New York court throws out lawsuit by shareholders against FXCM – says SNB removed peg without notice

“The court cannot find conscious misbehavior or recklessness when defendants’ business model had a successful track record and market investors were shocked by the SNB’s decision.” – Judge Kimba M Wood


On Thursday this week, US District Judge Kimba M Wood dismissed a shareholder class action lawsuit against FXCM, in which investors claimed that the company made false statements about its business model in the advent of the removal of the 1.20 peg on the EURCHF pair by the Swiss National Bank in January 2015.

The ensuing negative balances to which the firm was exposed, along with many other FX companies on the day that has become known as “Black Thursday” which led to the company taking an emergency loan from Leucadia, resulted in discourse by shareholders that led to a class action suit.

FinanceFeeds met with FXCM CEO Drew Niv this year. During the meeting, Mr. Niv explained in great detail how what FinanceFeeds considers to be his remarkable composure and standing as a leading senior FX industry executive enabled him to keep the company on an even keel despite the limited time available and the uncertainty of the actual exposure.

Mr. Niv succeeded in ensuring complete stability, against many odds, and must be commended for that.

The only aspect of the company that was damaged severely post SNB event was its share price, which the firm made steps toward rectifying with a reverse stock split, however this did not prevent a class action suit by investors.

The main points of the lawsuit relate to the outcome of the events that occurred on January 15, 2015, when the Swiss National Bank, contrary to a series of public statements made in the previous months, removed the peg on the EURCHF without any notice whatsoever which created unprecedented volatility.

Prior to that, FXCM had considered the previous period to have been the “lowest volatility in two decades” and had also striven to provide retail clients with the best execution methods available by executing all trades on a live market and not via a dealing desk.

Sadly, those who internalized every trade on January 15 actually profited, whereas the A-book brokers were exposed to negative balances.

In this case, which provided a positive outcome for FXCM, Judge Wood dismissed the class action lawsuit by shareholders, stating that the investors could not prove that FXCM and its executive team had intentionally inflated company stock, or acted recklessly ahead of the volatility caused by the removal of the peg by the Swiss National Bank.

A sensible outcome, as absolutely no entity whatsoever was privy to any prior indication that the Swiss National Bank would take such action.

Judge Wood said “The court cannot find conscious misbehavior or recklessness when defendants’ business model had a successful track record and market investors were shocked by the SNB’s decision.”

Although FXCM’s business model relied on monitoring its often leveraged customer accounts and automatically closing out positions if the account was at risk of going negative from a losing trade, the extreme volatility of the franc after the SNB decision led liquidity providers to stop providing prices or liquidity and FXCM could not close out customer accounts before their margin collateral was exhausted.

This decision comes at a time during which the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) has filed a charge against FXCM for capital shortages during the Swiss National Bank’s removal of the EURCHF peg, a citation which FXCM is contesting and about which the company has made a public statement of its position.

A victory for common sense in this case. Risk management should also be considered by shareholders, especially when backing an agency brokerage which transfers its trades in all good faith to a live and liquid market.

Read this next

Digital Assets receives UK’s EMI license, paving way for regulated expansion

Cryptocurrency exchange has been authorized as an Electronic Money Institution by the United Kingdom’s Financial Conduct Authority (FCA).

Digital Assets

Ripple’s Metaco joins Zodia Custody’s network for connectivity with Layers 0 and 1

“As the industry undergoes a pivotal transformation, our networked infrastructure is dedicated to standardise, govern and connect institutional digital asset flows — an essential step in forging use cases that transcend individual companies.”

Retail FX

BDSwiss Unveils Dynamic Leverage and Zero-Spread Account for Enhanced Forex Trading

Experience a new era in forex trading with BDSwiss, a leading player in the industry, as it introduces two groundbreaking enhancements designed to elevate traders’ experiences on its platform.

Retail FX

Plus500 joins Futures Industry Association as US operations expand

Plus500 Ltd (LON:PLUS) has become a primary member of the Futures Industry Association (FIA) in the United States. The membership supports Plus500’s plans to expand its US business, positioning itself within the world’s leading trade organization for futures, options, and centrally cleared derivatives markets.

Market News

Weekly data: Fiber and Gold price action 

This preview of weekly data looks at EURUSD and XAUUSD where economic data coming up later this week are the main drivers in the markets for the near short term outlook. 

Market News

Unveiling the Top Performers in December 2023: A Stock Market Overview

As we approach the end of 2023, the dynamic landscape of the stock market unveils a year marked by high-profile events, from the resurgence of tech stocks to the demise of financial institutions.


Avelacom enhances connectivity across Middle East and East Asia

“Network latency is a critical factor in their operations across multiple, fast-moving markets where seizing arbitrage opportunities instantaneously is essential. We are dedicated to continually optimizing our global network paths. Our London to Tokyo route, a flagship for Avelacom, has been upgraded alongside other key markets in Asia, India, Turkey, and the Middle East.”

Institutional FX

DMALINK adds Commerzbank to its FX streaming service

“The inclusion of Commerzbank stems from ongoing client demand, achieving our core objective of providing data-driven institutional FX liquidity in a variety of trade sizes to users of any of our platforms looking to access primary markets efficiently.”

Institutional FX

Citi taps Traydstream to streamline trade documentation for its clients

Traydstream specializes in intelligent data extraction using AI and optical character recognition. Its technology significantly reduces the time needed for document checks in trade transactions, leveraging a machine-learning engine with an extensive rule database.