XRP lawsuit: Next ruling will be “the biggest decision in the Ripple case”

Rick Steves

“If Judge Netburn ultimately rules that the emails must be turned over, it is HUGE”, said attorney John Deaton.

The SEC v. Ripple has heated up in the last few days with the unsealing of Ripple’s 2012 legal memos with advice on how to avoid making XRP a security in the eyes of the Securities and Exchange Commission, but the lawsuit is expected to go full steam in the days ahead.

Judge Sarah Netburn will soon be presented with “the biggest decision in the Ripple”, according to the opinion of XRP Holders’ attorney John Deaton.

As it is known, the Magistrate has recently ruled on the deliberative process privilege (DPP) issue with a few wins for Ripple, which were enough to be considered as a great result for the defendants and XRP holders, as Bill Hinman’s speech was found not to be privileged, as well as related notes and drafts.

The SEC then filed a motion for reconsideration as the plaintiff, arguing that what was once said to be a “personal opinion” is now being called “public guidance.”

The 180º turn by the SEC has shocked many following the lawsuit, but Magistrate Netburn will literally be the judge of that.

John Deaton, the attorney representing the more than 65,000 XRP Holders with Amicus Curiae status in the SEC v. Ripple case, has commented on the upcoming ruling, pointing to how critical it will be for the outcome of the lawsuit.

It’s all about XRP vs ETH

“Judge Netburn’s decision on the motion for reconsideration will be the biggest decision in the Ripple case. I say that [because] I don’t believe the motion to strike the [Fair Notice Defense) is a significant one [because] the Judge isn’t deciding [whether] Ripple had fair notice, but only [whether] it can argue it”, he said.

“The reconsideration motion relates to the 63 emails containing drafts and comments regarding the Hinman #ETH is no longer a security speech. The final version of the speech discusses both #Bitcoin and #ETH. The final version does not refer or mention #XRP”

“#XRP consistently battled #ETH for the number 2 Crypto behind #BTC in January 2018 – 6 months before the Hinman speech – #XRP hit an all-time high above $3 making it the world’s 2nd largest crypto.”

“What are the chances of #XRP not being raised at all in any of the 63 emails? What are the chances that at least one person in the email chain brought up #XRP? One person in the email chain could’ve posed a very reasonable question 🙋‍♂️, such as: “What about #XRP?”

“Once someone understands how #ETH was created and utilized and how #XRP was created and utilized, it becomes very logical to ask. For example, Attorney Wendy Moore – a partner at Perkins Coie – a law firm very knowledgeable of both #ETH and #XRP – asked that very question”.

“To be blunt, once you understand both #ETH and #XRP, it’s impossible NOT to ask that question. Joseph Grundfest, who helped the #ETH founders, explained this to the SEC in his December 17, 2020 letter. The Perkins Coie lawyers, who advised both platforms, raised the same question.

“It’s fair to assume that #XRP was brought up in one of those emails. We know that on June 13, 2018, a memo analyzing w/r #XRP was a security had been completed and DID NOT recommend enforcement. If true, the mere fact that #XRP was mentioned in the email is exculpatory.

If Judge Netburn ultimately rules that the emails must be turned over, it is HUGE. Don’t forget, even if the SEC persuades her that the emails are covered under the DPP, she can still pierce the privilege and order the documents produced.

“If she rules the emails privileged, but orders the SEC to produce them, it means #XRP is referred to and/or the evidence is indeed exculpatory. If the judge believes evidence is exculpatory and Ripple has no other means of obtaining the evidence, she will pierce the privilege.

If she overturns her previous ruling and decides the emails are privileged but doesn’t pierce the privilege, the emails, although helpful to Ripple, are likely not as big as we perceive.

The reconsideration will be the biggest decision in this case short of dispositive motions.

Read this next

Executive Moves

YourBourse hires 3 executives to transform development procedures

“Valter, Maria, and Sergey bring decades of experience in the FX industry to our company and I’m very excited how they will enable our ambitious growth plans.”


Baton adds OCC to collateral management network

“For the FCM community, this translates into ensuring money isn’t being left on the table. Our FCM clients are already using the Baton platform to move tens of billions of dollars of collateral every week.”

Retail FX

eToro buys US rival Gatsby to expand zero-fee trading offering

Israeli social trading and multi-asset brokerage company eToro has secured the regulatory nod to acquire no-fee trading app Gatsby as it aims to expand its business in the US.

Executive Moves

Genesis Global snatches CMO Jason Jhonson from metaverse company

The hire of Jhonson follows the announcement that Genesis raised $20 million in fresh funding from US banking giants, Bank of America, BNY Mellon and Citi.

Digital Assets

Celsius subsidiary GK8 integrates with Polygon while looking for new owner

“This integration affords our customers more agility in managing their crypto assets, which is key to creating new revenue streams.”

Digital Assets

BDO Italia audits Tether reserves to release monthly attestation

World’s largest stablecoin issuer, Tether has switched the accounting firm that audits the massive reserves that back its USDT token to BDO Italia, the 5th largest accounting firm in the world.

Retail FX

Libertex bags multi-year sponsorship deal with FC Bayern

Indication Investments Ltd, the operator of FX retail brand Libertex, has secured a lucrative sponsorship deal with German soccer giant FC Bayern.

Institutional FX

PrimeXM reports lower volumes for July as summer lull bites

PrimeXM has reported weaker trading volumes for July 2022, in line with other institutional and retail platforms that saw the activity of their clients dropped compared to a month earlier.

Retail FX

FCA warns of ATFX Global Trading / ATFXcoin

In its latest clampdown against the specific type of ‘clone fraud’, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has warned local investors to watch out for a company called ATFX Global Trading / ATFXcoin.