Australians overpay for FX services, new inquiry finds

Maria Nikolova

During 2017-18, individuals who used the big four banks for international money transfers in USD and GBP could have collectively saved about AUD150 million if they had used a lower priced IMT supplier.

The Australian Competition & Consumer Commission (ACCC) has earlier today published a new report into foreign currency conversion (FX) services. The document reveals that Australians are overpaying for FX services.

The report shows Australian consumers purchase the equivalent of over AUD40 billion in foreign currency each year and further competition in the supply of FX services has the potential to deliver significant savings for consumers in relation to those purchases, both in aggregate and for individual consumers. For instance:

  • ƒƒACCC estimates that individual consumers who used the big four banks to send IMTs in USD and GBP during 2017–2018 could have collectively saved about AUD150 million if they had instead used the lowest priced IMT (international money transfer) supplier;
  • ƒƒCustomers of the big four banks sending an IMT for GBP150 to the United Kingdom (UK) in February 2019 could have paid a price that was over 20% higher than the cheapest IMT supplier’s price.

The report focuses its competition analysis on IMTs. IMTs are significant for a number of reasons. For example, an estimated AUD21 billion in personal IMTs are sent from Australia each year. Also, the average transaction size for IMTs is much larger than the other inquiry services (foreign cash, travel cards and payment cards). Third, IMTs are generally not substitutable for other services; for example, there is no substitute inquiry service for a consumer wishing to send money to another person overseas.

It can be challenging for consumers to make informed decisions about FX services, as ƒƒprices are complex.

Services that appear to be cheap when considering only fees or the retail exchange rate can turn out to be the most expensive option based on the total price. Some suppliers, possibly in recognition of consumers’ aversion to fees, do not charge an up-front transaction fee and instead earn revenue through the mark-up on the retail exchange rate. Services advertised as ‘no fee’ can give the illusion that the price is lower than it really is ƒƒprices are presented in different ways. For example, some suppliers display the exchange rate and note that fees may apply. Others quantify the fees but leave the calculation of the currency conversion and total price to consumers. ACCC’s inability to easily collate complete price information from publicly available sources demonstrates how difficult it is for consumers to compare total prices.

The ACCC has recommended a set of measures to improve how prices are presented to consumers.

IMT suppliers should take the necessary steps to inform their customers up-front of the total price of an IMT, including correspondent banking fees. Suppliers of IMTs and foreign cash are also advised to offer digital tools on their websites to calculate the total price for those services for consumers.

Further, foreign cash suppliers should ensure that they provide price information that will enable an in-store consumer to understand the total price of foreign cash transactions.

Merchants offering goods and services online to Australian consumers are encouraged to inform consumers if they are likely to be charged an international transaction fee. Merchants should provide this information prominently and clearly, before a customer enters into a transaction. If consumers are charged an unexpected international transaction fee, they should contact their bank or card scheme to request a refund of the fee.

Read this next

Executive Moves

Finalto recruits Antony Parsons as head of liquidity

Finalto, the financial trading division of Gopher Investments, is making a broader push into the liquidity provision space, culminating in a new appointment focused on expanding the business into new markets.

Digital Assets

Huobi introduces Tether’s stablecoins pegged to euro, gold

Huobi, the world’s sixth-largest crypto exchange by trading volume, is set to introduce for its clients two stablecoins representing ownership of physical gold and Euro-pegged tokens.

Retail FX

Saxo Bank reports lackluster volumes for November; FX up 40% YoY

FX trading volumes through Saxo Bank’s platforms improved slightly in November, extending its volatile curve as investors continued to weigh central banks’ policy against concerns over a global economic slowdown.

Executive Moves

CMC Markets taps Finalto’s Julia Free to head UK compliance

CMC Markets PLC (LSE:CMCX) has onboarded Julia Free as its newest head of UK compliance as part of a broader organizational reshuffling at the UK’s biggest spread better.

Digital Assets

Ankr successfully patches hack, will reimburse victims and take actions to prevent further attacks

DeFi protocol Ankr plans to reimburse its affected users after a hacker managed to exploit a bug in its code that allowed for unlimited minting of its liquid staking token.

Industry News

ASIC cancels/suspends AFS license of AFSL Group and Quantum Funds Management

ASIC canceled the AFS license of AFSL Group because it failed to lodge statements and audit reports and it did not maintain AFCA membership. The Australian regulator suspended Quantum because it does not have the required professional indemnity insurance coverage.

Executive Moves

BidX Markets hires Shaun French as Research Analyst – Multi Asset

“We believe with his background in the Financial Markets and being based in Dubai, he will be able to provide our clients with access to outstanding research, while also being in a great location to help support our international clients base which is growing at a rapid pace’’.

Institutional FX

Nasdaq migrates US options exchange to AWS with +10% performance in round-trip latency

Nasdaq has announced the successful migration of the core trading system of Nasdaq MRX – one of its six U.S. options exchanges – to Amazon Web Services (AWS).

Institutional FX

TraditionData launches oil swaps pricing data at a critical time in OTC oil traded markets

TraditionDATA has announced the release of a new proprietary Oil Swap Model (OSM) which brings further visibility into illiquid and opaque oil markets.