CFTC aims to use Court ruling that virtual currencies are commodities in other cases

Maria Nikolova

The US regulator seeks to use the ruling Judge Jack B. Weinstein in its case against My Big Coin Pay too.

As FinanceFeeds reported last week, Judge Jack B. Weinstein of the New York Eastern District Court agreed with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) and Chicago Mercantile Exchange Inc that virtual currencies are commodities under the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA). The Order was delivered as a part of a fraud case brought by the CFTC against Patrick K. McDonnell, of Staten Island, New York, and CabbageTech, Corp. d/b/a Coin Drop Markets (CDM), a New York corporation. The defendants are charged with fraud and misappropriation in connection with purchases and trading of Bitcoin and Litecoin.

Now, the CFTC is seeking to use this Order to support its action against other fraudulent cryptocurrency schemes. In the latest filings with the Massachusetts District Court, the regulator is referring to Judge Jack B. Weinstein’s Order in the case launched by the CFTC against McDonnell. This Order will be used as supplemental legal authority in the case brought by the CFTC against My Big Coin Pay, Inc., Randall Crater, and Mark Gillespie.

In particular, the CFTC refers to the Judge Weinstein’s ruling that:

  • virtual currencies fall well-within the Commodity Exchange Act’s definition of ‘commodities’;
  • the Commission “has standing to exercise its enforcement power over fraud related to virtual currencies sold in interstate commerce”.

Let’s recall that the CFTC had suffered a setback in its case against My Big Coin Pay. The regulator had hoped for a preliminary injunction hearing to be held on January 25, 2018, as the temporary restraining order does not enjoin the ongoing fraud, including the fraudulent solicitations currently on the Internet. The counsel for the defendants, however, insisted that the current orders are sufficient and that a delay would not harm the CFTC.

On January 30, 2018, Judge Rya W. Zobel agreed to reschedule the hearing for March 15, 2018, thus giving the defendants extra time. This illustrated the complexity of legal proceedings against virtual currency scams. Technically, the defendants may continue to solicit investor funds.

The CFTC has charged Randall Crater, Mark Gillespie, and My Big Coin Pay, Inc., with misappropriating over $6 million from customers. The case also targets Relief Defendants Kimberly Renee Benge, Kimberly Renee Benge d/b/a Greyshore Advertisement a/k/a Greyshore Advertiset, Barbara Crater Meeks, Erica Crater, Greyshore, LLC, and Greyshore Technology, LLC for allegedly receiving customer funds without providing any legitimate services to clients and without any interest or entitlement to such customer funds.

The regulator has found that customer funds had been transferred into the personal bank accounts of the defendants, and that the defendants had used those funds for personal expenses and the purchase of luxury goods.

Specifically, the CFTC Complaint alleges that from at least January 2014 through January 2018, the Defendants fraudulently solicited My Big Coin Pay customers in the United States by making false and misleading claims and omissions about MBC’s value, usage, and trade status, and that MBC was backed by gold. Defendants also allegedly fraudulently solicited numerous customers in the District of Massachusetts, receiving in excess of $5 million from those customers.

The case is captioned Commodity Futures Trading Commission v. My Big Coin Pay, Inc. et al (1:18-cv-10077).

Read this next

Digital Assets

CFTC Charges Binance and Its Founder, CZ, with Willful Evasion of Federal Law

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) has filed a civil enforcement action against Changpeng Zhao and three entities that operate the Binance platform with numerous violations of the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) and CFTC regulations.

Institutional FX

Macau announces MCEX exchange for institutional exposure to China’s micro and small businesses

One issue that can’t be overlooked, however, is how transparent can these cash flows be, given the reality of parallel economies in micro and small businesses. 

Digital Assets

Sphynx Ink and OpenSea Partner for “Winkles & Flam” Digital Collectibles

Sphynx Ink Inc. is launching Winkles & Flam, the first cartoon duo in the web3 space, with original hand-drawn art and educational content focused on video game history.

Industry News

Titanium Blockchain CEO sentenced to 4 years in prison for $21m crypto scam

He did not use the invested money as promised but instead commingled the ICO investors’ funds with his personal funds, using at least a portion of the offering proceeds for expenses unrelated to TBIS, such as credit card payments and the payment of bills for his Hawaii condominium.

Industry News

First Citizens acquires Silicon Valley Bank’s deposits and loans

Technically, First Citizens is acquiring Silicon Valley Bridge Bank, National Association, an entity created by the FDIC following the closure of Silicon Valley Bank by the California Department of Financial Protection and Innovation.

Industry News

FXDD named “Most Transparent Broker – Europe” for 2022

Continuing its winning streak, leading brokerage firm FXDD has won the “Most Transparent Broker – Europe” award – granted by the Awards 2022.

Industry News

The UTIP has launched a reseller program, opening new opportunities to maximize profits

The UTIP Technologies Ltd.  is underway to launch a reseller program. A purpose of the program is to attract new partners, boost a brand awareness and create a unique offer for forex brokers. This allows the reseller to buy and integrate attractively priced UTIP products with their own solutions and expand a range of products for their clients.


Fxview Sheds Light on Technology Enablement

Traders gain control over their activity and capital with low-latency execution.

Digital Assets

Haru Invest secures EU passport via VASP license in Lithuania

“Haru Invest has been growing stronger than ever, even during the volatile market situation, so we are very keen on crypto regulations. Obtaining a VASP registration is one of many milestones for our company, and it will help build trust in the crypto industry for our members by providing secure and compliant digital asset management services.”