US govt chooses not to provide all trading details in FX manipulation case

Maria Nikolova

In a letter to Judge Berman, the US government argues that “the trading itself was not the crime nor is it an element of the charged crime. The trading is evidence that the crime occurred”.

The conflict over evidentiary details in the case brought by the United States Government against three members of the so-called “FX Cartel” or “FX Mafia” continues. It has been apparent that neither of the parties in the case, captioned USA v. Usher et al (1:17-cr-00019), is eager to go through the huge amount of data associated with the allegedly collusive trading that went on for nearly five years.

The Defendants in this case: Richard Usher, Rohan Ramchandani, and Christopher Ashton, are accused of having conspired to manipulate the FX market by “coordinating their bidding, offering, and trading” at “certain times.”

In a letter to Judge Berman at the New York Southern District Court, dated September 12, 2017, the US Government stated its arguments not to provide trading data detail on any particular episode of collusive trading alleged to have occurred during the five-year period of the conspiracy. The letter is in response to Defendants’ request from last week about such details being included in a bill of particulars.

The US Government requests the Court to reject the Defendants’ requests for a bill of particulars and for the Government to provide specificity for all of the many thousands of episodes of collusive trading that took place during the entire five-year run of the conspiracy, whether or not those episodes will be discussed at trial, as well as for the Government to provide the specifics on a much earlier timetable.

A bill of particulars is seen as unwarranted by the Government because the Indictment provides factual background and a clear statement of the alleged collusive agreement.

The Government alleges that the conspirators carried out that agreement, in part, by coordinating their currency trading. However, it adds that: “the trading itself was not the crime nor is it an element of the charged crime”.

“The trading is evidence that the crime occurred, just as chat transcripts, emails, and recorded phone calls are”.

Even with no trading data, the combination of witness testimony, chat transcripts, emails, internal bank documents, and recorded phone calls should be sufficient, according to the Government, as evidence that the collusive agreement existed and trading in conformance therewith occurred.

“The Government chooses not to provide trading data detail on any particular episode of collusive trading”, the letter says.

The Government also notes the hefty volume of data in question. The alleged conspiracy in this case lasted approximately five years, during which the conspirators communicated together in an online chat room nearly all day, every day. The Government says it has not catalogued, and does not intend to catalogue, each of those thousands of collusive trading episodes. The Government adds that it will need to identify a small subset of representative episodes to be tried.

“Requiring the Government to specify “the episodes” (which is the same as “all episodes”) of collusive trading would likely take many months if not years to accomplish, to no one’s benefit”.

The Government argues that the timetable suggested by the Defendants is unachievable. In exchange, it proposes that:

  • Within two weeks of the Court’s Order, the Government will identify no more than 200 episodes involving alleged coordination of trading between the co-conspirators for potential use in the case-in-chief at trial. For each episode, the list will provide the date, Bates number of the associated chat or phone call that describes the episode, and the approximate time of each episode.
  • The Government will provide two updates to this list, on November 3, 2017, and December 15, 2017.
  • The Parties will exchange initial trial exhibit lists for case-in-chief evidence, either two weeks after the Court provides its opinion and order on dispositive motions or March 1, 2018, whichever is earlier, and final trial exhibit lists for case-in-chief evidence on May 3, 2018.

The trial is scheduled for June 4, 2018.

Usher, former Head of G11 FX Trading-UK at an affiliate of Royal Bank of Scotland plc, as well as former Managing Director at an affiliate of JPMorgan Chase & Co., Ramchandani, former Managing Director and head of G10 FX spot trading at an affiliate of Citicorp, and Ashton, former Head of Spot FX at an affiliate of Barclays PLC, have pleaded not guilty.

Read this next

Digital Assets

Zumo launches B2B ‘Crypto-as-a-Service’ solution for brokers

The new product, Zumo Enterprise, also features an embedded ESG and net zero strategy.


Top Tools to Add to Your Trading Platform to Delight and Retain Traders

The online trading boom that started during the pandemic-led lockdowns is abating. This is in part due to sustained market volatility which seems to be discouraging new investors. For example, day trading volumes in the US for retail investors declined in the last 2 quarters of 2021.  


Embedded finance platform Alviere taps Marqeta for branded card issuance in Europe and UK

Alviere has recently raised $70 million to fuel the ongoing expansion across the European region and the United Kingdom.

Retail FX

Overcharts partners with dxFeed for CME Group Market Depth

“More and more traders are using Market Depth while conducting volume analysis. Its primary function is to help traders identify potential support and resistance levels.”

Digital Assets

CoinGecko expands collaboration with security rating

CoinGecko, one of the earliest crypto data aggregators, has integrated the security score data from the rating. The trust assessments given to crypto projects will be integrated into their pages on CoinGecko website to draw users’ attention to the importance of security.

Metaverse Gaming NFT

Klaytn taps Parity Technologies to build infrastructure for Klaytn-Substrate

Klaytn has initiated a collaboration with blockchain infrastructure company Parity Technologies to strengthen its tech stack and meet the demands of enterprises looking to harness the crypto technology.

Retail FX

US Retail FX brokers suffer steep fall in client deposits, racked up $46K

Retail FX deposits at US brokerages, which have been struggling to eke out a profit in a strict regulatory environment, dropped in March 2022 by $35 million, CFTC data showed.

Retail FX

eToro supports Immutable X (IMX), Livepeer (LPT) and Cartesi (CTSI)

Israeli social trading network eToro has added support for trading three new tokens. Immutable X (IMX), Livepeer (LPT) and Cartesi (CTSI) are the next coins to join eToro’s list of featured digital assets.

Executive Moves

LiquidityBook hires Fintech veteran Jonathan Cross to lead EMEA business

LiquidityBook, a provider of FIX and OMS trading solutions for both the buy and sell-side, has added Jonathan Cross to its business team for the EMEA region.