Academics advise UK Parliament against implementing general AI law

Maria Nikolova

The Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence kicked off its autumn program of public evidence sessions by talking to three academics about the ‘big picture’ issues associated with AI.

LSE earnings strong ahead of merger and ‘Brexit’

The UK Parliament has been showing its interest in the area of artificial intelligence (AI) for a while. A number of inquiries and consultations have been launched, including ones on the necessity to regulate AI  and on the use of algorithms in decision-making.

Earlier this week, the Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence started its autumn program of public evidence sessions by talking to three experts about the ‘big picture’ issues associated with AI:

  • Professor Dame Wendy Hall, Professor of Computer Science, University of Southampton, and chair of the soon to be published review into artificial intelligence on behalf of the Government;
  • Professor Nick Bostrom, Director, Future of Humanity Institute;
  • Professor Michael Wooldridge, Head of Department and Professor of Computer Science, University of Oxford.

The trio gave evidence to the Committee on Tuesday. (You can view the full recording of the session on the UK Parliament TV).

Among the many questions raised during the discussion was the question of the progress made by AI over the recent years. Professor Michael Wooldridge had to explain the difference between “general AI” and “narrow AI”, stressing that general AI has not seen much of an actual progress.

“General AI is the big dream of AI. It’s the dream that you see in Hollywood, it’s the dream of conscious machines, machines that are self-aware, that may have conversations like we are having right now. And that’s a very nebulous goal. There hasn’t been any substantial progress in general AI”, Professor Michael Wooldridge said.

“All the progress in AI over the last decade which is real and substantial and exciting has been in narrow AI, which is on very narrowly focused tasks like recognizing faces”, Professor Michael Wooldridge explained.

Considering the advances of machine learning and the building of more sophisticated computer agents, the question of the possible impact of AI on the labor market was raised.

Professor Dame Wendy Hall stressed that “As with all big technological revolutions, overall, overtime, there will be more jobs created than lost. But that does not help the people whose jobs are going to be lost in the short term – anyone whose job is repetitive and can be replaced by some form of automation. That job is likely to go in the next 10-20 years”.

Asked what should be done by the lawmakers to mitigate any negative impact by AI on the labour market, she replied:

“What we should be doing in social reform is taking the opportunity to see what are the jobs that need people to do them and value these jobs.”

This echoes the stance of a number of financial services companies that have already adopted AI solutions. For instance, the CEO of Nordnet, which has recently hired a digital employee, explained that such a move would enable the human staff to do what humans do best.

In the European Union, there has been a lot of talk around the threat that AI presents to the labor market. In February this year, the European Parliament approved a resolution on robotics, with particular concerns voiced about job losses and ethical issues such as responsibility for any law violations committed by AI agents.

The problem about ethics and the possibility to somehow regulate AI was raised during the discussion on Tuesday too. The experts agreed that the necessary codes of practice already exist in numerous areas, but broader guidelines were dubbed not necessary.

Professor Michael Wooldridge said:

“AI-specific ethical guidelines, I’m not convinced is something that is particularly necessary. Nor AI law. Looking at specific areas – the data protection legislation that we have, would make sense but a general AI law – no.”

Read this next

Institutional FX

Fortex adds GBE Prime to liquidity offering

“This collaboration enhances our liquidity distribution capabilities, offering our clients improved pricing, order execution, and risk management. We look forward to the positive impact this integration will have on our clients.”

Retail FX

Fullerton Markets Caps Off Stellar Year with Dual Triumph at Gazet International Awards 2023

Fullerton Markets, one of the fastest-growing brokerages in the Asia Pacific, has today announced its remarkable success at the prestigious Gazet International Awards 2023, where it secured two coveted accolades, reinforcing its position as a global leader in multi-asset brokerage and marketing a triumphant end to the year.

Inside View

Are brokers really ready for EMIR Refit and ESMA changes in 2024?

The EMIR Refit and ESMA reporting requirements necessitate a strategic approach from brokers, involving major updates to reporting systems, data collection processes, and internal resources. We spoke with brokers and RegTech providers to learn more about the upcoming regulatory challenges.

Digital Assets

Binance to phase out BUSD support in two weeks

Binance has announced its plans to gradually phase out support for its native stablecoin, BUSD (Binance USD) by December 15, 2023. This move comes after Paxos, the issuer of BUSD, decided to stop minting new tokens.


Binance Labs invests $3.15M in Open Campus to advance Web3 education

Binance Labs, the venture capital arm of the cryptocurrency giant Binance, has invested $3.15 million in Web3 education platform Open Campus.

Institutional FX

Brighty App unveils EU B2B payment platform amidst exploding market

Brighty App is set to launch its European B2B platform, Brighty Business, this month. This platform is geared towards improving how businesses handle their financial operations, especially in the digital banking and cryptocurrency domains.

Digital Assets

Celsius’ withdrawal process slowed by overwhelming demand

Bankrupt crypto lender Celsius is taking steps to allow certain customers to withdraw their funds. However, some users have reported difficulties in logging in to process their withdrawals, as indicated by posts on various social media platforms.

Digital Assets

Cristiano Ronaldo hit with $1 billion lawsuit over Binance NFTs

Cristiano Ronaldo, the renowned footballer, is facing a class-action lawsuit in the United States over his promotion of Binance, the world’s largest cryptocurrency exchange.

Digital Assets

Zipmex creditors offered 3.35 cents on the dollar payout

Zipmex, a Thai crypto exchange grappling with financial difficulties, has proposed a restructuring plan to repay its creditors.