Effex Capital, involved in FXCM’s US exit, challenges Appeals Court ruling in NFA case

Maria Nikolova

Effex Capital challenges the Appeals Court’s decision from August this year, when the Court sided with NFA over the content of press releases concerning FXCM.


As FinanceFeeds has reported, Effex Capital, which was embroiled in FXCM’s exit from the US retail FX market, in August lost its appeal in a lawsuit targeting the National Futures Association (NFA). According to Effex Capital, NFA had defamed it in documents related to a settlement between the NFA and FXCM. The Court of Appeals sided with the District Court in that Effex Capital had not exhausted all administrative remedies available to it before taking NFA to Court.

On September 17, 2019, Plaintiffs-Appellants Effex Capital, LLC and its CEO John Dittami filed a petition for a rehearing en banc.

According to the appellants, the Panel failed to recognize that their state law claims do not require any modifications to the February 7, 2017 decision issued by NFA in its disciplinary action relating to FXCM given: (i) that Appellants’ due process claims challenged the procedures utilized by NFA in the Disciplinary Action; and (ii) NFA’s position that Appellants’ state law claims challenged the Consent Order.

Further, according to Effex, the Panel’s holding also overlooked a basic principal of statutory construction which requires the Court to presume Congress acted intentionally and purposely in enacting laws, since 7 U.S.C. § 2(a) expressly states the extent of Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s (CFTC) jurisdiction and contains a savings clause preserving the right to prosecute claims in both federal and state courts. Effex insists that 7 U.S.C. § 2(a) leaves no room for inference and unequivocally shows Congress did not intend to preempt Appellants’ state law claims.

If the Decision is not reversed,the Appellants say, “the Panel has effectively licensed Self-Regulated Organizations (SRO) to act tortiously with impunity by publishing false and defamatory statements about non-parties under the guise of bona fide disciplinary proceedings against an actual SRO-member”. Effex goes even further by stating that the Panel’s decision, places non-NFA-member, non-parties in the impossible predicament of being unable to obtain recompense because it: (a) overrides the savings clause; and (b) NFA, unlike CFTC, is not subject to statutory claims like the federal government.

Let’s recall that, in its initial lawsuit against NFA, Effex sought injunctive relief, asking for an order requiring the NFA to remove the FXCM Settlement Documents from its website, to delete all references to Effex, or, alternatively, to provide Effex with a “name clearing hearing.” It further requested an order compelling the NFA to “issue a new press release stating: (a) NFA did not make any findings against Effex or Dittami; (b) Effex was not a de facto dealing desk of FXCM; (c) Effex was not controlled by FXCM; and (d) FXCM was not ordered to make any customer restitution.” Effex also asked for money damages of $10,000,000 for lost profits and to redress its constitutional injury.

Read this next

Digital Assets

SEC apparently approved Ether ETF as VanEck’s listed by DTCC

Amid increasing speculation about the possible approval of a spot Ether (ETH) exchange-traded fund (ETF) in the United States, global investment manager VanEck’s ETF has been listed by the Depository Trust and Clearing Corporation (DTCC) under the ticker symbol “ETHV.”


Unlocking Investment Potential: Introducing MoonBag Presale, the Cryptocurrency Set to Surpass ApeCoin and Bitbot

Discover MoonBag Presale, the cryptocurrency set to surpass ApeCoin and Bitbot. Unlock your investment potential now!


Playtech sees promising growth despite dispute with Caliplay

Gambling technology group Playtech plc (LSE: PTEC) reported solid financial results for the four months to April 30 as B2B growth and Snaitech’s record performance pushed it towards large gains in revenue.


Multipool Launches LBP on Fjord Foundry Raising $200k in 24 Hours

Multipool, a leading innovator in the blockchain and cryptocurrency industry, launched their Fjord Foundry LBP on May 21st, raising $200k in the first 24 hours.


$BEER, a New Solana-Based Memecoin completes Pre-Sale of 30,000 SOL this week

The Liquid Gold, $BEER, has become the most discussed topic on Solana over the past two weeks. $BEER has skyrocketed into Twitter trends across Europe & Asia, captivating beer lovers worldwide.

Digital Assets

Hong Kong regulator orders Worldcoin to cease operations over privacy concerns

Hong Kong’s privacy regulator has ordered Worldcoin Foundation to cease all operations of its cryptocurrency project in the city, citing risks to privacy and personal data.

Inside View

MT4 vs MT5: Which Should You Choose for Crypto Trading?

MetaTrader 4 (MT4) and MetaTrader 5 (MT5) are two sophisticated trading platforms developed by MetaQuotes Software. Although MT4 is the more widely adopted choice, traders must determine which platform is better suited for them and understand the reasons behind this choice. Here’s everything you need to know.

Digital Assets

Intentable.io Launches Intent-Centric Architecture and Marketplace

Discover how Intentable.io, formerly Kiroboflow, is revolutionizing blockchain interactions with its Intent-Centric Architecture and new marketplace for intent-based strategies.

Digital Assets

Crypto ETFs, retail trading spike as Bitcoin nears record highs

BlackRock’s spot bitcoin exchange-traded fund (ETF), which trades under the ticker IBIT on Nasdaq, saw a record amount of cash injection after a quiet few weeks of net outflows. The healthy metrics came as bitcoin briefly traded above the $71,000 level for the first time in a month.