Mark Karpeles claims he is not MtGox’s alter ego

Maria Nikolova

“I did not direct any advertising on behalf of Mt. Gox and I was not responsible for Mt. Gox’s day-to-day accounting”, Mark Karpeles says in a Declaration.

In what may seem as a rather unusual move, Mark Karpeles, the former head of ill-fated Bitcoin exchange MtGox, is now claiming that he was not the Exchange’s alter ego. The reason for such a claim is that it may allow him to be protected from being sued in Illinois under the so-called “fiduciary shield rule”.

The fiduciary shield doctrine “prevents courts from asserting jurisdiction over a person on the basis of acts taken by that person not on his own behalf, but on behalf of his employer.” All Karpeles has to prove is that he, despite being the sole shareholder of the Exchange, was not its alter ego.

Let’s recall that Mark Karpeles is being sued in Illinois by US clients of MtGox who accuse him of:

  • intentionally, with gross recklessness, or negligently stealing plaintiffs’ bitcoins and fiat currency;

  • negligence, alleging that Karpeles owed the plaintiffs a duty of reasonable care to prevent improper access and misuse of the plaintiffs’ bitcoins and fiat currency and to allow authorized users complete access to the same and breached those duties;

  • consumer fraud – Karpeles represented that he would protect MtGox clients’ bitcoins and fiat currency and allow them to buy, sell, trade, and withdraw those funds, while siphoning, or allowing others to siphon, funds from Mt. Gox customers’ accounts.

The plaintiffs also allege that Karpeles concealed that Mizuho Bank was no longer providing international withdrawal services, that thousands of bitcoins had been lost or stolen, and that he was shutting down the exchange and filing for bankruptcy.

Karpeles has already indicated that he would oppose the allegations against him. In August, he said the Illinois Northern District Court does not have jurisdiction over him.

On Tuesday, September 25, 2018, he filed a Memorandum in support of his motion to dismiss the case against him. It is this document that refers to the fiduciary shield doctrine.

Karpeles admits that he was, at all relevant times, acting in his capacity as President and CEO of Mt. Gox. But he insists that “the mere fact that he was the sole shareholder of an entity owning 88% of Mt. Gox is not enough to prevent the application of the fiduciary shield rule”.

The defense submits a declaration by Karpeles in which he aims to prove that he was not the alter ego of Mt. Gox. But that declaration includes only brief statements such as “MtGox observed corporate formalities and kept corporate records” and that “Mt. Gox issued shares of stock, of which Tibanne KK owned eighty-eight percent.” There are also statements that Mr. Karpeles never commingled funds, assets or identities with Mt. Gox and that Mr. Karpeles never diverted assets from Mt. Gox to himself or any other person. Mt. Gox was not undercapitalized, the Declaration by Karpeles states.

But all these are mere statements without any evidentiary support offered for them.

The case, captioned Greene v. MtGox Inc. et al (1:14-cv-01437), continues at the Illinois Northern District Court.

Read this next

Institutional FX

Sucden Financial launches access to 25 of China’s futures and options contracts

“We are delighted to offer clients access to three key futures markets in China, the world’s largest commodity consumer.”

Industry News

Kraken sponsors Williams Racing to expand institutional reach and fan engagement

“Kraken’s partnership with Williams Racing shows what is possible when you combine a great mission with excellence, innovation and breakthrough performance. These are both iconic brands that have stood the test of time. We’re excited to engage with both Kraken’s and Williams Racing’s global communities, showcasing the power and life-changing impact of crypto and Web3.”

Retail FX

FXChoice taps Acuity’s news, sentiment tools, calendars, trade ideas on MT4/5

“Our tools are designed with the end-user in mind and are engineered to present insightful and actionable market data in an accessible way to help traders manage risk by identifying potential market movements before they occur and ultimately make better decisions on how, when, and where to invest.”

Digital Assets

BlockFi to refund $103K to Californian users

Bankrupt crypto lender BlockFi will refund more than $100,000 to its California-based users who continued to repay loans even after the company halted client withdrawals following a liquidity crisis.

Institutional FX

SimCorp and FlexTrade team up to strengthen Open Platform

Broker-neutral technology firm FlexTrade Systems announced that its solution FlexTRADER EMS has been certified for integration with SimCorp, a provider of integrated, front-to-back, multi-asset investment management solutions.

Digital Assets

MicroStrategy prepays Silvergate loan, trims loss on BTC bet

MicroStrategy, spearheaded by one of bitcoin’s most vocal proponents, has prepaid the $205 million bitcoin-backed loan it took out from insolvent crypto-focused Silvergate Bank in March 2022.

Executive Moves

UK spread better InterTrader hires Joe Rundle as CEO

Multi-regulated online trading provider InterTrader has publicly revealed its newest appointment, having onboarded industry veteran Joe Rundle as its Chief Executive Officer (CEO).

Digital Assets

Federal judge puts brakes on Voyager sale to Binance

A federal judge temporarily halted the proposed deal to sell bankrupt crypto lender Voyager Digital’s assets to Binance US after a request by the United States government for an emergency stay.

Industry News

Equals Group expands payments solutions and BaaS into Europe

“We have made a significant investment in our technology and payment platform over the last few years which will allow us to rapidly deploy new products into the European market and we are confident that we can meet the diverse needs of businesses across the continent.”