HK regulator imposes HK$400m fine on UBS for overcharging its clients

Maria Nikolova

The overcharge practices affected about 5,000 Hong Kong-managed client accounts in about 28,700 transactions.

Hong Kong’s Securities and Futures Commission (SFC) today announces the imposition of HK$400 million fine on UBS AG for overcharging its clients over a 10-year period and for related serious systemic internal control failures.

The overcharges occurred through post-trade spread increases and charges in excess of standard disclosures or rates between 2008 and 2017. The overcharge practices affected about 5,000 Hong Kong-managed client accounts in about 28,700 transactions.

The SFC has found that, between 2008 and 2015, the client advisors (CAs) and client advisors’ assistants (CAAs) in UBS’s Wealth Management division had overcharged clients when conducting bond and structured note trades by increasing the spread charged after the execution of trades without clients’ knowledge; and between 2008 and 2017, UBS had also charged its clients fees in excess of its standard disclosures or rates.

Specifically, following their clients’ requests to buy or sell products, the CAs and CAAs would enter the limit order price of the clients’ trades into UBS’s client order processing system. In circumstances where the actual execution price achieved in the market was better than the limit order price, the CAs and CAAs would increase the spread after executing the trades in order to retain the price improvement for UBS without agreement with, or disclosure to, the clients, and sometimes misreported the execution price or spread to the clients.

The SFC’s investigation further revealed that UBS failed to understand and properly disclose the capacity in which it acted for its clients when conducting secondary market bond and structured note trades. UBS acknowledged that its historical approach to capacity was confused, its past communications with regulators regarding its capacity were incomplete, and its communications with clients on whether it was acting as their agent or principal were unclear and, in some cases, erroneous.

The regulator has also found that UBS failed to report its spread overcharge practices to the SFC until two years after the identification of the misconduct. This was not an isolated incident, but was one of a number of late reporting incidents whereby UBS failed to report the relevant misconduct to the SFC in a timely manner, or at all.

After UBS implemented a new order taking platform, One Wealth Management Platform (1WMP), in October 2017, it reported 15 incidents to the SFC or the Hong Kong Monetary Authority relating to the failures of 1WMP covering a variety of issues, including further spread overcharges. These issues call into question UBS’s capability to put in place effective remediation to address the spread overcharge practices and proper internal controls to avoid the recurrence of historical deficiencies.

In deciding the disciplinary sanctions, the SFC considered a variety of factors, including:

  • the elements of dishonesty in UBS’s spread overcharge practices;
  • the duration of UBS’s spread overcharge practices, i.e. around ten years;
  • the fact that UBS’s spread overcharge practices were undetected for at least seven years;
  • the serious and systemic nature of UBS’s internal control failures;
  • UBS’s disciplinary actions against over 20 staff who had engaged in the malpractice;
  • UBS’s appointments of independent reviewers to (i) identify the root causes of the spread overcharge practices and assess the magnitude of its spread overcharge practices, (ii) validate the relevant overcharge and compensation arising from 1WMP, and (iii) review the adequacy and effectiveness of UBS’s remediation measures; and
  • UBS’s agreement to fully compensate the affected clients.

Read this next

Executive Moves

TopFX promotes Omar Al-Janabi to head of sales and business development

Prime brokerage firm TopFX has strengthened its Middle East operations with the promotion of Omar Al-Janabi, who is taking on an expanded role as global head of sales and business development.

Retail FX

Plus500 says 2022 revenue to be ‘significantly’ ahead of analysts’ estimates

Israeli-based, but London-stock market listed Plus500 said it expects annual revenue and earnings to be ahead of analysts’ estimates even as trading levels normalised from record volumes in the first quarter.

Digital Assets

Crypto derivatives giant BitMEX launches spot market

Crypto exchange BitMEX is looking to branch out of its singular focus on crypto derivatives with a suite of new product offerings. Although derivatives are to remain at the heart of BitMEX’s business, the popular platform will add spot crypto trading as it aims to aggressively grow their user base.

Uncategorized

PrimeXM reports mixed trading volumes for April

PrimeXM has reported weaker trading volumes for April 2022, in line with other institutional and retail platforms that saw the activity of their clients dropped compared to a month earlier.

Digital Assets

DLT Finance approved by BaFin to support brokerage and custody of digital assets

DLT Finance is already partnered with big names within the digital asset space, including Kraken, Bitstamp, B2C2, and Bittrex.

Institutional FX

LUKB taps vestr to launch actively managed products, AMCs

The partnership with vestr goes to show the growing importance of digitising the active investment management space.

Digital Assets

Jewel taps Tokeny to launch stablecoin-as-a-service solution on Polygon

Jewel aims to offer a stablecoin-as-a-service solution to other digital asset and financial institutions B2B, allowing those businesses to provide cheaper, easier and near real time payments with stablecoins issued and redeemable directly at the bank level at Jewel.

Industry News

SEC charges $410+ million Ponzi scheme with pre-IPO shares

We allege that the defendants deceived investors about the pre-IPO shares they held, how much they were charging in fees, and who was controlling the business—all while paying themselves more than $75 million.

Industry News

FNZ taps data analytics GIST to address ESG ratings bias

The allocation of capital is critical to driving the change required to transition to net-zero and building a more sustainable economy and society.

<