Ripple wins big due to SEC’s “major errors” at “suicide mission hearing” – Hogan analysis

Rick Steves

By wanting to have it both ways, the SEC has inadvertently put the Hinman speech back into play as “market guidance”, which puts it back into relevance as official guidance as to whether XRP is a security and back into play as to the fair notice defence. 

The SEC v. Ripple hearing this week, which saw Judge Sarah Netburn showing an increased lack of patience toward the SEC’s “inconsistent positions” over Hinman’s speech, has led to widespread commentary among the members of the public.

Among these is Jeremy Hogan, an Orlando-based attorney that has been regularly presenting his views on the XRP lawsuit and, once again, offered his analysis of the conference in a video shared on Youtube.

“That hearing didn’t go well for the SEC. We used to call those ‘suicide mission hearings’ because you were being sent to your death but it was actually much worse for the SEC than you may even imagine as some major errors were made today by them”.

A summary of the hearing can be found here.

“In trying to win a loser, the SEC might just have lost a winner”

The SEC is desperately trying not to handle the infamous Hinman emails over to Ripple, said Hogan, who added the plaintiff has already lost in the deliberative process privilege argument previously and now it is raising the attorney-client privilege argument.

However, changing positions on who or what the clients here were is definitely a problem for the SEC, as attorney Thien-Vu Hogan has pointed out in a previous analysis.

The issue with the SEC’s claim is that the plaintiff will struggle to explain who the client is as the agency has taken no less than 3 positions on whose opinion the speech was: first it was the SEC’s opinion, then it later became Hinman’s personal opinion, and now it is the division’s opinion.

That’s exactly what happened at the hearing. Judge Netburn asked the SEC counsel to “help [her] understand what legal advice Director Hinman received and for what purpose it was given. What was the legal advice for? What was he seeking that advice for?”

Another sharp question was “do you still stand by that position today that Hinman’s speech was his personal opinion?”

The Judge seemed unconvinced by the SEC’s answers and “twisted the knife a little bit more” by letting the plaintiff know that the SEC’s distancing from the speech is problematic because there must be a purpose for the SEC lawyers to give legal advice. “And if this is his personal opinion, then there’s no purpose for the legal advice.”

Jeremy Hogan then commented on the SEC’s strategy calling it a “mistake” for changing its position. “You have to stick with that.”

By wanting to have it both ways, the SEC has inadvertently put the Hinman speech back into play as “market guidance”, which puts it back into relevance as official guidance as to whether XRP is a security and back into play as to the fair notice defence.

“And in trying to win a loser, the SEC might just have lost a winner”, Mr. Hogan concluded.

Read this next


Fed Policymakers Navigate a Delicate Path Amidst Inflation and National Debt Concerns

The Federal Reserve’s monetary policy has been a subject of debate in Western markets, especially regarding its approach to interest rates.

Institutional FX

PhillipCapital extends trade surveillance partnership with Eventus

“PhillipCapital has seen first-hand how Validus can scale to meet any capacity requirements as clients grow, as well as our team’s expertise in not only our customizable technology but the market and regulatory challenges facing the industry.”

Market News

Why Yellow Metal Prices are Plummeting

Gold prices have been steadily declining after failing to surpass the resistance zone at $1,650. The current price is at its lowest point in seven months. Strong economic data from the US has triggered a meltdown in the gold market.

Industry News

Nuvei enters China following licenses in Australia, Singapore, and Hong Kong

The expansion into China represents more than just a geographic milestone for Nuvei. It also adds an essential component to the company’s comprehensive suite of alternative payment methods (APMs), which currently counts 634 different options. These APMs play a crucial role in catering to local market preferences, thereby enhancing Nuvei’s value proposition for businesses looking to penetrate new markets within the APAC region.

Institutional FX

LiquidityBook launches LBX PMS 2.0 after acquiring Messer

With this rollout, LiquidityBook aims to meet the diverse requirements of its clientele, ranging from startup hedge funds and asset managers to broker-dealers and outsourced trading desks.

Institutional FX

Celoxica enters Australia to offer low latency market data and execution services in APAC

“There is a significant opportunity to deliver fast and efficient market access to APAC financial market participants, including trading firms, brokers, exchanges, and service providers. I am eager to extend our reach in this crucial market.”

Institutional FX

Cboe to launch four new Credit Volatility Indices (Credit VIX)

“The Credit VIX Indices are expected to provide new clear signals on bond market sentiment, and act as a new barometer of corporate credit risk in North America and Europe.”

Executive Moves

TradeZero hires Leo Ciccone as Chief Compliance Officer (CCO) for TradeZero Canada

“Leo brings to TradeZero broad and comprehensive experience coupled with deep business and regulatory relationships that will assist us in ensuring we meet and exceed industry best practices and to further our growth initiatives going forward,”

Institutional FX

Apex launches fractional fixed income trading for retail investors

“The ability for people – and not just high net-worth investors – to easily add fixed-income and diversify their portfolios is a game-changer.”