Nasdaq says SEC’s market structure proposal raises more questions than answers

Maria Nikolova

The potential change to Nasdaq’s revenues due to the new rules could largely be dependent on the net impact of customers who decide to switch to a new consolidated SIP.

Nasdaq today published an IR update regarding the market structure proposal unveiled by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) earlier in February.

SEC‘s market structure proposal is set to change equity trading under Reg NMS by re-defining which orders will be displayed in the market (under NMS Rule 604), how many shares will be required for orders to be “protected” from trade-throughs (under NMS Rule 611) and when markets can be locked or crossed (under NMS Rule 610).

Further, the proposed rule will shift regulation of brokers/dealers that handle investors’ orders by adding further ambiguity to the Duty of Best Execution owed to customers, and the calculations and disclosures of order handling (under NMS Rule 605 and Rule 606).

It also reforms regulation of exchanges by changing the operation of short selling regulation (under Reg SHO Rule 201), Limit Up/Limit Down and MarketWide Circuit Breakers, and creating new categories of “Regulatory” and “Administrative” data under NMS Rule 600.

The new rule also changes the collection, consolidation and dissemination of market data to investors, including what data is collected from brokers and exchanges, and how that data will be consolidated and distributed.

Importantly, the new rule expands the scope of consolidated “SIP” data to include five levels of depth-of-book data and exchange auction data, including changes to NMS Rules 600, 603, and 608.

It will also see the creation of a system of competing consolidators that would be authorized to buy and distribute all consolidated data from all exchanges. A competing consolidator would be required to make all consolidated data available to those that wished to purchase it.

The new rule allows “self-aggregators” to buy and consolidate data for their own use, subject to few regulatory standards, and establishes a new system of registration for a new class of market participants — “competing consolidators“ and subjects them to registration and to provisions of Regulation SCI.

Nasdaq notes that the potential change to its revenues could largely be dependent on the net impact of customers who decide to switch to a new consolidated SIP, away from depth or Nasdaq Basic products. While product substitution could occur, Nasdaq would receive compensation from new content and potential additional users of core market data.

The SEC’s rulemaking proposal, if implemented as proposed, would require additional information before impacts can be reasonably assessed. Therefore, Nasdaq is not making changes at this time to its medium-term outlook of low to mid single digit revenue growth for market data.

Nasdaq notes the proposal is complex, thus giving way to more questions than answers.

For instance, the proposal abandons the single, unified NBBO in favor of a decentralized, splintered NBBO calculated by dozens of different participants. Investors will have no “North Star” for determining the quality of their trades.

Nasdaq also stresses that the proposal partially rescinds the rule against locking or crossing the markets, allowing some orders to lock or cross the market depending on the price of the stock, the size of the order, and the state of the NBBO.

In addition, a bifurcated system of round lots and protected quotes would exist, with orders below 100 shares not being protected even though they are redefined as round lots and will be displayed in the exchange data feed. Therefore, displayed retail orders will not be protected against trade-throughs.

Nasdaq sees the SEC’s proposal as giving rise to numerous issues with respect to pricing and product design of market data. Thus, for example, according to Nasdaq, the proposal is silent on critical elements of market data products, pricing and production. Unknown are the products that will be offered, the prices of these products, the allocation of quote and trade revenue, the collection of revenue from newly-registered competing SIPs and self-aggregators.

Furthermore, Nasdaq says the proposed rule creates several conflicts of interest amongst clients and competitors, and a dramatic expansion of the role of government and interested parties in rate-setting within competitive industries.

Finally, multiple NBBOs will make it harder to surveil market activity to protect investors.

The SEC issued the proposed rule on February 14, 2020. After the proposed rule is published in the Federal Register, a 60-day comment period begins. After comment period closes, the SEC must review the comments, and this process can take several months to complete.

Read this next


SteelEye tries ChatGPT for market surveillance

This capability can be used as a starting point for initiating a surveillance investigation and to standardize workflow processes to boost the throughput and consistency of cases. It is also useful when analyzing communications in foreign languages, as the system returns the above insights in English regardless of the languages being used.

Industry News

SEC charges ex-Morgan Stanley advisor of NBA players after $13m fraud

Darryl Matthew Cohen was arrested this week and is facing three different federal counts of fraud, which could amount to 20 years in prison if convicted, besides the SEC complaint. 

Industry News

AWS FinTech Africa Accelerator launched, applications until April 27, 2023

Founders will be offered tech resources, expert guidance, and a global network of industry leaders, technologists, entrepreneurs, investors, associations, and partners, in order to build their fintech products. 

Industry News

Interactive Brokers pays unmatched interest up to USD 4.33% on cash balances over $10,000

For clients of Interactive Brokers, interest accrues daily, and payments are posted on a monthly basis. Interactive Brokers’ cash management is integrated into client broker accounts, making it simple to earn interest and borrow at the lowest rates without transferring cash.

Retail FX

FP Markets adds cTrader to roster of trading platforms that include MT4, MT5, Iress

“Our market share swings towards the more sophisticated segment of traders and we have been inundated with requests for an additional platform with more institutional-style characteristics. The addition of the cTrader trading platform offering allows our clients the choice to further shape their trading experience with us.”

Digital Assets

SEC mulls lawsuit against Coinbase’s staking and spot trading

Shares in Coinbase fell 15 percent after the US Securities and Exchange Commission threatened a potential enforcement action against the crypto exchange over certain products.

Digital Assets

Kraken halts ACH transactions amid banking crisis

San Francisco-based cryptocurrency exchange Kraken says it will no longer process Automated Clearing House (ACH) following the failure of its payments partner, Silvergate Bank.

Digital Assets

French influencers face two years in jail for promoting crypto products

France’s National Assembly’s Economics Committee voted in favor of a law that bans social media influencers from touting risky financial services, including cryptocurrencies.


Exberry’s Guy Melamed on paradigm shift with cloud-native exchanges at FIA Boca 2023

FinanceFeeds Editor-in-Chief Nikolai Isayev spoke with Guy Melamed about Exberry’s cloud-native exchange SaaS platform certified by AWS to bring about a paradigm shift in the industry at a time of cybersecurity concerns.