XRP lawsuit: ‘Make or break’ ruling for Ripple ahead – Conference transcript released

Rick Steves

The release of the transcript might signal that the Judge’s ruling over Ripple’s motion to compel the SEC to hand over internal deliberations is right around the corner. This motion is a make of break for Ripple’s fair notice defense.

The Southern District of New York US Federal District Court has released the transcript of the widely followed telephone conference of August 31 in the SEC v. Ripple case.

The conference debated the Deliberative Process Privilege (DPP) in the context of Ripple’s motion to compel the SEC to hand over internal documents concerning the agency’s views on digital assets, namely XRP, BTC, and ETH.

A granted motion would be a huge win for Ripple as Judge Sarah Netburn would signal that the defendant’s fair notice defense might have some ground.

Why investors didn’t know XRP would be treated as securities?

As Ripple counsel Matthew Solomon said in the conference, the purpose was to find out whether the SEC acknowledged that market participants did not understand that offers and sales of XRP would be treated as securities either because the SEC itself wasn’t certain or because their communications with market participants made that clear.

This relates to Ripple’s fair notice defense in which the defendants argue that the regulator failed to make it clear that its native digital asset could be construed as an investment contract.

The conference explored analogous court cases, including Kik and Zaslavskiy, and their request for internal SEC deliberations as part of fact discovery.

Judge Sarah Netburn first asked about the SEC’s aiding and abetting claim regarding the complaint against the individual defendants, if Brad Garlinghouse think it relies on objective or subjective foreknowledge that XRP was a security in 2013, to which counsel Matt Solomon replied that it had to be obvious to reasonable people.

If the status of XRP was not obvious to the SEC until filing the lawsuit in December 2020, it could not have been obvious to Mr. Garlinghouse, Ripple’s counsel stated.

Matt Solomon then mentioned the SEC’s use of the deliberative privilege process (DPP) argument to keep its internal documents from being handed over to the defendants. Mr. Solomon argued that the plaintiff went grossly overboard in regard to DPP and should be compelled to hand over those documents as requested by Ripple.

Judge not happy with SEC’s arguments

The Judge moved to attorney Jorge Tenreiro, the SEC’s counsel, and asked his view of the “reckless standard” for the aiding and abetting claim made by the plaintiff.

Mr. Tenreiro first attacked Ripple’s analysis and stated that specific, simple foreknowledge alone is all that counts. “But was Mr. Garlinghouse’s action objectively reasonable?”, the Judge asked.

The SEC answered with a subjective argument – “He could sit before a jury and say he did or didn’t know” – to which the Judge interrupted “But that’s subjective!”.

The Judge asked again and Mr. Tenreiro repeated himself, i.e., not offering an objective interpretation of Garlinghouse’s alleged aiding and abetting of an unregistered securities offering.

Then, the SEC counsel complained that Ripple wants to “collapse everything” into “digital asset law” and look at “everything internally” and “swing the door open” which would be “very damaging”.

Judge ruling right around the corner?

The court ruled it would have the SEC’s internal documents handed over so the Judge could decide whether there was enough ground to grant Ripple’s motion to compel.

The hearing was in late August 2021 and the court has ruled over many other motions afterward and presided over the expert discovery that included the testimony of 16 experts.

The release of the transcript might signal that the Judge’s ruling over Ripple’s motion to compel the SEC to hand over internal deliberations is right around the corner. This motion is a make or break for Ripple’s fair notice defense.

Read this next

Executive Moves

Lirunex Limited recruits Waleed Salah as head of MENA sales

Maldives-based brokerage firm Lirunex Limited has secured the services of Waleed Salah, who joined the company in the role of its head of sales for the MENA region.

Executive Moves

Trading 212 parts ways with co-founder Borislav Nedialkov

Trading 212 has a void to fill at its FCA-regulated business in London, following the departure of two key players, Raj Somal and Borislav Nedialkov.

Digital Assets

Binance acquires troubled crypto exchange GOPAX

Binance, the world’s largest digital asset trading platform, has reportedly acquired a majority stake in the troubled South Korea-based cryptocurrency exchange GOPAX.

Digital Assets

Kraken exits Middle East, closes UAE office

Digital currency exchange Kraken will close down its operations in Abu Dhabi, UAE and lay off the majority of its team focused on the Middle East and North Africa.

Industry News

CFTC comments on ION Cleared Derivatives issues after Russian-linked hack

“The ongoing issue is impacting some clearing members’ ability to provide the CFTC with timely and accurate data. As this incident unfolded, it became clear that the submission of data that is required by registrants will be delayed until the trading issues are resolved.”

Industry News

FCA took down 14 times more misleading ads in 2022 thanks to technology

The FCA has made significant improvements to the digital tools it uses to find problem firms and misleading adverts. These improvements have enabled it to work through a much larger number of cases compared with 2021.

Executive Moves

HKEX appoints ex-Goldman Sachs Matthew Cheong to lead platform’s focus on derivatives

“He has worked for a number of the world’s leading investment banks and his experience will be invaluable to HKEX as we continue to enhance our derivatives product offerings and build on our innovative and robust platform business, connecting capital with opportunities.”

Digital Assets

Zodia Custody and SBI Digital Asset Holdings launch JV for crypto asset custodian in Japan

“Zodia Custody is both proud and excited to be working with SBI DAH to help set up SBI Zodia Custody; the first tier 1 crypto asset custodian for institutions in Japan.”

Digital Assets

Paxos opens R&D center in Israel to focus on transaction signing and crypto custody security

“Paxos is looking to expand its team in Israel in 2023 and beyond, giving engineers the opportunity to work on cutting-edge financial products and shape the future of the global economy.”

<