Do traders really care about execution method, or whether a broker is A or B book? Not one bit, says OANDA APAC CEO Rajesh Yohannan

Among FX industry executives, the amount of resources, both cognitive and financial, committed toward ensuring that the execution method is as transparent as possible, is enormous. For several years, many of us have pondered a line which borders on political correctness in banishing the b-book model of execution to almost taboo status, and majoring on […]

Among FX industry executives, the amount of resources, both cognitive and financial, committed toward ensuring that the execution method is as transparent as possible, is enormous.

For several years, many of us have pondered a line which borders on political correctness in banishing the b-book model of execution to almost taboo status, and majoring on ensuring that, whether by promotional material, educational resources or corporate ethos, all customers are made fully aware that the agency model is the shining light and a bastion of good business practice.

The pondering was brought to a shuddering halt today at the FXIC Forex industry conference in Shanghai, China, by a senior executive of one of the world’s most conservative and technologically advanced firms – OANDA Corporation’s CEO for the Asia Pacific region, Rajesh Yohannan.

Mr. Yohannan, during a ‘fireside chat’ with Shift Forex Chief Operations Officer Matthew Miller, explained “I am certain that no actual retail traders are interested in whether a firm uses STP (straight-through processing) methods to execute orders. We concentrate on that, along with other parts of the execution process, far too much because we are on the inside.”

“Industry executives such as brokers and liquidity providers are concentrating on the way that a trade is executed, including how low the latency is, often spending huge resources on increasing execution speed, and how the liquidity is aggregated” he said.

“These factors are important to brokerages, but are of very little consequences to retail traders” said Mr. Yohannan.

What do traders want, and what is transparency to them?

Mr. Yohannan, quite correctly, stated that “Traders care about other aspects such as whether their funds are safe with the broker that they have chosen, and whether the trading environment works and executes their orders efficiently.”

“We are one of the most conservative companies in the business and err on the side of caution with regard to risk management, and customers are interested in aspects such as this because if a retail trader with a relatively small deposit is being given a high leverage account and no recourse, then it is likely that he will not trade, whereas he would be likely to be confident and trade for a long period of time with a broker which offered security of funds, a good user interface and customer experience.” – Rajesh Yohannan, CEO, Asia Pacific, OANDA Corporation

The particular discussion was part of a very detailed dialog between Mr. Miller and Mr. Yohannan, Mr. Miller having concurred that many firms coming to Shift Forex for consultation have raised this point.

Indeed, it is worth of note that many experienced retail traders are well aware that a b-book execution model in which the broker takes a proportion (or perhaps most) of the risk is actually no bad thing at all, as long as the pricing is correct and that there are no attempts to act against the trader’s best interests.

Mr. Yohannan concluded that for most retail traders, a correct price is very important, as is the stability of the broker in terms of capitalization along with the aforementioned matters with regard to custody of funds and trading environment, and that these matters will always take precedence in the mind of the retail trader over the internal structure of the firm’s methodology.

Photograph: Matthew Miller, COO of Shift Forex finds out what traders really want, with Rajesh Yohannan, CEO, APAC at OANDA Corporation. Copyright Andrew Saks-McLeod

Read this next

Digital Assets

Kraken exits Middle East, closes UAE office

Digital currency exchange Kraken will close down its operations in Abu Dhabi, UAE and lay off the majority of its team focused on the Middle East and North Africa.

Industry News

CFTC comments on ION Cleared Derivatives issues after Russian-linked hack

“The ongoing issue is impacting some clearing members’ ability to provide the CFTC with timely and accurate data. As this incident unfolded, it became clear that the submission of data that is required by registrants will be delayed until the trading issues are resolved.”

Industry News

FCA took down 14 times more misleading ads in 2022 thanks to technology

The FCA has made significant improvements to the digital tools it uses to find problem firms and misleading adverts. These improvements have enabled it to work through a much larger number of cases compared with 2021.

Executive Moves

HKEX appoints ex-Goldman Sachs Matthew Cheong to lead platform’s focus on derivatives

“He has worked for a number of the world’s leading investment banks and his experience will be invaluable to HKEX as we continue to enhance our derivatives product offerings and build on our innovative and robust platform business, connecting capital with opportunities.”

Digital Assets

Zodia Custody and SBI Digital Asset Holdings launch JV for crypto asset custodian in Japan

“Zodia Custody is both proud and excited to be working with SBI DAH to help set up SBI Zodia Custody; the first tier 1 crypto asset custodian for institutions in Japan.”

Digital Assets

Paxos opens R&D center in Israel to focus on transaction signing and crypto custody security

“Paxos is looking to expand its team in Israel in 2023 and beyond, giving engineers the opportunity to work on cutting-edge financial products and shape the future of the global economy.”

Executive Moves

Stash appoints Liza Landsman as CEO to further grow investing app

Stash is an investing and banking app with over 2 million active subscribers. Its subscription plans start at just $3 a month, and offer a range of products including investing, banking, education, and advice.

Institutional FX

Invast Global ramps up its offering with 10 soft commodity CFDs

Sydney-based prime-of-prime provider Invast Global has expanded its offering with the addition of ten soft commodity CFDs, which increases their index and commodity CFD offering to 35 instruments.

Retail FX

FF Simple and Smart Trades says Goodbye to CySEC authorization

The Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC) confirmed that it has wholly withdrawn the Cyprus Investment Firm (CIF) licenses of FF Simple and Smart Trades Investment Services Ltd.

<