SEC v. Ripple: Why is the lawsuit taking so long?

Rick Steves

The answer might not ease the impatience, but it offers perspective on the United States legal system.

We at FinanceFeeds have noticed a recent surge of visitors towards our piece “SEC v. Ripple: When will the lawsuit end?“, which possibly indicates growing anxiety among the wider trading industry, with the XRP community of stakeholders suffering the most.

The lawsuit filed in December 2020 has pressured cryptocurrency exchanges in the United States to delist the crypto asset developed by Ripple Labs and has probably made many potential customers, including banks and central banks, hesitant to sign up for their services while the lawsuit lingers.

The question “Why is the lawsuit taking so long?” has also spread across social media and attorney James K. Filan, one of the XRP community’s favorite lawyers, provided an answer. It might not ease the impatience, but it offers perspective on the United States legal system.

“This is not the only case Judges Torres and Netburn have to work on. Statistics show that Judge Torres has almost 700 cases pending at any given time. Many of those are civil cases where there will be lots of motion practice, as in this case.”

“Judge Torres also has many criminal cases and under the Constitution those take precedence. There are motions, hearings, trials, and sentencings in all of those cases too. There is a backlog of all cases because the courts have been closed on and off for the past year.”

“Finally, these judges work their asses off. You saw that when Judge Netburn issued a ruling on the Sunday before Memorial Day. I’m sure they are both trying hard to get things done right and quickly. But done right comes before done quickly. We all have to have some patience.”

As to WHEN, the case is likely to be decided at summary judgment in early 2022, according to attorney Jeremy Hogan’s calculations.

The two main issues that should put an end to the case are Ripple’s fair notice defense and whether XRP is a security or not.

Regarding the Fair Notice Defense, the SEC has recently warned the Court that a Ripple win would nullify the Howie Test – the benchmark that has come under scrutiny with the emergence of the digital asset class. Ripple has partnered with Rutgers Law School to push for reform.

A Ripple win on the Fair Notice could not only have a significant impact on Ripple and XRP but also on the crypto ecosystem as a whole and even partially defund the SEC.

On the nature of XRP, the SEC has been claiming the asset is a security due to its centralized nature. Ripple, on the other hand, has kept proposing new use cases for the ledger – which is a sign of utility.

Regarding the status of XRP, Ripple Labs subpoenaed William Hinman to offer his deposition and clarify the SEC’s internal views and policy decision-making, among other issues.

The former Director of the SEC’s Division of Corporate Finance has publicly stated that Ethereum, as well as Bitcoin, are not securities.

Although the SEC is attempting to quash that subpoena, many experts close to the lawsuit believe he will be called to depose. The SEC has previously said his speech on Ethereum and Bitcoin were his own personal views, not necessarily of the SEC.

Mounting pressure on the SEC could, however, motive the financial watchdog to provide its official view on the status of Ethereum once its upgrade, ETH2, goes live. This would help the regulator sound more coherent with its own legal arguments in the SEC v. Ripple case.

Such a decision could be a turn of events for Ethereum as the new upgrade gets even closer to a security status, according to the Howie test and the SEC’s past enforcement actions.

 

You might also want to read:

Will the Ripple lawsuit turn against Ethereum with the SEC revisiting its status?

Can the Ripple lawsuit turn against Ethereum?

SEC finds Ripple’s argument “ironic” in bid to avoid controversial deposition

BTC, ETH, ETH2, USDT, BNB, ADA, DOGE, DOT, UNI: Who’s next after the SEC is through with Ripple’s XRP?

Read this next

Institutional FX

Deutsche Bank goes live with its FX pricing and trade engine in Singapore

Deutsche Bank has gone live with its electronic foreign exchange pricing and trading engine in Singapore, where demand for currency trading among institutional players is on the rise.

Retail FX

CySEC extends the suspension of Depaho license until November 19

The Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC) has decided to extend further the suspension of the license of the Cyprus investment company Depaho Ltd, which operates the retail FX brands GTCM, FXGM and TRADEAPP.

Retail FX

CAPEX.com introduces QuantX, a tool to build automated portfolio

Multi-licensed broker CAPEX.com has rolled out a new portfolio platform, QuantX, which uses a client’s risk tolerance assessment and other criteria to create fully customized investment portfolios.

Digital Assets

Ripple scores major win: Judge orders SEC to explain…a lot

The SEC is ordered to explain, among other things, how the Howie test applies to XRP, what is the status of Ether and Bitcoin, and the sale of XRP as investment contracts.

Retail FX

Trade CFDs on 900+ of the Biggest Companies this Earnings Season with HotForex

Traders with the internationally acclaimed multi-asset broker HotForex can trade CFDs on the stocks of over 900 companies during Earnings Season with tight spreads, flexible leverage, negative balance protection and the many other advantages that have made it an honest, open and transparent broker of choice to over 2.5 million traders around the world.  

Digital Assets

Polygon (MATIC) double spend bug yields $2 million bounty for developer

Polygon, the Layer 2 solution on top of Ethereum, has recently paid out the highest ever bug bounty in history to a whitehat developer Gerhard Wagner for pointing out a double-spend bug in the network which could have resulted in huge losses if it had been exploited.

Digital Assets

KuCoin aims to become largest social trading platform in crypto

KuCoin was founded in September 2017 and it currently provides Spot trading, Margin trading, P2P fiat trading, Futures trading, Staking, and Lending to its 8 million users in 207 countries.

Digital Assets

Apifiny’s crypto trading network adds Instant Transfers for best bid and offer

Instant transfers significantly enhance Apifiny Connect, allowing traders to more efficiently buy and sell on 25 connected markets across six continents.

Retail FX

iFOREX clients can follow two experts trading in real time

Trading Rooms’ access will be free of charge for active traders who open an account with the broker.

<