Central Bank of Ireland inspection of investments firms identifies issues in selling of complex investment products

Maria Nikolova

Inspection found evidence that a number of firms are not paying sufficient attention to the requirements when selling complex investment products, instead placing undue reliance upon ‘box-ticking’ to demonstrate compliance.

The Central Bank of Ireland today published findings from its inspection of investment firms’ compliance with appropriateness test for consumers.

The European Union’s Markets in Financial Instruments Directive (MiFID II) requires firms to complete a thorough and robust assessment of a client’s knowledge and experience in order to determine whether the product or service is appropriate for that client. Investors purchasing complex products without financial advice may be exposed to significant risk, as these products often have extremely complicated structures and features that make it difficult for clients to understand the associated risks.

Firms must issue a clear warning to the client if they consider that the product is not appropriate for that client. It is critical that clients are adequately warned when products are not appropriate, thus enabling them to make informed investment decisions.

Appropriateness tests require firms to assess information on the consumer’s knowledge and experience and to determine whether a product is appropriate.

The inspection found evidence that a number of firms are not paying sufficient attention to the requirements, instead placing undue reliance upon ‘box-ticking’ to demonstrate compliance. Several firms failed to provide evidence that they are paying sufficient attention to the application of the appropriateness requirements, instead placing undue reliance upon standardised questionnaires and ‘box-ticking’ to demonstrate compliance.

In many cases, firms’ practical application of the requirements was undermined by weak processes, systems, and controls; resulting in errors and assessments proceeding with incomplete information.

Many firms are relying on a blanket approach for gathering client information that fails to consider the significant differences in risk and complexity that occurs between investment products. Firms need to improve the quality of information collected.

In many cases, it was not clear how firms reached the appropriateness decision.

The review also revealed inadequate and weak warnings issued where products were found to be inappropriate for clients, including the use of vague, ambiguous language. The appropriateness warning should not be viewed by firms as a disclaimer which overrides the legal obligations of firms to act in the best interests of the consumer.

The Central Bank is engaging directly with those firms where issues have arisen.

“The Central Bank is now engaging directly with the firms concerned to address the shortcomings that have been identified. The appropriateness test is a key component of consumer protection for people who are using the services of an investment firm, and we want to ensure these rules are being complied with in spirit as well as in law,” said Gráinne McEvoy, Director of Consumer Protection.

Read this next


Bandit Network’s Points SDK and Brave Ads Power Astar zkEVM’s Quest Platform “Yoki Origins”

“Yoki Origins,” supported by Bandit Network and Brave Ads, introduces a gamified and rewarding experience for Astar zkEVM users, marking a significant milestone in Web3 adoption.

Digital Assets

Crypto ETFs to debut in Hong Kong next week

Hong Kong has authorized six cryptocurrency-based spot ETFs set to launch on April 30, according to Bloomberg.


BlockDAG Among The Best New Crypto To Invest In Post 8 Billion Coins Sales; More On Bitcoin Cash Futures’ Launch & Solana Positive Predictions

Explore Solana’s ATH predictions to see whether it can rise after a $17B dip? BlockDAG sells 8 billion coins in presale as Bitcoin Cash Futures launch.

Fundamental Analysis, Market News, Tech and Fundamental

Global FX Market Summary:USD, FED, German IFO ,Gold April 24 ,2024

Mixed US economic data and Fed rate hike uncertainty are causing volatility in the EUR/USD pair, while the Eurozone and gold prices add another layer of complexity.

Market News, Tech and Fundamental, Technical Analysis

EURCHF Technical Analysis Report 24 April, 2024

EURCHF currency pair can be expected to rise further toward the next major resistance level 0.9840, which stopped the pervious waves C and B, as can be seen below.

Digital Assets

Binance’s CZ could stay in prison until 2027, wife begs for mercy

Changpeng “CZ” Zhao, the founder and former CEO of Binance, has apologized for his decisions and accepted “full responsibility” in a letter to U.S. District Judge Richard A. Jones.

Digital Assets

Monex Group expands crypto business with 3iQ takeover

Monex Group has completed the acquisition of a majority stake in 3iQ Digital Holdings, Inc., a Canadian digital asset investment fund manager, as part of its strategy to expand its crypto business.

Education, Fintech, Inside View

How to Get Into Fintech: Best Tips to Succeed

The Fintech sector is experiencing significant growth, with fresh opportunities emerging rapidly.  Innovations such as machine learning and cryptocurrency are revolutionising finance, leading to a need for trained experts.

Digital Assets

FalconX launches Prime Connect on Deribit

“We are pleased to launch Prime Connect with Deribit and look forward to providing our full suite of prime services which allow institutions to confidently scale their digital assets portfolios while trading on exchanges.”