Silk Road’s mastermind Ross Ulbricht faces objections to appeal

Maria Nikolova

Ulbricht has not established that the Pen/Trap data he seeks constitute “newly discovered” evidence that is material to his defense, or likely would have led to his acquittal at trial, US Attorneys argue.

Several months after Ross William Ulbricht, also known as Dread Pirate Roberts, the mastermind behind Silk Road, the notorious marketplace that used Bitcoins for its transactions, filed an appeal from a set of orders issued by the Honorable Katherine B. Forrest, United States District Judge, in the Southern District of New York, he now faces objections from the US Government.

Earlier today, the USA filed an appellee brief with the Second Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals. In the document, US attorneys insist that Ulbricht’s claims should be dismissed and that the District Court did not err in its judgment.

Let’s recall that Ulbricht appeals from

  1. an order entered on February 5, 2018, denying his request for an extension of time to submit a motion for a new trial pursuant to Rule 33 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure;
  2. an order entered on February 21, 2018, denying his request for reconsideration, both entered by the Honorable Katherine B. Forrest.

The motions by Ulbricht focus on data he claims is new. Over the course of investigating Ulbricht and his Silk Road enterprise, the Government had obtained five orders for pen register and trap and trace data (Pen/Trap). On February 5, 2018, while his petition for certiorari was pending, Ulbricht filed a series of motions, including a request for an extension of time to file a Rule 33 motion based on purportedly new evidence related to the five Pen/Trap orders. The District Court denied the motion for additional time to file a Rule 33 motion later that day.

Let’s note that Rule 33 provides, in relevant part, that “upon the defendant’s motion, the court may vacate any judgment and grant a new trial if the interest of justice so requires.”

The Attorneys explain that where a motion for a new trial is based on a claim of newly discovered evidence, the defendant bears a particularly high burden, for relief may only be granted upon a showing that (1) the evidence is newly discovered after trial; (2) facts are alleged from which the court can infer due diligence on the part of the movant to obtain the evidence; (3) the evidence is material; (4) the evidence is not merely cumulative or impeaching; and (5) the evidence would likely result in an acquittal.

The District Court did not abuse its discretion in denying Ulbricht’s request for an extension of time to file a Rule 33 motion, because Ulbricht has not established that the Pen/Trap data he seeks constitute “newly discovered” evidence that is material to his defense, or likely would have led to his acquittal at trial.

Ulbricht characterizes the purportedly “newly discovered” evidence as (1) Pen/Trap data for three of the orders “which should be contained in the three sealed magistrate’s files”; (2) “additional, new [Pen/Trap] data which the government had just discovered and promised to produce to the defense”; and (3) “evidence” from a book regarding Ulbricht’s conviction, American Kingpin, which “revealed” that the investigating agency was “invading” Ulbricht’s residence to “monitor his location, movements and online activity within his residence” through the use of the Pen/Trap orders.

The US attorneys argue that Ulbricht’s challenges are meritless. The existence of the Pen/Trap data was known to Ul-bricht as early as February 2014, they say, adding that the arguments he puts forth now about the purported import and use of the Pen/Trap data were raised by Ulbricht and rejected by the District Court and this Court on direct appeal. As such, the District Court did not abuse its discretion in denying both Ulbricht’s motion for additional time to file a futile Rule 33 motion, and his request for reconsideration of that denial.

From early 2011 through October 1, 2013, Ulbricht owned and operated a vast online black market, known as “Silk Road,” through which thousands of vendors sold approximately $183 million dollars of illegal drugs, as well as a variety of other goods and services. Ulbricht designed and created Silk Road to facilitate illegal transactions anony mously and beyond the reach of law enforcement, including by hosting the site on the Onion Router (Tor) network, which hides the identities of its users and their IP addresses, and by requiring vendors and customers to do business in Bitcoin, a virtual currency designed to be as anonymous as cash.

The Indictment was filed on August 21, 2014, charging Ulbricht in seven counts, including distributing and aiding and abetting the distribution of narcotics, engaging in a continuing criminal enterprise, and conspiring to launder money. Trial commenced on January 13, 2015, and ended on February 4, 2015, when the jury found Ulbricht guilty on all counts. On May 29, 2015, Judge Forrest sentenced Ulbricht to a term of life imprisonment and ordered forfeiture in the amount of $183,961,921.

Ulbricht is currently serving his sentence.

Read this next

Executive Moves

Crculus taps Michael Idzkowski as head of sales

Michael Idzkowski has joined Crculus, a UK-based startup that describes itself as a multi-custody middleware infrastructure for financial institutions, in the post of its head of sales.

Retail FX

ActivTrades jumps on fractional stock trading bandwagon

CFDs and FX broker, ActivTrades has updated its trading offering to provide its clients with the opportunity to trade fractions of stocks.

Digital Assets

BitMEX to list its native token by end of 2023

BitMEX CEO Alexander Hoeptner said the crypto exchange is planning to list its native token, called BMEX, on the spot market by the end of the year.

Market News

Forex investments take over popular sentiment as a worthy global trend

Quite the confusion is afoot in the financial markets. Tighter regulation, rising inflation, energy sector disruptions, social unrest and wars have taken a toll on the world’s economies. How come Forex, as a means of investment, has come up on top as a global trend in 2022? Against the backdrop of current events, the international broker’s expert team at OctaFX has gathered some answers.

Crypto Insider, Metaverse Gaming NFT

How Hiding Crypto’s Influence Will Be Key To Unlocking Its Success

In past years, cryptocurrency has advanced well beyond the technophiles responsible for its initial success to reach widespread name recognition. Crypto has found its way into news, music, culture, and other relevant facets of daily life. 

Digital Assets

SCRYPT Digital taps Enclave Markets to mirror dark pool trading in crypto

“A service like this has been sorely lacking in the crypto space. There hasn’t been a solution that provides the security or privacy that institutions require with these kinds of trades.”

Institutional FX

FXSpotStream reports record monthly volume at $1.613 trillion

Trading volumes on institutional FX platforms surged in September after fears over the impact of recent developments around Russia’s military invasion of Ukraine sent speculative asset classes reeling.

Industry News

OKX adds four-time Olympian snowboarder Scotty James as brand ambassador

‘What is OKX?’ is the name of the new multi-milion dollar brand campaign launched by crypto exchange OKX as part of its efforts toward world expansion.

Industry News

Circle buys Elements and announces beta version of Crypto Payments API

“Lowering barriers of entry for payments and financial services and establishing dollar payments utility are core to Circle’s mission.”

<