Chamber of Digital Commerce supports Telegram in unregistered digital token offering case

Maria Nikolova

The Chamber’s arguments run counter the SEC’s motion for a summary judgment against Telegram.

Shortly after the United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) moved the New York Southern District Court for a summary judgment against Telegram Group Inc. and TON Issuer Inc. as a matter of law on its claim that the defendants made unregistered offers and sales of securities, a third party is trying to intervene in the case.

As per documents filed with the Court on January 21, 2020, the Chamber of Digital Commerce is trying to make the Court consider its amicus curiae brief. The latter is a statement by someone who is not a party to a case and is not solicited by a party, but who assists a court by offering information that bears on the case.

Although the Chamber of Digital Commerce does not explicitly state that its brief is in support of Telegram, it is apparent that the Chamber’s arguments run counter the SEC’s motion for a summary judgment against Telegram. Cutting the long story short, the Chamber of Digital Commerce argues that an asset does not become a security simply by virtue of being the subject of an investment contract (i.e., a securities transaction). The SEC, however, argues that this is the case and that Grams are, hence, securities and that Telegram is responsible for an $1.7 billion unregistered digital token offering.

In its amicus curiae brief, seen by FinanceFeeds, the Chamber of Digital Commerce presents itself as a not-for-profit trade association formed in 2014 to promote the acceptance and use of digital assets and blockchain-based technologies. The Chamber claims to represent more than 200 companies that are investing in and innovating with blockchain-based technologies.

The Chamber says it has a strong interest in the central issue in the SEC’s case against Telegram, in particular, the interest is on how the analysis of whether a transaction is an investment contract, and thus a “security,” is applied to transactions involving digital assets.

“Although the Chamber does not have a view on whether the offer and sale of Grams is a securities transaction, the Chamber has an interest in ensuring that the legal framework applied to digital assets underlying an investment contract is clear and consistent”, the Chamber’s brief says.

The Chamber requests the Court to distinguish the subject of the investment contract from the digital asset. This requires two separate analyses: (i) Whether there is an investment contract offered in a securities transaction; and (ii) whether the subject of the investment contract is a commodity that can be sold in an ordinary commercial transaction. It further requests that the Court affirm that a digital asset is not a security solely by virtue of being in digital form or recorded in a blockchain database.

In particular, the Chamber asks the Court to maintain the distinction between investment contracts and their underlying assets, making clear that an asset does not become a security simply by virtue of being the subject of an investment contract (i.e., a securities transaction). Let’s explain that this would pave the way for Telegram to claim that Grams are not securities and that, hence, Telegram should not be sued by the SEC.

This case concerns Telegram’ active promotion and sale of “Grams,” a form of digital token, which according to the SEC, is a security. In 2018, Telegram and TON Issuer effected a purportedly private sale of approximately $1.7 billion worth of Grams, with no registration statement in effect. The SEC argus that the defendants thus violated Section 5 of the Securities Act of 1933 (“Securities Act” or “Act”), 15 U.S.C. § 77e.

The SEC has asked the Court to consider the economic reality of what Telegram was doing: raising money to build a platform that would create value and profits for the investors. Much like a stock certificate, a Gram represents an asset, the SEC argues. When sold to the investors, that asset was an investment contract. And, upon the launch of the TON network, that asset will remain an investment contract. The sale of Grams was not registered and thus violated Section 5 of the Securities Act, the SEC concludes.

Read this next

Digital Assets

AAX ranked world’s second largest spot exchange, only behind Binance

Crypto trading volumes experienced their first surge in activity since March as the majority of digital assets began their recovery from the recent grim price action, according to a new report by Cryptocompare.

Digital Assets

Bitpay teams up with Cardlytics to provide 15% cashback rewards

Crypto payment service provider Bitpay announced a partnership with Cardlytics Inc (NASDAQ:CDLX), which it says will offer more rewards for BitPay cardholders on its platform.

Digital Assets

BlackRock digs further into crypto with spot bitcoin private trust

BlackRock, the world’s largest asset manager with almost $8 trillion in AUM, has launched a spot bitcoin private trust for institutional clients in the United States.

Digital Assets

SEC fines Bloom Protocol, orders refund to BLT token purchasers

Blockchain startup Bloom, which raised $30 million in funds via an initial coin offering (ICO), has agreed to return the money to token purchasers and pay a $300,000 fine, the SEC announced.

Institutional FX

FX volume takes step back at Singapore Exchange in July

The Singapore Exchange (SGX), the country’s paramount exchange operator, has released its monthly volumes across its FX, derivatives and commodities segments for July 2022.

Market News

The Week Ahead: 12 August from David Madden, Market Analyst at Equiti Group

There was a spike in volatility last week when the US CPI report ticked down to 8.5% from 9.1%, missing the forecast of 8.7%. The announcement led to chatter the Fed might not carry out a 0.75% interest rate hike in September.

Digital Assets

Pomelo Pay adds crypto payments capabilities from TripleA

According to a June survey conducted by Deloitte, nearly 75% of retailers plan to accept either cryptocurrency or stablecoin payments within the next two years.

Executive Moves

Talos appoints “boss, mentor, and friend” Neal Pawar as strategic advisor

“Foundational technologies are needed for institutions to fully embrace this potential, however, and in my opinion Talos’s platform is steadily becoming the de facto industry standard for digital asset trading.”


Avelacom enhances Middle East connectivity amid new market trends

Avelacom found that smaller markets in the region were not sufficiently covered by third-party vendors.