Court orders US Govt to produce additional trading data disclosures in spoofing case

Maria Nikolova

The Government has until February 21, 2020, to produce additional data disclosures in the proceedings targeting former Deutsche Bank precious metals traders.

James Vorley and Cedric Chanu, the former Deutsche Bank precious metals traders accused of spoofing, have managed to secure partial Court approval of their motion for additional disclosures from the United States Government regarding the trading data that will be the principal evidence at trial.

An order signed by Judge John J. Tharp, Jr. of the Illinois Northern District Court on February 12, 2020, gives the Government about one week to produce a raft of trading data disclosures requested by the defendants.

In particular, until February 21, 2020, the Government will have to:

  1. identify the alleged “Primary Orders” in the 150 trading episodes it expects to present at trial;

  2. to identify its “High Priority” episodes; and

  3. to disclose the selection criteria it used in identifying potentially fraudulent trades.

Let’s recall that the Government has identified 150 trading “episodes” as to which it intends to present evidence at trial. The identified episodes are time periods during which trading activity occurred; each identifies a span of time ranging from a few seconds to more than half an hour. The episodes span a period of more than five years, beginning on June 11, 2008 and running to July 9, 2013. In addition to the date of the episode and the time period defining each episode, the Government’s list of these episodes identifies the product traded and the traders involved in each episode.

Vorley and Chanu have filed a motion to compel regarding the trading episodes the government has identified. First, the defendants seek identification of the alleged “Primary” and “Fraudulent” orders in each trading episode. The Court notes that Government provides no reason it should not be required to also identify the alleged “Primary Orders,” and since they were an integral part of the alleged scheme, the Court agrees that they should be specifically identified. As this is information that has, presumably, already been identified by the Government, it should be able to provide that information to the defendants promptly.

The traders also seek disclosure of the selection criteria that the government used to identify the initial collection of approximately 3,000 trading episodes that it culled from the records of the defendants’ trading activity.

The government has explained that it did not use objective selection criteria to identify its list of 150 trading episodes. Rather, it used selection criteria only to identify a collection of about 3,000 trading episodes, which it then analyzed individually to assess whether they were probative of fraudulent trading. A critique of the selection parameters is irrelevant, according to the government, because none of the trading episodes were selected for inclusion on the list of 150 trial episodes by virtue of such criteria. What matters, the government argues, is not how or why the government came to review a particular trading episode, but whether that episode is probative of fraudulent trading.

In its statement issued on February 12, 2020, the Court concludes that disclosure of the selection criteria initially used by the government to identify potentially fraudulent trading episodes is warranted.

Let’s note that the trial of Vorley and Chanu has been rescheduled and is now set to commence on May 5, 2020.

Read this next

Industry News

The B2Broker B2Core REST API Is Now Live

B2Broker has announced the release of its new REST API, which lets customers use B2Broker’s solutions and services for business purposes.

Executive Moves

CME Group taps Paul Woolman to lead Equity Index, Giovanni Vicioso to lead Crypto

“Our equity and cryptocurrency businesses have experienced tremendous growth in recent years, underpinned by strong customer adoption and continued innovation.”


Sumsub launches document-free KYC for users in India, Brazil, Nigeria and Indonesia

Sumsub has launched one click-KYC for users in India, Brazil, Nigeria and Indonesia in a move that allows businesses to instantly onboard over 2 billion users without requesting their ID documents.

Digital Assets

Cboe becomes first major global exchange operator on DeFi data platform, Pyth Network

“Our participation in the Pyth network will provide another avenue to broaden customer access to our data, and aligns with our strategy to deliver market data to investors around the globe based on how they want to consume their data, whether through direct connectivity methods, the cloud or the blockchain.”

Industry News

FINRA fines Barclays Capital $2 million for best execution failures for 5 years

FINRA has fined Barclays Capital $2 million for failing to comply with its best execution obligations in connection with its customers’ electronic equity orders between January 2014 and February 2019. 

Digital Assets

SETL helps SWIFT, CSDs and custodians develop common framework for tokenisation systems

London-based enterprise DLT and blockchain company SETL has delivered a pilot project for SWIFT which implemented a common framework linking tokenisation systems between central security depositories (CSDs) and global custodians.

Digital Assets

Crypto volumes hit CHF 87.1 million at Switzerland exchange

Switzerland’s principal exchange has experienced a rebound in trading activities for September 2022, with monthly volumes increasing by more than 20 percent MoM.

Digital Assets

Bitcoin Suisse Vault taps Polkadot governance features

Bitcoin Suisse has added support for Polkadot protocol governance on its proprietary, hyper-secure cold storage solution, the Bitcoin Suisse Vault.

Retail FX

Finalto sweetens offering for African traders with localized FX pairs

Finalto, the financial trading division of Gopher Investments, announced today that it has extended its offering with inclusion of a number of African Pairs to its trading platforms.