SEC v. Ripple: Judge orders controversial deposition of ex-SEC Director

Rick Steves

The deposition will take place on Monday, July 19.

Judge Sarah Netburn has ordered William Hinman, former SEC Director of Corporation Finance, to depose next Monday.

Ripple’s subpoena had found great resistance from the Securities and Exchange Commission as his deposition could be key to clarify the SEC’s policy on digital assets, despite the agency stating his speech in 2018 regarding the nature of Ethereum and Bitcoin was his personal views only.

The Judge ruled in favor of Ripple Labs as “this is not a run of the mill enforcement case by the SEC” and because SEC v. Ripple is unique and the public interest in the resolution of this case is substantial.

She also said she is “very much disinclined” to have Mr. Hinman sitting twice and admitted that the SEC will likely direct Hinman not to answer much of the questions. Still, the Judge asked both parties to work out the scope of the deposition.

During the hearing, Judge Netburn asked why the SEC said that privilege would be breached if the scheduled deposition is about a public speech based on his personal views and not on behalf of the SEC, as the agency argued.

Hinman’s 2018 ETH speech was “the central question” for the Judge. The SEC admitted that its staff participated in the drafting of the speech. Ripple’s counsel added that ex-SEC Chair Jay Clayton told Congress that speech was an example of transparency on how the agency was treating cryptocurrencies.

The SEC argued that anything Hinman ever said is privileged as “deliberative” and told the Judge the deliberative process privilege would be invoked if Hinman was deposed.

Despite the ruling going in favor of Ripple, the blockchain firm’s counsel complained that the SEC is “withholding every part of every internal memorandum” citing privilege and its position is “untenable” and “prejudicing” the defense.

Ahead of the hearing, John E. Deaton, the attorney who has previously filed a Motion to Intervene in the name of XRP holders, published an opinion piece with his line of questioning for the deposition.

Read this next

Institutional FX

BNY Mellon to leverage Baton System’s CCP network on its ECPO service

“The union of Baton’s extensive CCP connectivity with the ground-breaking functionality of BNY Mellon’s ECPO service forms a powerful offering to cleared derivatives market participants.”

Institutional FX

NYSE and Tel Aviv Stock Exchange to promote dual listings

“This major step is intended to foster collaborations between the two exchanges and to encourage the dual listing of Israeli companies in their home market and on the NYSE.”

Technology

TT’s KRM22 selected as risk technology partner of Chicago-based RCM

“Broad product coverage and effective risk analytics performance are essential to proper implementation of risk management and risk analysis.”

Industry News

DXtrade FX/ CFD Platform Integrated with Your Bourse for Turnkey Liquidity

DXtrade brokers received access to 30+ major banks and Tier 2 liquidity providers with Your Bourse.

Executive Moves

Wave hires Harumi Urata-Thompson as CFO of SEC-regulated crypto investment company

“With extensive experience leading teams across both the traditional finance and digital asset sectors, Harumi is well-equipped to provide our team with the immediate strategic insights needed to optimize our financial operations. She is a fantastic addition to our team as we continue to strengthen our position as one of the leading digital asset managers and to deliver sophisticated financial services to our clients.”

Retail FX

TRADE.com enters United States as brokerage obtains license from FINRA

“We intend to be fully operational as a brokerage house in the U.S. by the end of H1 2023 and look forward to forging long term relationships with new business partners and clients.”

Technology

Pico launches Corvil Cloud Analytics as trading industry moves into cloud

“Since Corvil Cloud Analytics is software only, this accelerates our deployments and also provides an expedited avenue for proof-of-concept use cases. It’s now easier than ever for clients to access the platform so they can see firsthand what makes Corvil an industry leader in data analytics.”

Executive Moves

Finalto recruits Antony Parsons as head of liquidity

Finalto, the financial trading division of Gopher Investments, is making a broader push into the liquidity provision space, culminating in a new appointment focused on expanding the business into new markets.

Digital Assets

Huobi introduces Tether’s stablecoins pegged to euro, gold

Huobi, the world’s sixth-largest crypto exchange by trading volume, is set to introduce for its clients two stablecoins representing ownership of physical gold and Euro-pegged tokens.

<