DOJ lashes back at ex-Deutsche Bank traders requests for acquittal in LIBOR manipulation case

Maria Nikolova

The US Government argues that Matthew Connolly’s and Gavin Campbell Black’s motions for a judgment of acquittal or a new trial fail to identify any genuine gaps in the proof at trial.

About two months after former Deutsche Bank traders Matthew Connolly and Gavin Campbell Black, found guilty of rigging LIBOR, moved for acquittal or a new trial, the Department of Justice (DOJ) has responded to these claims.

In a set of documents filed on Monday, February 4, 2019, with the New York Southern District Court, the US Government seeks to prove that the defendants’ latest motions fail to raise any issue that warrants acquittal or a new trial. The defendants’ motions should be denied, the US authorities insist.

The DOJ explains that the jury heard more than enough evidence to find all elements of the crimes alleged against Black and Connolly beyond a reasonable doubt. The co-conspirators’ testimony also established that the defendants participated in the scheme, the DOJ says. Mr King (one of the co-conspirators), for example, described how he received requests from Gavin Black and Matthew Connolly to change Deutsche Bank’s LIBOR submissions to suit its trading positions.

Here are a couple of examples:

  • Bloomberg chat with Gurjit Dehl, in which Mr. Black asked “can we have a high 6mth libor today pls gezzer?”
  • Bloomberg chat with Mr. King, in which Mr. Black asked “COULD WE PLEASE HAVE A LOW 6MTH FIX TODAY OLD BEAN?”.

Furthermore, the DOJ argues against the defendants’ assertion about there having been a “reasonable range” within which LIBOR submitters were free to select their submissions with reference to their banks’ trading positions. The DOJ stresses that the evidence at trial did not establish such a range ever existed. According to the Government, the defendants forcefully made that argument at trial, but the jury rejected it. Mr. King, Mr. Curtler, and Mr. Parietti (the co-conspirators) all testified, not only was that not their understanding, but they had never heard the concept of a “reasonable range” until after the investigation began.

The argument about the alleged widespread practice of LIBOR manipulation at Deutsche Bank was also attacked by the DOJ. The US authorities said that “even if supervisors directed or encouraged the fraud, that is not a defense to illegal conduct.

The “I was following orders” excuse is not equivalent to a good faith defense”, DOJ says.

Also, the defendants’ attempt to shift the blame to Deutsche Bank’s training and the prevalence of the fraudulent conduct should likewise be rejected, according to the US Government. That the defendants were not specifically trained not to manipulate LIBOR is seen not to negate their fraudulent intent.

Connolly was Deutsche Bank’s director of the Pool Trading Desk in New York, where he supervised traders who traded USD LIBOR-based derivative products. Black was a director on Deutsche Bank’s Money Market and Derivatives Desk in London, who also traded USD LIBOR-based derivative products.

In October 2018, a jury convicted Connolly and Black for their participation in a scheme to manipulate the London Interbank Offered Rate (LIBOR).

Read this next

Executive Moves

Scope Markets promotes James Hughes to head of marketing

Belize-based FX and CFDs brokerage Scope Markets has promoted James Hughes, who until recently was its head of brand, to take on an expanded role as the company’s global head of marketing.

Retail FX

Fraudsters clone Financial Commission’s website, two ex-members under suspicion

The Financial Commission, an industry-specific dispute resolution service that caters to the financial services industry, today announced that it believes a clone website has been impersonating its membership roster.

Retail FX

CMC Markets warns of operational challenges in Q1

CMC Markets PLC (LSE:CMCX) said in a trading update for the fiscal year 2023 that February and March posed a more challenging environment with lower equity volumes and a higher proportion of lower margin institutional trading activity.


Why Is Digital PR So Important for Financial Service Providers? Buzz Dealer’s CEO Uri Samet with the Answers

Digital PR is all about spreading your message faster, wider, and stronger in the online world, through proper SEO, link-building, and organic and paid social media work.

Inside View

Why And How Are Virtual Cards Disrupting The Finance Industry

Virtual cards have the potential to revolutionize the finance industry by providing faster and more secure payments, wider acceptance, and eco-friendliness.


Sweat Economy’s Oleg Fomenko on upcoming launch of Move-to-Earn app in the US

With the crypto winter’s biggest hurdles seemingly behind us as the prices of Bitcoin et al. climb the charts again, the Web3 economy is preparing for the next phase.

Industry News

OptionMetrics acquires Woodseer to add dividend forecast data for equities

“The addition of Woodseer’s product suite will enhance our ability to serve financial market stakeholders and academic institutions in their analysis of equity market performance and risk.”

Digital Assets

Metacade raises over $14.7M as presale set to close in 72 hours

Metacade, one of the most exciting GameFi ventures of 2023, has now raised over $14.7m as the presale goes into its final hours. With over 90% sold, the project expects to sell out ahead of their scheduled closing time, set for Friday 31st March at 23:59 Pacific Time. 

Digital Assets

Coinme launches Circle’s USDC on Stellar network

“By enabling USDC on Stellar in the Coinme wallet, anyone with cash can now utilize the Stellar blockchain to access a fully-backed dollar digital currency. People can now swap their cash for USDC on Stellar and send it in seconds for the cost of a penny.”