Barclays, UBS, RBS, HSBC have to be sued in NY over FX manipulation, plaintiffs argue

Maria Nikolova

Plaintiffs, representing a putative class of consumers and business end-users sue several banks for allegedly engaging in an unlawful conspiracy to fix FX benchmark rates.

An argument over jurisdiction has emerged in the case Nypl v. JP Morgan Chase & Co. et al (1:15-cv-09300), which accuses a number of major banks of conspiracy to fix foreign currency benchmark exchange rates and include price-fixed rates in the prices paid by plaintiffs and a putative class.

In their latest filing with the New York Southern District Court, the plaintiffs, representing a putative class of consumers and business end-users, try to prove that the banks have to be sued in the United States. Defendants Barclays PLC (LON:BARC), HSBC Holdings plc (LON:HSBA), Royal Bank of Scotland Group plc (LON:RBS), The Royal Bank of Scotland PLC and UBS AG had moved to dismiss the Third Amended Complaint for lack of personal jurisdiction. The plaintiffs argue that this motion for dismissal should be denied.

One of the main arguments that the Plaintiffs use is that on May 20, 2015 and December 11, 2012, the banks in question entered into Plea Agreements and Deferred Prosecution Agreements with the United States Department of Justice and had Orders imposing civil penalties entered against them by the Federal Reserve Board (FRB) and the Commodity Trading Futures Commission (CFTC) for engaging in a conspiracy to manipulate and price-fix FX benchmark exchange rates “in the United States and elsewhere” and “within the flow of, and substantially affected, interstate and U.S. import trade and commerce.”

By imposing fines directly on the parent-level corporations, Barclays PLC, Royal Bank of Scotland plc, and UBS AG and HSBC Holdings PLC in the Plea Agreements and FRB and CFTC Orders, the DOJ, FRB and CFTC held the parent corporations responsible for engaging in a conspiracy to manipulate and price-fix FX benchmark exchange rates “in the United States and elsewhere”. This is seen to establish a prima facie showing of personal jurisdiction over the moving Defendants, including wrongful conduct in offices in the United States in Stamford, Connecticut and New York, New York.

The DOJ, FRB and the CFTC held the foreign, parent companies responsible for their wrongdoing, the plaintiffs note.

The Third Amended Complaint also alleges that the foreign currency FX benchmark exchange rates that were generated by Defendants’ concerted manipulation of the benchmarks or “fixes” were collusively included in consumer pricing in the consumer retail sales of foreign currency in the United States to Plaintiffs and the putative class by Defendants as the principal, almost entire component (93%) in the pricing of Defendants’ retail sales of foreign currency to Plaintiffs and the putative class. The Complaint makes a prima facie showing of specific jurisdiction in that it alleges that the moving Defendants participated in the alleged conspiracy to manipulate and price -fix the benchmark exchange rates in the United States and aimed to cause harm in the United States by collusively including the price-fixed benchmark exchange rates in the pricing of consumer retail transactions.

The defendants are also alleged to have bypassed the physical location of branches and local addresses. Each of the banks is alleged to have purposefully directed its price-fixed foreign currency products interactively online in the United States, including New York using only their logo name “BARCLAYS,” “THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND,” “UBS,” AND “HSBC,” and to have waived any distinction between their various legal entities and brick and mortar addresses and have also subjected themselves to the personal jurisdiction of this Court.

Plaintiffs request that the Court denies moving Defendants’ Rule 12(b)(2) motion to dismiss and/or grant Plaintiffs’ discovery of the Defendants’ declarants.

Read this next

Executive Moves

CMC Markets taps Finalto’s Julia Free to head UK compliance

CMC Markets PLC (LSE:CMCX) has onboarded Julia Free as its newest head of UK compliance as part of a broader organizational reshuffling at the UK’s biggest spread better.

Digital Assets

Ankr successfully patches hack, will reimburse victims and take actions to prevent further attacks

DeFi protocol Ankr plans to reimburse its affected users after a hacker managed to exploit a bug in its code that allowed for unlimited minting of its liquid staking token.

Industry News

ASIC cancels/suspends AFS license of AFSL Group and Quantum Funds Management

ASIC canceled the AFS license of AFSL Group because it failed to lodge statements and audit reports and it did not maintain AFCA membership. The Australian regulator suspended Quantum because it does not have the required professional indemnity insurance coverage.

Executive Moves

BidX Markets hires Shaun French as Research Analyst – Multi Asset

“We believe with his background in the Financial Markets and being based in Dubai, he will be able to provide our clients with access to outstanding research, while also being in a great location to help support our international clients base which is growing at a rapid pace’’.

Institutional FX

Nasdaq migrates US options exchange to AWS with +10% performance in round-trip latency

Nasdaq has announced the successful migration of the core trading system of Nasdaq MRX – one of its six U.S. options exchanges – to Amazon Web Services (AWS).

Institutional FX

TraditionData launches oil swaps pricing data at a critical time in OTC oil traded markets

TraditionDATA has announced the release of a new proprietary Oil Swap Model (OSM) which brings further visibility into illiquid and opaque oil markets.


TNS connects to Tel Aviv Stock Exchange (TASE) as market data vendor

“This latest exchange connection allows TNS to provide access to approved recipients, including exchange members and market data vendors. This project includes market data for TASE’s equities and increases the number of market data feeds we now offer globally.”

Executive Moves

Cowen Digital taps Taylor S. Cable to lead Europe and Asia operation

“Cowen Digital is a pioneer in delivering institutional grade access to the digital asset ecosystem and I am very excited to join the team at this pivotal time to grow our presence in Europe and Asia.”

Industry News

ASIC sues American Express Australia for lack of TMD on credit cards

“ASIC has now taken multiple actions under the design and distribution regime, including issuing over 20 interim stop orders. This regime turned a new page in the regulation of financial products in Australia and is intended to deliver better outcomes for consumers. It is a priority for ASIC to maximize these increased protections and see the long-term benefits of the DDO regime realized.”