NY Court quashes attempt by Interactive Brokers’ clients to file amended complaint about improper account administration

Maria Nikolova

Judge George B. Daniels has denied a motion by the plaintiffs to submit an amended complaint against the broker saying that the proposed amendments would be futile.

Heather Hauptman and Timothy Moss, plaintiffs in a case targeting online trading major Interactive Brokers LLC, suffered a heavy blow on Friday, October 19th, as Judge George B. Daniels of the New York Southern District Court denied their motion to file an amended complaint against the broker.

Let’s recall what the case is about. Interactive Brokers’ clients brought a putative class action against their former broker-dealer, alleging that the company breached its contractual obligations by including certain exchange traded notes (ETNs) in their portfolio margin investment accounts.

In July this year, the plaintiffs sought to file an amended complaint claiming they had specified how and when they and Interactive Brokers established contractual agreements via the Portfolio Margin Disclosure Statement and other documents (the “2014 Agreements”) that prohibited Interactive Brokers from applying portfolio margin to ETNs.

Putting it otherwise, the plaintiffs tried to change their strategy by arguing it is not the Customer agreements that are at the heart of their claims. Rather, the broker’s clients alleged that additional promises and commitments by Interactive Brokers were made in 2014 and that these “exceed those imposed by FINRA.” The plaintiffs’ new claims alleged that the parties’ Disclosure Statement was supplemented and amended by the 2014 Agreements that specifically promised and agreed that Interactive Brokers would not include ETNs in its portfolio margin accounts, and thereby Interactive Brokers subsequently breached its agreements when it did so, resulting in substantial losses for the plaintiffs and other putative class members.

FINRA Rule 4210 was said to no longer be the predicate for the plaintiffs’ claims. The plaintiffs’ new claims arise from Interactive Brokers’ decision to implement Article 2175, which specifically agreed to stop trading ETNs in portfolio margin accounts without regard or reliance on FINRA rules or regulations.

The plaintiffs alleged that by providing portfolio margin’s risk-based margining treatment for open positions in ETNs and options on ETNs – such as the VXX – the broker breached its contractual agreements with its customers.

Judge George B. Daniels, however, did not find these arguments convincing and, on Friday, nixed the plaintiffs’ motion to file their amended complaint. The Judge explained that the proposed amendments would be futile.

Interactive Brokers’ customers asserted that their new “breach of contract claims now rest upon the theory that additional promises and commitments by Interactive Brokers made in the 2014 Agreements exceed those obligations imposed by FINRA.” However, the Judge noted, neither the Disclosure Agreement nor the 2014 Agreements indicate that Interactive Brokers agreed to assume obligations beyond those imposed by FINRA. According to the Judge, Interactive Brokers’ provision of the Disclosure Agreement to potential customers simply reflects its compliance with FINRA rules.

Because the 2014 Agreements, at most, reflect Interactive Brokers’ commitment to comply with FINRA’s decision, the 2014 Agreements do not impose any obligations on the broker in excess of those imposed by FINRA, the Judge said in his Order.

Read this next

Digital Assets

Crypto exchange Bittrex exits US market amid regulatory woes

Bittrex said on Friday it plans to wind down operations in the United States and voluntarily liquidate because of the uncertain regulatory environment surrounding their business.

Institutional FX

Tradeweb completes integration of Nasdaq’s US fixed income platform

Tradeweb Markets has completed the technology integration of Nasdaq’s US fixed income electronic trading platform, formerly known as eSpeed, which it acquired two years ago in a $190 million, all-cash transaction.

Digital Assets

FTX Europe to allow client withdrawals via new website

The Cypriot unit of failed cryptocurrency exchange FTX has launched a new website that it says would allow customers to withdraw deposits of fiat currency and crypto assets after months of suspension.

Retail FX

Liquidators apply to cancel SVS Securities’ FCA license

An update published today by Leonard Curtis said the UK high court of justice has approve their application to bring the special administration of the failed wealth manager SVS Securities to an end.

Digital Assets

Japan forms government panel to pilot digital yen

Japan’s Finance Ministry has created an advisory panel to look at the feasibility of issuing a central bank digital currency, otherwise known as “CBDC”.

Digital Assets

USDC sees massive $10.4 billion outflows in March

Cryptocurrency traders have withdrawn more than $10 billion from the world’s second largest stablecoin, USDC, in less than three weeks even as concerns over the fallout from the Silicon Valley collapse have receded.


OSTTRA’s Joanna Davies goes beyond 30-30-30 data standard at FIA Boca 2023

FinanceFeeds Editor-in-Chief Nikolai Isayev spoke with Joanna Davies about OSTTRA.


CloudMargin’s Stuart Connolly on how to manage collateral amid high rates at FIA Boca 2023

FinanceFeeds Editor-in-Chief Nikolai Isayev spoke with Stuart Connolly about CloudMargin’s SaaS platform, said to be the only cloud-native collateral and margin management system in the industry, at a time of stress due to rising interest rates.


Baton Systems’ Alex Knight on solving post-trade with DLT at FIA Boca 2023

FinanceFeeds Editor-in-Chief Nikolai Isayev spoke with Alex Knight about Baton Systems’ about rising settlement fails, collateral management, and the profile of DLT beyond cryptocurrencies.