CFTC seeks to depose programmers contacted by futures trader over spoofing software

Maria Nikolova

The US regulator wants to depose programmers of Greenline Financial Technologies and YJT Solutions contacted by Navinder Sarao.

The United States Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) is seeking to conduct additional discovery in its action against Jitesh Thakkar and Edge Financial Technologies, charged with aiding and abetting a spoofing scheme operated by futures trader Navinder Sarao.

On December 17, 2019, the parties in the action filed a joint status report with the Illinois Northern District Court, outlining their positions regarding fact discovery.

The document, seen by FinanceFeeds, makes it clear that the CFTC seeks to depose more programmers. In particular, the regulator wants to depose Sean Risteau of Greenline Financial Technologies and Michael Sanzo of YJT Solutions. Sarao contacted both companies, in addition to Edge, to develop his software program.

The names of these companies were mentioned by Thakkar and Edge into the summary judgment decision framework, citing purported actions or beliefs by both as supporting defendants’ arguments. For instance, Thakkar and Edge assert in their summary judgment papers that “Greenline was not able to work on the project, although not for any moral or legal reasons.” Likewise, the defendants describe in their summary judgment papers YJT’s response to Sarao’s solicitations, presumably to infer that YJT saw nothing improper in the solicitation, thus bolstering the defendants’ assertion that there was nothing improper to see.

The CFTC argues that it is entitled to discover the programmers’ actual reactions to Sarao’s solicitations. According to the regulator, the reactions by both programmers are relevant to assess the reasonableness and believability of the defendants’ asserted reaction—that they had no basis to know that Sarao proposed something improper.

As FinanceFeeds has reported, on December 4, 2019, the defendants filed a renewed motion for summary judgment with the Court.

Let’s recall that the when Court denied the first motion, it stated that the defendants could renew their motion after document discovery.

Shortly thereafter, Thakkar filed a motion in the related criminal case to modify the protective order so that he could provide the CFTC with all the documents the DOJ produced to Jitesh Thakkar in discovery. After Judge Robert W. Gettleman granted Thakkar’s motion, he copied and produced to the CFTC more than 800,000 pages of documents that the DOJ produced to him in the criminal case. The defendants also responded to the CFTC’s interrogatories and document requests in the civil case, producing another 1,068 pages of documents in addition to the voluminous documents previously produced by the defendants to the regulator.

Jitesh Thakkar and Edge Financial Technologies, Inc. request that the Court grant their motion, enter judgment in their favor, award them their costs and fees, and grant such other or further relief as this Court deems proper. If the CFTC insists it needs additional discovery to respond to the motion, the defendants request that the Court order the CFTC to provide an affidavit or declaration outlining exactly what discovery it still needs.

In April this year, Thakkar was acquitted on the conspiracy count in the criminal case brought by the Department of Justice against him. Soon after that, the Court declared a mistrial on the remaining aiding and abetting counts. Three jurors came out to speak to the attorneys and informed the attorneys that the jury voted 10 to 2 in favor of finding Jitesh Thakkar not guilty of the aiding and abetting charges. Following this result, the DOJ decided not to retry the case, and the Court dismissed the remaining counts against the defendant with prejudice.

Read this next

Digital Assets

GBTC share is trading at 36% below bitcoin spot price

Grayscale Bitcoin Trust share has widened its discount relative to the underlying cryptocurrency held in the fund, the highest margin ever since its debut in 2013. Digital Currency Group’s flagship GBTC shares traded at a discount of 35.8% to net asset value (NAV) today.

Digital Assets

Crypto lender Nexo investigated by 8 US state regulators

State securities regulators in New York, California, Kentucky, Maryland, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Washington and Vermont are investigating crypto lender Nexo for allegedly failing to register its Earn Interest Product.

Metaverse Gaming NFT

Astar Network’s ad features 329 top brands to support Web3 in Japan

Blockchain innovation hub Astar Network is making strides in promoting the Web3 adoption worldwide. In yet another milestone, the smart contracts platform has run a national newspaper ad in Japan that set a new global record with participation from 329 blue-chip firms.

Digital Assets

Pyth Network welcomes onchain data from crypto market maker Auros

“By sharing our high-frequency trading data with a truly onchain decentralized network, we aim to foster innovation that will lead to better financial solutions for all participants.”

Digital Assets

Tokeny integrates Ownera to boost liquidity of tokenized assets

“The adoption of FinP2P will result in higher liquidity and better access to capital and assets by providing regulated firms with one secure point of connection to multiple digital asset networks across the globe.”

Digital Assets

BingX launches subsidy vouchers to cover user losses in copy trading

“With the introduction of copy trade subsidy vouchers, new users can easily try out trading strategies without incurring losses.”

Digital Assets

Talos expands sales team: Frank van Zegveld, Matt Houston, Hillary Conley

“The extensive leadership and industry expertise of these new hires will enable us to build long-lasting relationships as we continue to build out our global presence in EMEA and beyond.”

Executive Moves

FX and CFD broker Emporium Capital hires industry veteran Robert Woolfe as COO

His past experience within the FX and CFD industry includes top roles at Capital Index, London Capital Group, GKFX, ETX Capital, and IG.  “I’m delighted to be part of the Emporium Capital team and spearheading the brokerages global expansion plans”, he said about the appointment.

Retail FX

Hantec Markets wins six categories at Global Retail Forex Awards 2022

Hantec Markets has recently rebranded with a new website and a renewed growth strategy that features the #TimeToStrike hashtag to signify a time of renewed growth for the broker.

<