Ripple wins big due to SEC’s “major errors” at “suicide mission hearing” – Hogan analysis

Rick Steves

By wanting to have it both ways, the SEC has inadvertently put the Hinman speech back into play as “market guidance”, which puts it back into relevance as official guidance as to whether XRP is a security and back into play as to the fair notice defence. 

The SEC v. Ripple hearing this week, which saw Judge Sarah Netburn showing an increased lack of patience toward the SEC’s “inconsistent positions” over Hinman’s speech, has led to widespread commentary among the members of the public.

Among these is Jeremy Hogan, an Orlando-based attorney that has been regularly presenting his views on the XRP lawsuit and, once again, offered his analysis of the conference in a video shared on Youtube.

“That hearing didn’t go well for the SEC. We used to call those ‘suicide mission hearings’ because you were being sent to your death but it was actually much worse for the SEC than you may even imagine as some major errors were made today by them”.

A summary of the hearing can be found here.

“In trying to win a loser, the SEC might just have lost a winner”

The SEC is desperately trying not to handle the infamous Hinman emails over to Ripple, said Hogan, who added the plaintiff has already lost in the deliberative process privilege argument previously and now it is raising the attorney-client privilege argument.

However, changing positions on who or what the clients here were is definitely a problem for the SEC, as attorney Thien-Vu Hogan has pointed out in a previous analysis.

The issue with the SEC’s claim is that the plaintiff will struggle to explain who the client is as the agency has taken no less than 3 positions on whose opinion the speech was: first it was the SEC’s opinion, then it later became Hinman’s personal opinion, and now it is the division’s opinion.

That’s exactly what happened at the hearing. Judge Netburn asked the SEC counsel to “help [her] understand what legal advice Director Hinman received and for what purpose it was given. What was the legal advice for? What was he seeking that advice for?”

Another sharp question was “do you still stand by that position today that Hinman’s speech was his personal opinion?”

The Judge seemed unconvinced by the SEC’s answers and “twisted the knife a little bit more” by letting the plaintiff know that the SEC’s distancing from the speech is problematic because there must be a purpose for the SEC lawyers to give legal advice. “And if this is his personal opinion, then there’s no purpose for the legal advice.”

Jeremy Hogan then commented on the SEC’s strategy calling it a “mistake” for changing its position. “You have to stick with that.”

By wanting to have it both ways, the SEC has inadvertently put the Hinman speech back into play as “market guidance”, which puts it back into relevance as official guidance as to whether XRP is a security and back into play as to the fair notice defence.

“And in trying to win a loser, the SEC might just have lost a winner”, Mr. Hogan concluded.

Read this next

Digital Assets

Wirex launches crypto loans with LTV of up to 80%

The recent market collapse hasn’t stopped Wirex from pursuing its crypto loan offering allowing users to borrow up to $100,000.

Digital Assets

Chainalysis and Cellebrite to launch integrated solution

As a result of this cooperation, examiners, investigators, analysts, and compliance officers will be able to seamlessly identify illicit cryptocurrency-related activity in a single place as part of their familiar digital investigation workflows.

Executive Moves

Gate.io hires ex-Google Tom Yang for brand building

Gate.io has appointed Tom Yang as Executive Vice President (EVP) to gradually carry out its global brand building and market development.

Digital Assets

What if Ripple loses and XRP is deemed a security?

The outcome of the Veritaseum case could provide guidance to XRP holders looking for answers about what will happen to their assets.

Executive Moves

BestEx Research taps Paul Merolla as General Counsel

He has served as General Counsel at institutional broker Instinet Group and was Associate Counsel at Goldman Sachs.

Industry News

eToro announces termination of SPAC deal amid “circumstances”

“We ended Q2 2022 with approximately 2.7 million funded accounts, an increase of over 12% versus the end of 2021, demonstrating continued customer acquisition and retention rates that have been improving over time. We remain confident in our long-term growth strategy and excited for the future of eToro.”

Digital Assets

EU crypto regulation limits privacy to 1,000-euro threshold

MiCA complements existing AML rules and aims to enhance financial stability and investor protection in Europe.

Retail FX

GKFX Prime adds MT4 and MT5

In April, GKFX launched a proprietary trading platform.

Industry News

UEZ hits the Korean market

On the 8th to 10th of June 2022, the team from UEZ Markets attended the breathtaking Smart Tech Korea 2022 expo in the wonderful city of Seoul

<