France goes increasingly concerned over social trading risks

Maria Nikolova

French consumer organizations and legal experts get increasingly confused on how social trading is supposed to be less risky than self-directed trading.

A traditional promise made by social trading networks is that newbies can count on the professionalism of signal providers or lead traders as a safer way to enter the online trading world than by relying on their own trading skills. Claims of certain amounts of gains have often accompanied this traditional promise.

French consumer organizations and legal experts, however, have been increasingly expressing their confusion as to how social trading is supposed to be less risky than the traditional self-directed type of trading. Online magazine Capital quotes Matthieu Robin, of France’s consumer association UFC-Que choisir, who says that the risk associated with social trading is not lower than the risk associated with traditional trading. Mr Robin does not see how the social trading system is excluded from the disastrous statistics for the retail FX sector.

According to numbers provided by France’s regulator AMF, nine out of ten retail FX traders lose money, with the average loss being at EUR 10,900. Data from the Paris Public Prosecutor’s Office, show that losses associated with trading of high-risk products like FX and binary options have topped EUR 4 billion over the last six years.

The report notes that the bigger problems stem from the operations of social networks that are either not regulated or have multi-layer structure of various entities responsible for various operations. Consumer advocate Catherine Lam warns that it is often impossible to know which company is actually responsible for the social trading service, as there is one company that has its name on the platform, another, whose name is mentioned in the T&Cs, a third – receiving the payment, a fourth is in charge of the order execution, etc.

The concerns associated with incorrect companies who provide self-directed trading services are relevant for the world of social trading too.

France has early this year seen the implementation of the Sapin 2 law, which prohibits the advertising of high-risk financial trading instruments like binary options and high-leverage FX and CFDs. Many companies have, however, refused to comply with the ban and continue to market their services to French clientele.

Talking of social trading regulation in Europe, we should note, of course, the MiFID II regulations that are set to come into force in January 2018. The new rules, inter alia, cover social trading networks. As firms continue to offer social trading and copy trading services, albeit on a much lesser scale than just a few years ago, the UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has allowed trading volume to be generated via the automatic execution of trades to continue thus far, however as the January implementation of MiFID II approaches, the requirement to register as an investment manager with the relevant competent authority will be enforced.

This means that all companies offering such a service will have to make sure that every lead trader passes portfolio management examinations and registers as an investment adviser.

Read this next

Retail FX

Traders Union Names RoboForex the Best Forex Broker of 2023

In a recent update, Traders Union has unveiled its highly anticipated ranking of the Best Forex Brokers for 2023, continuing its tradition of providing valuable information to traders.


Stagflation Speculation: Is the UK Economy Heading for Uncharted Waters?

Amid rising concerns about a potential recession, the term “stagflation” is increasingly being used to describe the UK’s current economic scenario, characterized by conflicting indicators such as high inflation and stagnant growth.

Industry News

Exness Becomes Titanium Sponsor for 6th Annual Forex Expo in Dubai.

Multi-asset broker Exness has been named the Titanium Sponsor for the 6th edition of the Forex Expo in Dubai, further cementing its role as a key player and supporter in the trading industry.

Digital Assets

Mt. Gox victims to wait another year for repayments

Nobuaki Kobayashi, the trustee responsible for managing the assets of the now-defunct Mt. Gox Bitcoin exchange, has announced an extension of the deadline for repaying the exchange’s creditors.


Sumsub launches Non-Document Verification in the UK: Client onboarding in 5 seconds

Sumsub’s partnership with OneID introduces Non-Document Verification, enabling near-instant identity verification through official bank records while ensuring compliance with UK regulations.

Industry News

CFTC fines Advantage Futures $395,000 for 12.8 million unmonitored trades

Collectively, these failures by Advantage resulted in over 12.8 million cleared contracts not being processed or surveilled from July 2018 to June 2022. This accounts for nearly 1.5% of the trading volume by Advantage’s customers during that four-year period.

Industry News

SEC doubles down on fund names rule: “Growth”, “Value”, “ESG” better watch out

“As the fund industry has developed over the last two decades, gaps in the current Names Rule may undermine investor protection. Today’s final rules will help ensure that a fund’s portfolio aligns with a fund’s name. Such truth in advertising promotes fund integrity on behalf of fund investors.”

Industry News

ASIC sues crypto exchange Kraken over alleged margin trading product violations

“These proceedings should send a message to the crypto industry that products will continue to be scrutinised by ASIC to ensure they comply with regulatory obligations in order to protect consumers. ASIC’s action should be a reminder of the importance to comply with the design and distribution obligations so that financial products are distributed to consumers appropriately.”

Industry News

ASIC grants 332 new AFS licenses in 2023 (YoY)

ASIC’s annual licensing report aims to increase transparency and offer guidance to licensees, professional auditor registrants, and prospective applicants regarding ASIC’s licensing and professional registration decision-making processes.