TFS-ICAP senior managers respond to CFTC allegations

Maria Nikolova

Ian Dibb and Jeremy Woolfenden argue that the CFTC fails to allege that the practice called “flying’” violates the CEA.

Several months after TFS-ICAP LLC and TFS-ICAP Ltd. opposed the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) allegations of fraud and supervision failures, Jeremy Woolfenden and Ian Dibb who are also defendants in this case, sought to respond to the CFTC claims.

Jeremy Woolfenden was the Global Head of Emerging Markets broking at TFS-ICAP, whereas Ian Dibb was the CEO of TFS-ICAP from approximately 2011 to 2017.

Mr Woolfenden and Mr Dibb have earlier this week submitted Letters which seek to highlight alleged deficiencies in the CFTC complaint in this case.

Jeremy Woolfenden, who is a United Kingdom citizen, argues that the CFTC claims against him have to be dismissed as he has never lived in the United States and never engaged in any alleged conduct in New York. The CFTC also fails to allege sufficient “minimum contacts” of Mr Woolfenden with the forum to satisfy the due process requirements, he says.

Both Mr Woolfenden and Mr Dibb argue that the practice called “flying” does not violate the Commodity Exchange Act.

According to the Complaint, “flying” is when a broker posts a bid or offer that is not backed by a specific trading institution. The Complaint alleges that this practice is fraudulent because the Volbroker User Agreement and User Guide indicate that bids and offers posted by brokers are binding bids and offers backed by trading institutions. These documents say no such thing.

The defendants insist that “flown” levels posted by brokers were merely good faith estimates of where the market would likely trade – a permissible and non-fraudulent practice – as opposed to a false factual representation that a specific institution was making an offer at a specific level. Therefore, according to Mr Woolfenden and Mr Dibb, the CFTC cannot allege that these levels were fraudulent.

Additionally, as detailed in TFS’s letter, the Complaint fails to allege materiality. Contrary to the CFTC’s assertions in response to TFS’s letter, there is nothing in the Complaint that “gives rise to a strong inference of materiality,” and, even if there were, that is neither a particular allegation nor the relevant legal standard. Rather, to survive a motion to dismiss, the CFTC must show that a “there is a substantial likelihood that a reasonable investor would consider the alleged misstatements important in making an investment decision.”

Mr Dibb notes that, although the Complaint refers to the incorporation of certain bids and trades into proprietary trading models, the Complaint is silent on whether flown prices and printed trades were actually important to investor decisions.

Let’s recall that the CFTC downplayed the arguments raised by TFS-ICAP LLC and TFS-ICAP Ltd. and insisted no amendment to its complaint is necessary. It remains to be seen what the CFTC’s reaction to Dibb’s and Woolfenden’s argumentation would be.

Read this next

Institutional FX

Integral also grapple with weak FX volumes in December

Foreign exchange trading volumes dropped in December across Integral’s trading platforms as many traders were away on annual leave and currency markets saw a relatively quiet period. December volumes outpaced those of last year, though turnover is still down month-over-month.

Digital Assets

BitMEX to turn German bank into regulated crypto products powerhouse in Europe

The historic German bank is already a leader in the application of blockchain technology and offers a range of digital assets banking services, including custody, tokenization, efficient payment transactions, and regulatory secure market access.

Industry News

CryptoUK appoints Teana Baker-Taylor as non-executive director

“CryptoUK is moving the needle on policy and regulatory framework development to ultimately build trust and protect all participants, from retail investors to the crypto industry players”

Retail FX

Skilling raises €10m to expand brokerage further after triple-digit growth in 2021

“This fundraising round represents the beginning of the next phase of Skilling’s growth as we further assert ourselves in the fintech industry”

Industry News

oneZero adds two more FX veterans, Indu Maheshwari and Kevin Verardi

The news of Indu and Kevin’s appointments comes a month after Jim Sullivan was announced as the company’s General Counsel, where he will be responsible for the company’s global legal function, based in New York.


Pareto Securities goes live with Broadridge’s OMS for low and high touch agency trading

The solution combines order management, market connectivity and smart order router (SOR) components developed by Itiviti, which was acquired by Broadridge last year in a $2.5 billion deal.

Retail FX

INGOT Brokers taps Acquity and Signal Centre for MT4/5 EAs and news analytics

INGOT Brokers is helping traders cut through the noise and get a clearer picture of the emerging market trends as well as better spot trading opportunities with AI-powered signals.

Digital Assets

Can the Ripple lawsuit be traded with Wrapped XRP to circumvent XRP delisting in US?

wXRP is a derivative product that is pegged to the digital asset that the SEC claims to be a security in what has been dubbed “the cryptocurrency lawsuit of the century”.

Digital Assets

e-CNY wallet downloads swell, but actual usage disappoints

China’s central bank has released a wallet app for payments and money transfers using the digital yuan earlier this month. Although the e-CNY wallet was the most downloaded app in January, but according to a Reuters report the actual use in transactions has been far less impressive.