Ripple scores decisive win in XRP lawsuit

Rick Steves

It remains to be seen whether the SEC will make a new attempt to avoid producing the documents, but the court seems increasingly unwilling to hear them out.

New York court Judge Sarah Netburn has denied the SEC’s motion to protect Hinman’s internal notes and emails under attorney-client privilege, according to court documents.

“This argument was previously raised secondarily, with the SEC primarily asserting the deliberative process privilege. The SEC motion is denied”, the Judge ruled.

Biggest decision in XRP lawsuit is final. Right?

The fight over Hinman’s documents has been the hardest in the case so far and will likely remain that way as it is thought to be the “biggest decision” in the SEC v. Ripple lawsuit.

A number of law experts, including XRP Holders’ amici attorney John Deaton, have said that once the court issues an appeal-proof decision against the SEC in regard to its privilege claims, the plaintiff will find itself in hot water as the agency clearly does not intend to hand over the documents to Ripple.

Why? It’s been said that the SEC’s behavior suggests that these notes and email exchanges could provide enough evidence in favor of Ripple’s fourth affirmative defense, also known as the fair notice defense, and could also end the SEC’s claims that XRP is a security.

It remains to be seen if the SEC will make a new attempt to avoid producing the documents to the defendants as this is not the first time the court sides with Ripple on this matter.

Last time, the court denied the SEC’s claim that the Hinman notes and emails were protected by deliberative process privilege and made it “appeal-proof”, according to attorney John Deaton. The plaintiff, however, returned to claim attorney-client privilege.

Policy advice is not protected legal advice

“I find that the documents did not have the predominant purpose of soliciting or providing legal advice”, Judge Sarah Netburn stated. “Indeed, later at oral argument, SEC counsel suggested that the legal advice was to “educate” Hinman on the legal standards. If the predominant purpose of the agency lawyers’ comments was to inform Hinman about the law but not to advise the agency in its decision-making, it is not protected communication.”

“The law is settled that policy advice—like whether it is a good idea or a bad idea to make a particular public statement as a public figure—or communication advice—like whether a statement is on-message with the agency’s position—is not protected legal advice, even when it is offered by lawyers. Accordingly, the predominant purpose of the communications was not to provide legal advice to aid the SEC in conducting the public’s business. The documents must be produced.”

“As much as I enjoyed the legal victory (and the Judge seeing right through the SEC deceit), I was even more glad to see the excitement and happiness on crypto-Twitter, again. It’s been a while”, said Jeremy Hogan, an Orlando-based attorney that has been regularly commenting on the case.

Read this next


Groundbreaking Innovations in BlockDAG’s Keynote 2 Drive Over 1120% Increase; Toncoin & Celestia Prices Rise

Explore BlockDAG’s Keynote 2, detailing the cutting-edge technical advancements that led to a significant presale boom. Discover how these innovations have driven BlockDAG’s success, and get the latest updates on Celestia and Toncoin prices.


BlockDAG X1 Beta App Pioneers in Crypto Mining Amidst Ethereum vs Solana Rivalry and XRP Price Increase

Dive into the details of BlockDAG’s X1 beta app’s global tech presence in Shibuya, Las Vegas, and Piccadilly Circus and its pre-sale triumph during a spike in Ethereum, Solana, and XRP values.


BlockDAG Hits $50.4M with Active Dev Release & Community Engagement; Binance Coin Price Drops and JasmyCoin Rallies

Explore how BlockDAG bolsters its reputation through a steady stream of Development releases. Get insights on Binance Coin price trends and the recent Jasmy Coin rally.

Crypto Insider

5 Upcoming Crypto for 10x Gains: How $1000 Can Become $10,000

Consider a situation where a $1000 investment may grow to a whopping $10,000. Astute Bitcoin investors have experienced this as a reality rather than a fantasy.

Retail FX

Weekly Roundup: eToro links up with Elon Musk, US crackdown on Russian FX

Let’s take a look back at top stories that dominated the financial markets in our Weekly Round coverage. This week’s digest takes a deep dive into the most recent events and trends within the Forex, Fintech, and cryptocurrency.


Must-Watch Top 5 Crypto Picks for Q2 2024 Featuring BlockDAG, Toncoin, Solana and More

Dive into BlockDAG’s meteoric rise and explore other promising altcoins like Pepe, Toncoin, Solana, and Render for superior returns.

Retail FX

Clone of Admiral Markets draws FCA attention

The United Kingdom’s financial markets watchdog today unmasked another fraudulent entity, this time bringing to light a clone firm that has been posing as FCA-‎authorised brand, Admiral Markets UK Ltd.

Digital Assets

Gemini Earn users to recover $2.18 billion in crypto payouts

Cryptocurrency exchange Gemini has agreed to pay $50 million worth of digital assets to investors in its Gemini Earn program as part of a settlement with the New York Attorney General (NYAG), announced on Friday.

Fundamental Analysis, Market News, Tech and Fundamental

Global FX Market Summary: British Pound (GBP) Weakness, US Inflation, Euro, USD June 14 ,2024

British Pound weakens due to lower inflation expectations, potential policy changes from Reform Party, and broader economic concerns.