple didn’t have Fair Notice, NO ONE had or has Fair Notice.”

Later, in a video published on Youtube, Mr. Hogan provided a more in-depth analysis, noticing that the Fair Notice defense has come to the forefront.

The Hinman deposition is scheduled for July 27, although the SEC plans to object to any question that could fall under the deliberative process privilege.

SEC v. Ripple angers XRP holders as rival Stellar (XLM) mixed in “love triangle” over MoneyGram

 

Now, this statement from two SEC Commissioners is likely to tip the balance in the SEC v. Ripple and the lawsuit against Brad Garlinghouse and Chris Larsen.

“And it’s relevant to both, boy is it relevant, first for the individual defendants because the standard, in that case, is that the SEC has to prove that “the Individual Defendants knew or recklessly disregarded that Ripple’s offerings and sales of XRP required registration as securities and that those transactions were improper.”

That legal standard is similar to what Ripple has to prove in its Fair Notice defense, according to the lawyer. Ripple’s claim is that it “did not have, and Plaintiff failed to provide, fair notice that its conduct was in violation of law, in contravention of Ripple’s due process rights.”

Mr. Hogan explained why Ripple Labs hasn’t filed this letter yet: “Ripple is going for the big win – summary judgment which will provide case precedent for it and all other crypto currencies. The individuals are just trying to get out fast. But by law you cannot file for summary judgment or at least have it heard, until discovery is complete and we have another couple months before discovery is closed in the Ripple case.”

The attorney linked to the XRP community then pointed to third parties “people” and “marketplaces” which limits the SEC’s moves. Instead of claiming its their personal opinion and has no legal effect, the two SEC Commissioners letter indicates that their understandings are based on discussions with people from the industry.

“I mean, you can litigate a hundred cases and never get a gift like this letter and I say it’s a gift from the Heavens because you know that the Commissioners could never comment on pending litigation.”

“And you know that Ripple could never get the Judge to make them sit for deposition, and you know that with Judicial Notice this letter had to be attached to another case like the case that just settled so that was a case the Commiissioners could comment on and they took that opportunity to put out thoughts on the confusion that exists in the marketplace.”

Also ahead in the SEC v. Ripple case is the deposition of William Hinman, July 27. Despite the probable stream of objections claiming privilege, there are expectations that the ex-SEC Director will help clarify what happened during the time of his speech in 2018 when he said Ether is not a security.

Read this next

Digital Assets

Despite crypto winter, Cake DeFi paid out $58 million in Q2 rewards

According to its latest ‘Transparency Report,’ Cake DeFi continued its growth trajectory in the three months through June 2022, even as the entire crypto industry experienced macro challenges this quarter.

Retail FX

SimpleFX Review: Cryptos, Spreads, Pros & Cons

SimpleFX combines years of Forex and cryptocurrency experience with a focus on offering resources to retail traders. 

Retail FX

Ironbeam becomes CME clearing member and launches MT5

“The direct clearing aspect along with our low-latency proprietary trading tools and technology solutions make Ironbeam the ideal trading destination.”

Institutional FX

Top 0.07%: oneZero makes it to Inc. 5000 of fastest growing companies in America

oneZero started out by serving the foreign exchange trading community, developing and executing technology that could scale with the growth of the FX market.

Industry News

CFTC wins case against broker for secretly taking other side of client orders in block trades

“As we said at the outset of this case, the illegal use of inside or confidential information undermines confidence in markets and will not be tolerated.”

Technology

BankiFi raises $4.8m to bring embedded banking platform to North America

“Our mission is to make all aspects of cash management and payments easier for SMBs everywhere, and this investment is another huge step to making that a reality.”

Executive Moves

Shieldpay hires ex-Payoneer Chris Andrews as Head of Sales

“We’ll be expanding our position in existing markets and accelerating growth into new verticals, whilst building on our direct and indirect channels.”

Digital Assets

Crypto.com secures preliminary approval to operate in Canada

Crypto.com, one of the longest-established crypto platforms, has become the first digital asset platform to sign a Pre-‘Registration Undertaking’ with the Ontario Securities Commission (OSC) in Canada.

Retail FX

CySEC hits IC Markets One with regulatory warning

The Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission has once again stepped up its fight against unauthorized brokers.

<