CFTC warns that traders accused of spoofing are trying to obtain excessive evidence

Maria Nikolova

According to the CFTC, James Vorley and Cedric Chanu attempt to seek discovery from the regulator without limitation, while trying to shield themselves from their obligations to provide discovery.

The latest request by the US Government to stay the civil action against James Vorley and Cedric Chanu, accused of spoofing, has resulted in disagreement between the traders and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). Whereas the defendants have asked for a narrower stay, the CFTC opposes their request.

On Monday, August 13, 2018, the US regulator submitted a document outlining its opposition to James Vorley and Cedric Chanu’s suggestion.

The CFTC does not oppose the Government’s third request to stay this civil proceeding during the pendency of the criminal case against the former traders, which is pending before the Honorable John J. Tharp, Jr. (No. 1:18-cr-00035). The regulator notes that although it would like to proceed expeditiously, it will not be prejudiced by a brief stay pending the conclusion of the criminal proceeding.

However, the CFTC opposes Defendants’ request for a one-sided, “narrower” stay that would permit them to obtain discovery while shielding them from having to provide discovery themselves. According to the regulator, the Court should reject the defendants’ unreasonable and unfair proposal.

The CFTC alleges that beginning in at least May 2008 through at least July 2013, Vorley and Chanu repeatedly engaged in manipulative or deceptive acts and practices by spoofing – bidding or offering with the intent to cancel the bid or offer before execution – while placing orders and trading in the precious metals markets.

On numerous occasions, Vorley and Chanu placed orders for COMEX gold, silver, platinum or palladium futures contracts that they wanted to get filled, and entered orders for the same contract on the opposite side of the market that they intended to cancel before execution (“spoof orders”). In placing these spoof orders, the defendants are alleged to have intentionally or recklessly sent false signals of increased supply or demand to trick market participants into executing against orders the defendants wanted to get filled.

Vorley and Chanu propose a “narrower” stay which would allow discovery to go forward with the exception of deferring depositions of parties and witnesses who intend to assert their Fifth Amendment rights against self-incrimination. The CFTC argues that the Court should reject this proposal, which would allow the defendants to seek discovery from the regulator without limitation, but will shield the defendants from their obligations to provide discovery.

According to the CFTC, the strong inference from the proposal of Vorley and Chanu is that they would assert their Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination and thus be shielded from testifying in depositions, while remaining free to obtain wide-ranging discovery, including deposition testimony, from the CFTC and third parties. The defendants would thus be spared from either answering questions in a deposition or from having to assert their Fifth Amendment privilege in response to specific deposition questions, and thus escape being subject to the consequent adverse inferences against them that they would be subject to in the course of ordinary discovery.

The regulator says that the defendants’ request is “a blatant attempt to obtain extensive discovery to assist in their defense in the criminal proceeding, without providing equal discovery to the CFTC (and simultaneously gaining an advantage over the CFTC in preparing for trial)”.

The previous requests for staying this civil action had not led to any disagreements.

The case, captioned Commodity Futures Trading Commission v. Vorley et al (1:18-cv-00603), continues at the Illinois Northern District Court.

Read this next

Digital Assets

Midas launches investment strategies for the ‘crypto winter’

Midas.Investments has released three new investment strategies on its custodial CeDeFi platform, creating new opportunities during the ‘crypto winter’.   The platform merges diverse approaches to digital asset management into single-click products to let investors gain steady profits in any market conditions — including the ongoing bear market. a custodial CeDeFi platform, CeDeFi: Unlocking the […]

Digital Assets Wallet adds several ERC-20 tokens

The product expansion includes representatives of the DeFi world, the Metaverse, and the largest stablecoins.

Market News

Savvy Investors to Profit Whether the Stock Market Rebounds or Not

Equities have gone up enormously since the low. SP500 has gained 13.88% since June 17. In August, the indices drifted sideways. On Wall Street, veteran investors expect a move in either direction.

Industry News

Wall Street-backed MEMX obtains SEC approval for options trading platform

The company has raised more than $135 million in funding from 18 stock trading and investing heavyweights, including BlackRock, Citadel Securities, and Morgan Stanley.

Industry News

Amundi US launches ESG strategy that seeks to outperform S&P 500

Amundi’s Responsible investing team includes more than 45 specialists, and its ESG analysis covers more than 13,500 issuers across debt and equity.

Industry News

Verto launches embedded FX payments solution

The Verto API automates currency conversions, tracks payments and exchange rates in real-time, and is being launched in the follow-up of a $10 million in Series A funding last year.

Industry News

SEC awards over $16m to whistleblowers after another successful enforcement action

The program is 10 years-old and has arguably played a critical role in the Division of Enforcement’s ability to effectively detect wrongdoing, protect investors and the marketplace, and bring violators to justice.

Digital Assets

Ripple submits most succint explanation of Hinman issue in XRP lawsuit

It might be useful to get up to date as this could be the end of the road for the SEC.

Retail FX

TradingView integrates first Brazilian broker, Órama Investimentos

Órama offers all kinds of investment products, from fixed income to crypto-related funds.