Different view on FXCM: Jonathan Baumgart

Maria Nikolova

“Even in a pure STP / agency model, some counterparty must handle the hot potato known as risk”, says Jonathan Baumgart.

The full impact of what happened at one of the major retail FX brokers – FXCM, which has been sanctioned by US authorities and prohibited from the US market, has yet to be known.

As opinions pile with regards to the consequences for the US FX market and the entire Forex industry, FinanceFeeds has turned to Jonathan Baumgart, CEO, MoneyMatters.pl & Atomiq Consulting, to share his insight on this topic. Having spent nearly five years at FXCM as a Sales Associate, as well as launching the firm’s Berlin office, Mr Baumgart provides an expert opinion about the US market and a different view on the FXCM ruling.

What happened at FXCM?

Jonathan Baumgart

“I’ve read many comments on finance sites about the FXCM ruling and find that the retail community often misunderstands what happened here”, Mr Baumgart explained.

“FXCM failed to disclose how it was handling risk, misleading traders to think they were dealing with a pure agency model. The thing is, even in a pure STP / agency model, some counterparty must handle the hot potato known as risk. The liquidity partner / counterparty of an agency broker must also employ risk management practices which could result in situations such as slippage or difficulties trading around news events, these are both scenarios traders don’t like to encounter but are unavoidable if you are trading any financial instrument”, he said.

“Although by no means an excuse, FXCM is an example of the extreme measures and risks a broker in the US took to try to make the business work under strict regulatory rules” – Jonathan Baumgart, CEO, MoneyMatters.pl & Atomiq Consulting.

The impact on the FX industry

As many foresee a raft of negative consequences from the FXCM ruling, including a hit on the image of the FX industry worldwide, FinanceFeeds asked Mr Baumgart about his opinion on the impact from FXCM’s exit from the US market and the regulatory ruling.

“Although this news will have ripple effects for FXCM’s non-US client base and be another stumbling block for credibility after SNB, the only impact I see in America is a further consolidation of an already tightly consolidated market”, Mr Baumgart said.

“How many other G10 countries in the world have only 2 brokers to choose from?” – Jonathan Baumgart, CEO, MoneyMatters.pl & Atomiq Consulting.

He then elaborated on the factors for the US FX market being in such a situation.

“The main reason the US industry looks like this is due to regulatory changes. Since the beginning of this decade the industry has consolidated due to extremely prohibitive capital requirements (nearly 20 times greater than Europe), increased margin per trade and product restrictions which forbid CFD or metals trading”, he said.

The Dodd-Frank Act

“As far as the future of the US industry goes, it’s a wait and see approach based on Trump’s signal to “do a big number” on Dodd-Frank. His vague comment leaves us on our toes. Will this promise include retail FX? Could capital requirements and other rules related to margin change? Should regulations change under the Trump administration then this would breathe new life into what is at the moment a defunct industry”, concluded Mr Baumgart.

    Read this next

    Digital Assets

    Shiba Inu Enhances Privacy & Security with New Encryption

    SHIB, the force behind the Shiba Inu cryptocurrency, today introduced Fully Homomorphic Encryption (FHE) into its platform, ensuring unmatched data protection for its users.

    Digital Assets

    Binance Broadens Its VIP Invitation Program for Traditional Asset Traders

    Step Into the Future of Trading: Binance Invites Traditional Asset Traders to Join Its Exclusive VIP Program

    Digital Assets

    Algotech Presale Revolutionizes DeFi Scene, Surpassing $1 Million Raised in Just Weeks

    Emerging Cryptocurrency trading platform Algotech (ALGT) known to be famous with its cutting-edge features. The TradFi platform features advanced algorithms to provide a competitive edge to traders. 


    Revolut enables direct transfers from Singapore to Bangladesh and Kenya

    British fintech firm Revolut has broadened its array of services with the introduction of the “Mobile Wallets” feature in Singapore, facilitating direct money transfers to Bangladesh and Kenya.

    Digital Assets

    SBF claims “zero loss” to FTX customers, 100-year sentence is “grotesque”

    Sam Bankman-Fried, the former FTX CEO who was found guilty of fraud charges last year, is facing his sentencing next month. But before that day arrives, he’s making a plea for what he considers a fair shake.

    Digital Assets

    Bitcoin nears $62,000, sparking retail buying frenzy

    Bitcoin dashed past the $61,000 barrier on Wednesday, a peak it hadn’t touched since the waning days of November 2021.

    Market News

    OPEC+ Extension of Oil Output Cut Causes Rally

    The dynamics surrounding crude oil are indeed fascinating, given its unique role as both a globally traded commodity and a vital energy source deeply influenced by the OPEC+ alliance’s decisions.

    Institutional FX

    DKK reports 226% growth in 2023 with eyes on African expansion

    “Our numbers are beginning to show how we are powering, the growth required by emerging markets, and we plan for the success of our strategies to continue to thrive in 2024.”

    Industry News

    ‘WTF’ as in ‘What The Fraud?’, Sumsub’s new podcast on digital fraud

    “We found a lack of informative podcasts talking about digital fraud threats and prevention for business owners. So, we decided to dive in and share our expertise along with industry top minds in the ‘What The Fraud?’ podcast.”