Ripple funds Rutgers Law School to reform crypto regulation

Rick Steves

Of the 23 major financial market jurisdictions, nine of them haven’t taken any form of enforcement action against crypto-related companies, and the remaining jurisdictions have a more lenient approach compared to the SEC in a deliberate strategy to appeal to fintech startups.

As the battle between Ripple and the Securities and Exchanges Commission (SEC) intensifies, Ripple Labs has published a blog post pointing to recent research by Yuliya Guseva of Rutgers Law School and her colleague Douglas S. Eakeley, which found the SEC has a higher rate of intervention in blockchain-related cases.

The SEC “brings more enforcement actions against digital-asset issuers, broker-dealers, exchanges, and other crypto-market participants than do regulators in most other major jurisdictions combined”, the paper states.

Acknowledging that the size of the U.S. cryptocurrency market is a contributing factor to the SEC’s high rate of intervention, Prof. Guseva believes the use of the Howey test is a key factor for the SEC action.

The test has been used for more than 70 years to determine whether a transaction should be classified as an investment contract and therefore registered as a security.

The research paper argues that the Howie test is no longer suitable for judging 21st-century innovations as it found that the SEC has departed from its previously clear policy of prosecuting crypto-fraud and protecting investors. It cited Kik, Telegram, and Ripple as examples.

“I am worried about the dynamic inconsistencies in the recent SEC enforcement actions. Together with the broad reach of the Howey test, the inconsistencies in enforcement may exacerbate uncertainty and fail to provide market participants with a clear ex ante understanding of the securities laws”, said Prof. Guseva.

Of the 23 major financial market jurisdictions, nine of them haven’t taken any form of enforcement action against crypto-related companies, and the remaining jurisdictions have a more lenient approach compared to the SEC in a deliberate strategy to appeal to fintech startups.

 

“[If] the SEC can no longer provide clarity through strategic predictability of a transparent enforcement approach, and if the market finds substantial inconsistencies in the regulator’s moves and strategic commitments, the fabric of cooperation between the innovators and the regulator can be undermined”.

This may lead to firms being less inclined to comprehensively comply with U.S. securities law or seek cooperation with the SEC. So, the SEC should be mindful of its enforcement policies involving fraud or cases concerning opaque regulatory issues.

In the case of digital assets, which can have different utilities or a limited application, a functional approach where one looks at the actual uses and applications of a digital asset may be more appropriate, the paper argues, adding that “law schools have become crucial hubs for debating policies and suggesting doctrinal and regulatory solutions to the industry, the regulators, and other stakeholders”.

Ripple’s University Blockchain Research Initiative (UBRI) is funding the Fintech and Blockchain Collaboratory by Rutgers Center for Corporate Law and Governance headed by Prof. Guseva. The organization gathers academics, regulators, and lawyers to discuss the latest policy issues in fintech and crypto, and most of all, contribute to reform the space.

In just the last 18 months, the U.S. regulator ordered Telegram to stop selling its cryptocurrency, fined Kik Interactive $5 million over issues with its Kin token, and is currently suing Ripple.

The lawsuit against Ripple alleges they aided and abetted Ripple’s unregistered sales of securities, dating as far back as 2013 and 2015 respectively.

In its answer, Ripple stated it had “never offered or sold XRP as an investment” and that “XRP holders do not acquire any claim to the assets of Ripple, hold any ownership interest in Ripple, or have any entitlement to share in Ripple’s future profits.”

In addition, the cryptocurrency firm argued that “utility depends on XRP’s near-instantaneous and seamless settlement in low-cost transactions. Treating XRP as a security, by contrast, would subject thousands of exchanges, market-makers, and other actors in the gigantic virtual currency market to lengthy, complex, and costly regulatory requirements.”

 

Read this next

Digital Assets

Binance US weighs plans to go public, CEO CZ says

Binance.US, the American outpost of the world’s biggest crypto exchange, has seemingly plans to follow Coinbase’s path and go public one day.

Retail FX

FX volumes, number of active clients boom at Exness in June 2021

The latest group of retail FX platforms to report their monthly volumes indicate that June was a busier month all round, with Exness setting its second-highest monthly volumes on record.

Industry News

Individuals impersonating CySEC representatives draw warning from Cyprus watchdog

The Cyprus financial watchdog said on Friday there was evidence of fraudulent impersonation of its officials who are engaged with firms under CySEC’s supervision.

Digital Assets, Inside View

SEC v. Ripple angers XRP holders as rival Stellar (XLM) mixed in “love triangle” over MoneyGram

“Although the SEC claims that all XRP are unregistered securities and Brad Garlinghouse and Chris Larsen unjustly enriched themselves, it allows Ripple Co-founder JedMcCaleb to sell his XRP for hundreds of millions of dollars to possibly buy MoneyGram. Makes perfect sense”, said XRP Holders’ attorney John Denton ironically.

Industry News

Monex loses second appeal in CFTC anti-fraud enforcement action

Since Dodd-Frank that such trading must be conducted on a regulated exchange, and that the offeror must be registered with the CFTC.

Technology

Profile Software announces automated custody platform and mobile tech

The upgraded version of Axia Custody offers advanced functionality for multi-custodian operations across borders for a competitive multi-channel international-level client experience.

Industry News, Institutional FX

IHS Markit to pay CME Group $113m amid EU approval of post-trade JV

IHS Markik, at the same time, is being acquired by S&P Global Inc for $44 billion in stock, subject to approval as well.

Digital Assets

India’s Central Bank working towards implemention of digital currency

The Deputy Governor of the Reserve Bank of India, T Rabi Sankar, has said that the central bank was working towards a phased implementation of a central bank digital currency and is in the process of introducing it for wholesale and retail segments shortly.

Industry News

Visa acquires Currencycloud to facilitate global funds movement

Visa has announced the acquisition of Currencycloud, which provides APIs which help institutions with remittance and currency exchange capabilities in a deal that is valued at $963 million.