Plaintiffs in Forex benchmark rate fixing lawsuit seek to support their claims

Maria Nikolova

The plaintiffs in a case targeting some of the world’s major banks seek to prove that the amendments they want to make to their complaint are not futile.

As FinanceFeeds has earlier reported, Judge Lorna G. Schofield of the New York Southern District Court has instructed the plaintiffs in a Forex benchmark fixing case to file a letter providing details about the amendments they want to make to their complaint against some of the world’s major banks. These amendments concern the definition of “foreign currency retail transactions”.

According to the plaintiffs, “foreign currency retail transactions” should include transactions other than those involving foreign currency purchased with USD and physically received at the defendant banks’ retail branches within the United States, including credit and debit card transactions and ATM cash withdrawals abroad.

Let’s recall that this lawsuit was brought by Go Everywhere, Inc., Valarie Jolly, Mad Travel, Inc., Lisa McCarthy, John Nypl, and William Rubinsohn. The list of defendants includes JPMorgan Chase & Co. (NYSE:JPM), JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A., Barclays Capital, Inc., Citibank, N.A., Citigroup Inc (NYSE:C), Bank of America Corp (NYSE:BAC), Bank of America, N.A, HSBC Bank USA, N.A., and HSBC North America Holdings, Inc. A putative class of consumers and end-user businesses allege that they paid inflated Forex rates caused by an alleged conspiracy among the defendant banks to fix prices of FX benchmark rates in violation of Section 1 of the Sherman Antitrust Act, 15 U.S.C. sec. 1 et seq.

On Tuesday, January 29, 2019, the plaintiffs filed a Letter with the Court aiming to support their claims against the banks. The plaintiffs insist that the proposed amendments are not futile.

First, the plaintiffs note that the defendants’ core conduct alleged in the original complaint is the banks’ conspiracy in restraint of trade to manipulate benchmark FX rates resulting in overcharges in plaintiffs’ purchases of foreign currency. The proposed amendments relate to overcharges in purchases of foreign currency with credit, debit, ATM cards and wire, that arose from the conspiracy alleged in the original complaint.

In addition, the plaintiffs argue that the proposed amendments plausibly allege that there is a strong, arithmetic and mechanical correlation between credit, debit and ATM exchange rates, which move in near-perfect correlation with FX benchmark rates, and because FX benchmarks constitute the predominant component of FX credit, debit and ATM exchange rates, a direct link connects the alleged anticompetitive conduct and the plaintiffs’ injury.

According to the plaintiffs, this claim is supported by the declaration of Carl Saba, in which Mr. Saba concluded as follows:

“My analysis leads me to conclude that over the 144 days analyzed, there appears to be a strong correlation between the ECB Fix Rate for the EUR / USD currency pair, and the base exchange rates quoted by Visa and Mastercard to End-users (before addition of transaction fees). For the large majority of days, the variance between the End-user rates and the ECB Fix Rate is less than 1%”.

Furthermore, the proposed amendments allege that the plaintiffs made direct purchases of foreign currency from Defendant banks with their credit, debit and ATM cards issued by Defendant banks and wire. As alleged, plaintiffs’ cash, check, credit, debit, ATM and wire accounts are located at the defendant banks and, as alleged, the plaintiffs make their direct purchases of foreign currency directly from their accounts at defendant banks with those various modes of purchase.

Finally, the plaintiffs stress that the unlawful agreement is the banks’ conspiracy to restrain trade to which the defendants pleaded guilty, resulting in overcharges to the plaintiffs. The proposed amendments merely allege further modes of overpayment for foreign currency by credit cards, debit cards, ATM cards and wire resulting in direct injury to the plaintiffs in their card purchases of foreign currency from the defendants at exchange rates alleged to be arithmetically and mechanically correlated with FX benchmark rates.

According to the plaintiffs, FX benchmarks constitute the predominant component of FX credit, debit and ATM exchange rates, hence their is a direct link between the plaintiffs’ injury and the banks’ anticompetitive conduct.

Read this next

Executive Moves

Scope Markets promotes James Hughes to head of marketing

Belize-based FX and CFDs brokerage Scope Markets has promoted James Hughes, who until recently was its head of brand, to take on an expanded role as the company’s global head of marketing.

Retail FX

Fraudsters clone Financial Commission’s website, two ex-members under suspicion

The Financial Commission, an industry-specific dispute resolution service that caters to the financial services industry, today announced that it believes a clone website has been impersonating its membership roster.

Retail FX

CMC Markets warns of operational challenges in Q1

CMC Markets PLC (LSE:CMCX) said in a trading update for the fiscal year 2023 that February and March posed a more challenging environment with lower equity volumes and a higher proportion of lower margin institutional trading activity.


Why Is Digital PR So Important for Financial Service Providers? Buzz Dealer’s CEO Uri Samet with the Answers

Digital PR is all about spreading your message faster, wider, and stronger in the online world, through proper SEO, link-building, and organic and paid social media work.

Inside View

Why And How Are Virtual Cards Disrupting The Finance Industry

Virtual cards have the potential to revolutionize the finance industry by providing faster and more secure payments, wider acceptance, and eco-friendliness.


Sweat Economy’s Oleg Fomenko on upcoming launch of Move-to-Earn app in the US

With the crypto winter’s biggest hurdles seemingly behind us as the prices of Bitcoin et al. climb the charts again, the Web3 economy is preparing for the next phase.

Industry News

OptionMetrics acquires Woodseer to add dividend forecast data for equities

“The addition of Woodseer’s product suite will enhance our ability to serve financial market stakeholders and academic institutions in their analysis of equity market performance and risk.”

Digital Assets

Metacade raises over $14.7M as presale set to close in 72 hours

Metacade, one of the most exciting GameFi ventures of 2023, has now raised over $14.7m as the presale goes into its final hours. With over 90% sold, the project expects to sell out ahead of their scheduled closing time, set for Friday 31st March at 23:59 Pacific Time. 

Digital Assets

Coinme launches Circle’s USDC on Stellar network

“By enabling USDC on Stellar in the Coinme wallet, anyone with cash can now utilize the Stellar blockchain to access a fully-backed dollar digital currency. People can now swap their cash for USDC on Stellar and send it in seconds for the cost of a penny.”