SEC v. Ripple: Win on Fair Notice could “save the industry from the SEC”, said top lawyer

Rick Steves

“For the most part, the SEC will not be able to bring any more crypto lawsuits if that happens, and the SEC is funded by the fines and such from these lawsuits so…read between the lines”.

The SEC v. Ripple lawsuit is holding its most important battle so far: the Fair Notice defense which argues the firm had no reasonable fair notice from the SEC on whether selling XRP would constitute an illegal securities offering.

The regulator has motioned to strike that defense and its “main argument seems to be that Ripple cannot even raise a Fair Notice defense”, said the XRP community’s ‘favorite attorney’ Jeremy Hogan.

The SEC argues that there is a case precedent that states that a Fair Notice defense cannot be raised in this exact situation, citing the Kik Interactive case held a few years ago.

“Indeed, Judge Hellerstein recently evaluated an Upton defense based on facts materially indistinguishable from those alleged by Ripple, and found the defense to fail as a matter of law”, the SEC stated.

That’s where attorney Jeremy Hogan disagrees. “Lucky for us, I have read all of the Kik Interactive pleadings and this is just not true. In fact, I just pulled it up on Courtlistener to show you”, he said in a Youtube video.

“Right there at entry #26 you can see that in the KIK Interactive case the SEC also filed a Motion to Strike the Defense, called a Motion for Judgement on the Pleadings, here. And if you go down to entry 29 you can see that the Judge denied the motion without prejudice.”

While the Judge eventually did rule against Kik, it was not “on the pleadings” but later at summary judgment. “And that’s where I also think Ripple’s Fair Notice defense will be decided. Prediction: Motion to Strike Denied”, Mr. Hogan stated.

What if Ripple wins on the Fair Notice defense?

Attorney Jeremy Hogan was clear about the legal consequences of a win on the Fair Notice defense: “It becomes persuasive authority for any crypto company the SEC sues from this point forward. If the Fair Notice defense survives and Ripple wins, the SEC is going to have an uphill battle winning any other lawsuit they bring.

“But it’s even bigger than that. . . Even if Ripple loses the Fair Notice defense, they can appeal the ruling. And if an appellate court determines that Judge Torres was wrong and Ripple did not have Fair Notice, then the SEC is now really in trouble because that ruling is binding on every crypto lawsuit that comes along.

“For the most part, the SEC will not be able to bring any more crypto lawsuits if that happens and, the SEC is funded by the fines and such from these lawsuits so…read between the lines”, he explained.

The Fair Notice defense is the one the SEC is most worried about because that could potentially save the industry from the regulator and “it’s the defense that would lead to the case settling/resolving before a hearing on Summary Judgment“.

Of course, it wouldn’t prevent the SEC from filing complaints against crypto schemes such as BitConnect. The regulator has recently filed charges against it’s promoters.

Although XRP holders have no stake in Ripple Labs, the fluctuating price of the cryptocurrency has led its owners to follow the SEC v. Ripple lawsuit intensely.

A lot has been said in the past and the final result of the lawsuit is anyone’s guess for the time being. Still, Ripple Labs is most likely analyzing its options for any settlement deal or decision by the court.

In October 2020, co-founder Chris Larsen said that the firm might be moving its headquarters overseas. “To be honest with you, we’re even looking at relocating our headquarters to a much more friendly jurisdiction.”

In early April 2021, CEO Brad Garlinghouse told CNN the firm is ready to march on without the XRP if it loses the legal battle against the US regulator.

So, to answer the question ‘What if Ripple loses the lawsuit?’: no one knows besides them, but relocating to a friendlier jurisdiction is most likely to serve the interests of XRP holders in such a scenario.

For now, we’ll have to stick to the lawsuit agenda.

Read this next

Digital Assets

Binance US weighs plans to go public, CEO CZ says

Binance.US, the American outpost of the world’s biggest crypto exchange, has seemingly plans to follow Coinbase’s path and go public one day.

Retail FX

FX volumes, number of active clients boom at Exness in June 2021

The latest group of retail FX platforms to report their monthly volumes indicate that June was a busier month all round, with Exness setting its second-highest monthly volumes on record.

Industry News

Individuals impersonating CySEC representatives draw warning from Cyprus watchdog

The Cyprus financial watchdog said on Friday there was evidence of fraudulent impersonation of its officials who are engaged with firms under CySEC’s supervision.

Digital Assets, Inside View

SEC v. Ripple angers XRP holders as rival Stellar (XLM) mixed in “love triangle” over MoneyGram

“Although the SEC claims that all XRP are unregistered securities and Brad Garlinghouse and Chris Larsen unjustly enriched themselves, it allows Ripple Co-founder JedMcCaleb to sell his XRP for hundreds of millions of dollars to possibly buy MoneyGram. Makes perfect sense”, said XRP Holders’ attorney John Denton ironically.

Industry News

Monex loses second appeal in CFTC anti-fraud enforcement action

Since Dodd-Frank that such trading must be conducted on a regulated exchange, and that the offeror must be registered with the CFTC.

Technology

Profile Software announces automated custody platform and mobile tech

The upgraded version of Axia Custody offers advanced functionality for multi-custodian operations across borders for a competitive multi-channel international-level client experience.

Industry News, Institutional FX

IHS Markit to pay CME Group $113m amid EU approval of post-trade JV

IHS Markik, at the same time, is being acquired by S&P Global Inc for $44 billion in stock, subject to approval as well.

Digital Assets

India’s Central Bank working towards implemention of digital currency

The Deputy Governor of the Reserve Bank of India, T Rabi Sankar, has said that the central bank was working towards a phased implementation of a central bank digital currency and is in the process of introducing it for wholesale and retail segments shortly.

Industry News

Visa acquires Currencycloud to facilitate global funds movement

Visa has announced the acquisition of Currencycloud, which provides APIs which help institutions with remittance and currency exchange capabilities in a deal that is valued at $963 million.