“FX Cartel” traders request declaration of mistrial due to prejudicial testimony

Maria Nikolova

Defendants’ counsel says the testimony of the Government’s star witness Matthew Gardiner is highly prejudicial.

As the trial of Richard Usher, Rohan Ramchandani, and Christopher Ashton, the former Forex traders also known as “FX Cartel” or “FX Mafia” progresses at the New York Southern District Court, the tensions are on the rise, especially due to the testimony of the Government’s chief cooperating witness Matthew Gardiner.

On Wednesday, October 17th, the counsel for the defendants filed a Letter with the Court, requesting the declaration of a mistrial.

The Letter explains that the government has elicited from Gardiner testimony regarding:

  • (a) employment actions taken against individuals; and
  • (b) an enforcement action that the Federal Reserve Board (FRB) took against Gardiner several years after the end of the charged conspiracy.

According to the defense, these lines of testimony contravene Federal Rules of Evidence 403, the rules against hearsay, the Confrontation Clause, and the rule against impermissible lay opinion testimony.

“Unfortunately, with this highly prejudicial line of questioning, the government has created irreparable prejudice that necessitates the declaration of a mistrial”, the defense argues.

During his cross-examination, Gardiner testified that the types of information-sharing about which he spoke on direct were “prevalent” in the FX market. The government elicited from him that three of the individuals about whom he had testified on cross-examination, in addition to the defendants, had been fired by their employers as a result of internal investigations conducted by their banks. The government elicited further that the number of traders who were fired or suspended around that time “went sort of north of 50/55.”

Following that, the government elicited testimony that the FRB imposed on Mr. Gardiner, by consent decree, “a lifetime ban based upon his conduct with the defendants.”

The defense finds this testimony as problematic because it is seen to suggest to the jury that large banks, as well as the FRB, have already deemed certain relevant conduct impermissible. However, these entities are not the finders of fact. They did not implement the applicable law, procedures, or standard of proof that govern this trial. Their views should play no role in the jury’s deliberations, the defense argues.

Moreover, the defense notes that the adverse actions discussed in the redirect testimony occurred years after the conduct at issue in the instant case and reflect after-the-fact judgments of the FRB and various banks regarding certain practices. These actions are said to have no bearing on the defendants’ contemporaneous intentions and perceptions during the time period relevant to the charges.

The redirect testimony inflicts unfair prejudice that no curative instruction could cure, the defendants argue. Forgetting and disregarding this testimony would require jurors to perform ‘mental acrobatics.’ That is why, a mistrial is necessary.

Should the Court decline the defendants’ application for a mistrial, however, the defendants respectfully request that the Court: (a) strike the redirect testimony from the record; and (b) instruct the jury: (i) that no euro-dollar traders have been charged with antitrust offenses in the United States; (ii) that employment-related and administrative actions are entirely different from criminal liability; and (iii) that the jury may not consider any evidence of such actions in its deliberations.

The case is captioned USA v. Usher et al (1:17-cr-00019).

Read this next

Retail FX

Investors from Cyprus and Dubai acquire ‘significant stake’ in M4Markets

Seychelles-regulated brokerage firm M4Markets firm has picked up some investment from Cyprus and Dubai based investors in a new funding round that it will be using to grow its business.

Executive Moves

UAE broker Amana elevates Amr Masry to sales director

Amr Masry has been promoted to a new senior role at Amana Capital, becoming the group’s newest Sales Director, following a successful tenure with the UAE-based FX and CFDs broker.

Executive Moves

TopFX promotes Omar Al-Janabi to head of sales and business development

Prime brokerage firm TopFX has strengthened its Middle East operations with the promotion of Omar Al-Janabi, who is taking on an expanded role as global head of sales and business development.

Retail FX

Plus500 says 2022 revenue to be ‘significantly’ ahead of analysts’ estimates

Israeli-based, but London-stock market listed Plus500 said it expects annual revenue and earnings to be ahead of analysts’ estimates even as trading levels normalised from record volumes in the first quarter.

Digital Assets

Crypto derivatives giant BitMEX launches spot market

Crypto exchange BitMEX is looking to branch out of its singular focus on crypto derivatives with a suite of new product offerings. Although derivatives are to remain at the heart of BitMEX’s business, the popular platform will add spot crypto trading as it aims to aggressively grow their user base.


PrimeXM reports mixed trading volumes for April

PrimeXM has reported weaker trading volumes for April 2022, in line with other institutional and retail platforms that saw the activity of their clients dropped compared to a month earlier.

Digital Assets

DLT Finance approved by BaFin to support brokerage and custody of digital assets

DLT Finance is already partnered with big names within the digital asset space, including Kraken, Bitstamp, B2C2, and Bittrex.

Institutional FX

LUKB taps vestr to launch actively managed products, AMCs

The partnership with vestr goes to show the growing importance of digitising the active investment management space.

Digital Assets

Jewel taps Tokeny to launch stablecoin-as-a-service solution on Polygon

Jewel aims to offer a stablecoin-as-a-service solution to other digital asset and financial institutions B2B, allowing those businesses to provide cheaper, easier and near real time payments with stablecoins issued and redeemable directly at the bank level at Jewel.