FCA quantifies impact of CFD offering restrictions on brokerage profits

Maria Nikolova

The profit reduction for firms offering CFDs to retail clients is c. £38.5 million and £55.3 million.

The UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) today published an impact assessment regarding the regulations that restrict the offering of contracts for difference (CFDs) to retail clients.

The rules, inter alia, limit leverage to between 30:1 and 2:1 depending on the volatility of the underlying asset, envisage a close-out of a customer’s protection when their funds fall to 50% of the margin needed to maintain their open positions on their CFD account, and provide protections that guarantee a client cannot lose more than the total funds in their trading account. The restrictions introduced by the FCA go further than ESMA’s by applying to a wider range of products by including CFD-like options, and limiting leverage for CFDs referencing certain government bonds to 30:1 (compared with 5:1 under ESMA’s measures).

As per the document made public today, the FCA assessed the impact of CFD leverage limits on firm’s profits by reviewing the earnings and revenue estimates from sell-side analysts for two UK based CFD firms before and after the implementation of ESMA’s temporary measures (these firms do not offer CFD-like options and are not impacted by those restrictions). The FCA used this information because it was the only publicly available information to assess expected impact on firms’ due to loss of profits.

The UK regulator believes that information from these firms is representative of the UK CFD market because they represent 43% of the UK CFD market based on client money. Moreover, the firms differ in their platforms, product offerings and business models, so that a range of products and business models is covered. However, the FCA recognises that this data may lead to an over-estimation because firms may offset declining profits by reducing costs, such as marketing costs and variable remuneration, and some firms are expanding to different jurisdictions unaffected by the measures.

The reduction in net income for these two firms for the financial years 2019 – 2021 is close to £17 million per year on average. This represents a 6.7% decline in net income (around 6% for the first firm and 10% for the second).

Business feedback also suggested that the FCA restrictions on CFD-like options will cause disruption to one firm’s business. Although the regulator requested this information, these firms did not provide an estimation of costs.

Since firms’ business models differ, scaling up this loss of net revenue for the whole market will not yield a precise estimate of CFD firms’ total loss of profit. In light of this, the FCA calculated lower and upper bounds for the estimates for the remaining CFD firms based on the expected decline in net income of 6% and 10% for these two firms. The corresponding reduction for all firms is therefore approximately £38.5 million and £55.3 million.

Scaling up the losses based on trading volumes to account for losses on CFD-like options leaves these figures unchanged because of the low retail trading volumes of CFD-like options.

Read this next

Crypto Insider

Gate.io lists DeFiChain’s DFI token amid growing popularity

Bitcoin-based DeFi platform DeFiChain announced the listing of its native DFI token on Gate.io, one of the world’s leading cryptocurrency exchanges.

Digital Assets

Binance in discussions with Japan regulators to relaunch operations

Binance, the world’s largest crypto exchange by traded volume, is reportedly seeking a license to operate in Japan after its exit from the country four years ago.

Digital Assets

OKX Chain integrates .crypto domains to simplify wallet transactions

Unstoppable Domains, a company building Blockchain domain names, has entered a partnership with EVM and IBC compatible chain OKC (OKX Chain). This collaboration will grant OKC’s users the ability to simplify deposits and withdrawals within the regulated fiat-focused crypto-asset exchange.

Retail FX, Technology

MetaTrader’s iOS issue opens brokers’ eyes to other trading platforms

In a surprising (or-not-so-surprising) move, Apple has removed MetaTrader 4 and MetaTrader 5 from its App Store in a huge blow for the leading FX trading platform provider.

Retail FX

Pepperstone adds Capitalise.ai analytics and automated trading tools free of charge

“We look forward to bringing significant value to Pepperstone traders and making a real, positive impact in their daily trading habits. We are excited to welcome them on board.”

Retail FX

FP Markets wins Best Global Value Broker for 4th consecutive year at the 2022 Global Forex Awards

“We greatly appreciate the continued international recognition as at FP Markets we pride ourselves on these attributes and these prestigious awards are testament to the hard work from our global team to always provide our clients with the ultimate trading experience.”

Inside View

How to Engage Your Customer at Every Stage of Their Journey

As many as 89% of successful businesses say that providing assistive customer experiences is critical to their growth. That’s because a mere 5% increase in customer retention can boost profits by 25% to 95%.

Industry News

CFTC fines Chinese firms Chinatex and COFCO $720,000 for wash trading

Chinatex traders engaged in wash trading in order to liquidate a long position in the account of an affiliated company and re-establish the position in its own account, to the ultimate benefit of its parent company, COFCO.

Industry News

US-based operation of Brazilian broker XP fined $500,000 for recordkeeping failures

“Proper recordkeeping is vital to protecting our markets and market participants from fraud and manipulation. This case serves as another example of the Commission’s intent to vigorously enforce the recordkeeping obligations of its registrants.”

<