TradeStation, Interactive Brokers refuse mediation in Trading Technologies patent infringement case

Maria Nikolova

According to the latest filings by TradeStation and Interactive Brokers with the Federal Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals, the case is not amenable to mediation.

A follow-up to FinanceFeeds’ earlier report about Trading Technologies appealing a March decision by the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) in a legal move related to the so-called “patent ‘556”, called “System and Method for Displaying Order Information in Relation to a Derivative of Price”…

In brief, the PTAB Final Written Decision dated March 31, 2017, sides with a number of online trading companies, including Interactive Brokers LLC, IBG LLC, TradeStation Group Inc, TradeStation Securities, TradeStation Technologies and IBFX. The brokers have been sued by Trading Technologies over an alleged infringement of the patent, which describes “a user interface for an electronic trading system that allows a remote trader to view trends for an item, which assists the trader to anticipate demand for an item”.

The parties in the case have filed their docketing statements, with appellees Interactive Brokers LLC, IBG LLC, TradeStation Group Inc, TradeStation Securities, and TradeStation Technologies, saying that mediation is not an option in this case.

In their docketing statement, appellees TradeStation Group, TradeStation Securities, and TradeStation Technologies, confirm that they have had settlement discussions with other parties in the case. They also state that these discussions were mediated by Judge Holderman (retired from N.D. Ill. and current JAMS mediator). And yet, TradeStation Group, TradeStation Securities, and TradeStation Technologies say that the present case is not amenable to mediation because “the parties strongly disagree about the merits of the case and are unlikely to reach agreement”.

Appellees IBG LLC and Interactive Brokers LLC also confirm that they have had settlement discussions with other parties but state that “IBG LLC and Interactive Brokers LLC do not believe that mediation would be fruitful at this time”.

In March, the Board determined that the patent claims made by Trading Technologies are directed to an abstract idea – providing a trader with financial information to facilitate market trades, which is a fundamental economic practice. All that “claim 1” encompasses, for instance, are steps that, according to the brokers and the Board, can be performed using pen and paper, or even in a trader’s mind.

The PTAB was not convinced by Patent Owner’s arguments that the claimed GUI improves the computer because it allows the computer to be used in new and inventive ways. The use of a GUI to display market information was seen as “a well-understood, routine, conventional activity that does not add significantly more to the abstract idea.”

Trading Technologies seeks Vacatur to this decision and the denying of its request for rehearing.

Appellees seek affirmance of PTAB’s decision finding patent claims to be patent-ineligible.

The case is captioned Trading Technologies Intl. v. IBG LLC (0:17-bcaag-02323).

Read this next

Retail FX

Belgium regulator blacklists FXP360, Appex Finance, and Wise-Markets

Belgium’s financial watchdog, the Financial Services and Markets Authority ‎‎(FSMA), has issued a warning against the unauthorized activities of multiple ‎ platforms that are offering investments in the country without ‎complying with Belgian financial legislation.‎

Digital Assets

MicroStrategy piles on Bitcoin, acquiring 0.90% of circulating supply

MicroStrategy, the world’s largest Bitcoin corporate holder, has further increased its holdings of the primary cryptocurrency. According to a recent filing, the company acquired an additional 16,130 bitcoins between November 1 and November 29, spending $593.3 million at an average price of $36,785 per bitcoin.

Digital Assets

Paxos gets nod to issue dollar-backed stablecoins in UAE

Stablecoin issuer Paxos has received preliminary approval from Abu Dhabi’s Financial Services Regulatory Authority to issue U.S. dollar-backed virtual currencies and provide crypto-brokerage and custody services.

Digital Assets

Flare Labs Begins Testing FAssets on Coston Testnet Paving Way for Non-Smart Contracts to Flare

Flare Labs has introduced FAssets on the Coston testnet, enabling the integration of non-smart contract tokens like BTC, XRP, and DOGE into the DeFi ecosystem.

Digital Assets

Philippine bars access to Binance, citing unregistered operations

The Philippines’ Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is moving to block access to Binance due to regulatory concerns, citing the platform’s operation without proper registration and authorization in the country.

Digital Assets

FTX cleared to sell investments in Grayscale and Bitwise funds

Bankrupt cryptocurrency exchange FTX has received approval from the bankruptcy court to start selling its stakes in digital trusts managed by Grayscale Investments.

Digital Assets

Nexo launches Dual Investment for yield earning and price prediction

“Dual Investment revolutionizes how users engage with BTC and ETH, offering a flexible, intuitive, yet sophisticated platform for predicting asset price movements, all while securing high yields.”


Aquis Stock Exchange goes live with cloud-based matching engine powered by AWS

“By running on AWS, the Aquis Stock Exchange is driving transformation across the capital markets industry while continuing to enhance the scalability, functionality and innovation that will benefit its members and stakeholders in an environment where security and resiliency are our highest priority.”


Options Technology certified as Microsoft Azure partner for Digital & App Innovation

“Securing our fifth Microsoft Solutions Partner status in less than 12 months is a testament to our commitment to innovation, excellence, and the highest industry standards. We are not only keeping pace with the evolving landscape of cloud technology but leading the way in shaping its future.”