XRP community shocked at Senator Warren and SEC Chair “orchestrated powerplay” to outflank CFTC

Rick Steves

“Senator Warren gave Gensler every opportunity to say the SEC must control things. The only thing she didn’t ask him is if he wanted a puppy.”

Senator Elizabeth Warren has sent a letter to SEC Chair Gary Gensler to request information about the regulator’s “authority to properly regulate cryptocurrency exchanges and to determine if Congress needs to act to ensure that the SEC has the proper authority to close existing gaps in regulation”.

Asking for a response by July 28, Senator Warren mentions the dangers to investors and consumers “in this highly opaque and volatile market” especially now that trading volumes have skyrocketed: Coinbase (the largest exchange in the US) saw volumes exploding from $30 billion in Q1 2020 to more than 10-fold in Q1 2021, even before going public.

Now that Coinbase trades on the Nasdaq, it gives mainstream investors who may be wary of directly buying risky digital securities the ability to own stock in a Securities and Exchange Commission-approved business that facilitates the transactions.

The Senator then pointed out the regulatory gaps that allow for trading volume manipulation – 95% of the volume of trading of Bitcoin listed on CoinMarketCap “is fake and/or non-economic in nature”, according to a study – and issues with custody of assets.

Cryptocurrency traded on exchanges is “deposited and probably co-mingled with the deposits of others. It is not recorded on the blockchain; it is represented by an entry in an electronic, centralized ledger. It is uninsured and there is no guarantee [the trader] will get it. [Traders] must rely on—trust—the intermediary.”

“Additionally, because cryptocurrency exchanges lack the same type of regulation as traditional securities exchanges, they can also engage in practices like proprietary trading and wash trading to take advantage of their customers without sufficient disclosures”, the US Senator continued, pointing to a 2018 report that found nearly 20% of the executed volume on Coinbase was proprietary.

The questions Senator Warren sent to the SEC Chair, to be answered by July 28, 2021, are the following:

1. Do you believe that cryptocurrency exchanges are currently operating in a “fair, orderly, and efficient” manner? If not, what problems has the SEC identified that are associated with the use of these exchanges?

2. How do the characteristics of assets traded on cryptocurrency exchanges differ from those of assets traded on traditional securities exchanges? Do these characteristics warrant additional investor and consumer protections for cryptocurrency exchanges relative to those provided for traditional exchanges?

3. Describe the extent of the SEC’s existing authority to regulate existing cryptocurrency exchanges. To what extent does that authority differ from the agency’s authority over traditional securities exchanges?

4. Foreign regulators have moved to restrict cryptocurrency exchanges in their jurisdictions in recent years while calling for international coordination to address regulatory gaps. One specific regulatory challenge may arise from the unique organizational structure of some global exchanges. For example, Binance, one of the largest cryptocurrency exchanges in the world by trading volume, “is everywhere and yet based nowhere. The cryptocurrency exchange has processed trillions of dollars in trades this year as it transfers digital and conventional money around the world through a constellation of affiliates. And yet it has no headquarters.”

In your view, to what extent is international coordination needed to address gaps in the regulation of cryptocurrency exchanges and ensure the protection of investors and consumers in the United States?

5. In a recent address, Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) Commissioner Dan M. Berkovitz stated: “In a pure ‘peer-to-peer’ DeFi system… [t]here is no intermediary to monitor markets for fraud and manipulation, prevent money laundering, safeguard deposited funds, ensure counterparty performance, or make customers whole when processes fail. A system without intermediaries is a Hobbesian marketplace with each person looking out for themselves. Caveat emptor—‘let the buyer beware.’” Berkovitz further argues that DeFi derivative instruments are likely illegal under the Commodity Exchange Act.

a. Do you agree with Commissioner Berkovitz’s assessment of DeFi platforms?

b. Do decentralized platforms raise similar investor and consumer protection concerns within the SEC’s jurisdiction? If so, what challenges does the SEC face in addressing these concerns?

c. Do the characteristics of decentralized cryptocurrency exchanges warrant additional investor and consumer protections relative to those needed for centralized cryptocurrency exchanges?

An orchestrated powerplay by Gensler, Senator Warren, and the SEC to outflank the CFTC?

The Twittersphere is raising the alarm, calling this letter a chess move that aims to definitively offer the Securities and Exchange Commission authority over digital assets and its ecosystem.

“Gensler and Warren are uniquely close and it is likely the SEC saw this letter before it was publicly sent (common practice among staffers)”, said Ron Hammond, Director of Government Relations at the Blockchain Association.

James K. Filan, an influential attorney close to the XRP community, went for the jugular: “This is an orchestrated powerplay by Gensler, @SenWarren and the @SEC_News to outflank the @CFTC for control of the crypto space. @SenWarren gave Gensler every opportunity to say the SEC MUST control things. The only thing she didn’t ask him is if he wanted a puppy.”

“Here’s the SEC’s hook: “And even though they share many features of traditional securities exchanges, such as “bring[ing] together buyers and sellers, execut[ing] trades, and display[ing] prices, cryptocurrency exchanges may be able to escape federal regulation if the digital asset being traded does not qualify as a security under federal law.”

“I’m thinking the answers we’ll see to @SenWarren’s questions were drafted before the actual questions”, Mr. Filan tweeted.

Lack of clarity in the United States fuels dispute between the SEC and CFTC

The lack of regulatory clarity in the emerging digital asset class in the United States has fueled many controversies throughout the years, with the latest being the SEC v. Ripple lawsuit.

There is still no clear understanding of what makes a cryptocurrency a security or not, and whether it should be regulated under the authority of the CFTC or the SEC.

The Ripple lawsuit has been widely considered as an opportunity to finally make all questions go away. CFTC Commissioner Dawn D. Stump has publicly stated that the regulator is closely watching the outcome of the SEC v. Ripple. “The question of whether XRP is a security will be crucial.”

Still, a digital asset doesn’t have to be a security in order to the SEC press charges against a blockchain company, according to “crypto mom” Commissioner Hester Peirce.

As the SEC is getting closer to outflank the CFTC, the top cryptocurrencies by market cap – which tend to get more scrutiny from regulators – were analyzed by attorney Jeremy Hogan for their “danger rating” of being sued by the SEC.


You might also want to read:

Will the Ripple lawsuit turn against Ethereum with the SEC revisiting its status?

SEC v. Ripple: Why is the lawsuit taking so long?

SEC finds Ripple’s argument “ironic” in bid to avoid controversial deposition

Read this next

Institutional FX

Binance delivers pricing and trading over MT4/5 with oneZero integration

Binance’s VIP & Institutional unit today announced a partnership with oneZero Financial Systems, a global multi-asset class software and infrastructure provider for institutional and retail brokers.

Institutional FX

BNY Mellon to leverage Baton System’s CCP network on its ECPO service

“The union of Baton’s extensive CCP connectivity with the ground-breaking functionality of BNY Mellon’s ECPO service forms a powerful offering to cleared derivatives market participants.”

Institutional FX

NYSE and Tel Aviv Stock Exchange to promote dual listings

“This major step is intended to foster collaborations between the two exchanges and to encourage the dual listing of Israeli companies in their home market and on the NYSE.”


TT’s KRM22 selected as risk technology partner of Chicago-based RCM

“Broad product coverage and effective risk analytics performance are essential to proper implementation of risk management and risk analysis.”

Industry News

DXtrade FX/ CFD Platform Integrated with Your Bourse for Turnkey Liquidity

DXtrade brokers received access to 30+ major banks and Tier 2 liquidity providers with Your Bourse.

Executive Moves

Wave hires Harumi Urata-Thompson as CFO of SEC-regulated crypto investment company

“With extensive experience leading teams across both the traditional finance and digital asset sectors, Harumi is well-equipped to provide our team with the immediate strategic insights needed to optimize our financial operations. She is a fantastic addition to our team as we continue to strengthen our position as one of the leading digital asset managers and to deliver sophisticated financial services to our clients.”

Retail FX

TRADE.com enters United States as brokerage obtains license from FINRA

“We intend to be fully operational as a brokerage house in the U.S. by the end of H1 2023 and look forward to forging long term relationships with new business partners and clients.”


Pico launches Corvil Cloud Analytics as trading industry moves into cloud

“Since Corvil Cloud Analytics is software only, this accelerates our deployments and also provides an expedited avenue for proof-of-concept use cases. It’s now easier than ever for clients to access the platform so they can see firsthand what makes Corvil an industry leader in data analytics.”

Executive Moves

Finalto recruits Antony Parsons as head of liquidity

Finalto, the financial trading division of Gopher Investments, is making a broader push into the liquidity provision space, culminating in a new appointment focused on expanding the business into new markets.