Ex-Deutsche Bank traders seek to provide further support for acquittal in LIBOR manipulation case - FinanceFeeds

Ex-Deutsche Bank traders seek to provide further support for acquittal in LIBOR manipulation case

Maria Nikolova

Matthew Connolly and Gavin Campbell Black aim to overturn convictions that they participated in a scheme to manipulate LIBOR.

Several months after a jury convicted former Deutsche Bank traders Matthew Connolly and Gavin Campbell Black for their participation in a scheme to manipulate the London Interbank Offered Rate (LIBOR), the defendants have sought to support their claims for acquittal or a new trial.

In a raft of documents filed with the New York Southern District Court on Monday, March 25, 2019, Matthew Connolly and Gavin Campbell Black insist that the Court should enter judgment of acquittal or new trial in their case.

One of the main arguments advanced by both Mr Blackand Mr Connolly focuses on the Government’s interpretation of the British Bankers Association (BBA) rules. According to the defendants, these rules did not prohibit Panel Banks from considering their trading positions; nor was there any evidence that the BBA or anyone else in the industry who had read these rules interpreted them to prohibit this practice at the time of the events in question. To the contrary, the evidence demonstrated that market participants actually and reasonably believed that they were permitted to consider trading positions in selecting a rate from within a permitted range. 

Deutsche Bank’s LIBOR submissions were not false simply because they benefitted a position, Mr Connolly argues. Noticeably absent from the trial record, his Motion says, is any evidence concerning how the BBA expected Panel banks to formulate their LIBOR submissions and what the BBA would consider to be a “false” LIBOR submission. Nothing in the BBA LIBOR definition states that a Panel bank’s LIBOR submission must be the lowest rate at which it could borrow funds, nor did the government offer any evidence that the BBA expected that each Panel bank’s LIBOR submission be the lowest rate at which it could borrow.

Without offering any evidence regarding what the BBA permitted Panel banks to consider when formulating a LIBOR submission and without testimony from the BBA regarding its rules surrounding the LIBOR submission process, the government failed to prove that the LIBOR submissions at issue were false in any way, the defense argues.

Furthermore, the Government is said to have brought this prosecution without evidence that Mr. Black or Mr Connolly lied to anyone and without evidence that the BBA or a counterparty was deceived by any of his statements or harmed by any of their trades.

Hence, Messrs. Connolly and Black have to be acquitted or granted a new trial.

Let’s recall that the Department of Justice (DOJ) lashed back at the defendants’ arguments in February this year and explained that the jury had heard more than enough evidence to find all elements of the crimes alleged against Black and Connolly beyond a reasonable doubt. Thus, for instance, the co-conspirators’ testimony established that the defendants participated in the scheme, the DOJ says. Mr King (one of the co-conspirators), for example, described how he received requests from Gavin Black and Matthew Connolly to change Deutsche Bank’s LIBOR submissions to suit its trading positions.

Here are a couple of examples:

  • Bloomberg chat with Gurjit Dehl, in which Mr. Black asked “can we have a high 6mth libor today pls gezzer?”
  • Bloomberg chat with Mr. King, in which Mr. Black asked “COULD WE PLEASE HAVE A LOW 6MTH FIX TODAY OLD BEAN?”.

The case continues at the New York Southern District Court.

Read this next

Industry News

John McAfee indicted on crypto fraud charges

This is only the first case brought by the CFTC for a manipulative scheme involving digital assets

Industry News

ASIC announces regulatory costs ahead of CFD trading restrictions

The Australian regulator “is acutely aware of the challenges facing many businesses due to COVID-19”, but made no reference to the challenges FX and CFD brokers will face amid the leverage restrictions.

Industry News

Top lawyers say 2021 will be record year for AML penalties

Federal regulators have imposed more than $200 million in penalties on corporations, just in the last two months.

Industry News

Swedish crypto conman pleads guilty to $16 million scam

Karlsson was extradited from Thailand and is facing a maximum sentence of 20 years for the wire fraud and securities fraud charges and another 20 years for the money laundering charge.

Industry News

ESG premium on corporate bonds of +5bps in Europe

The top issuers of ESG bonds and loans in 2020 were France, Germany, and Luxembourg, compared to France, the UK, and Spain in 2019.

Technology

Finastra gains access to NICE Actimize AML and fraud solution

The AI-powered platform provides AML and fraud solutions, with real-time behavioral analytics and machine learning capabilities.

Industry News

A new dawn in stock trading is here. Your brokerage should embrace it!

London looks set to capitalize on the latest global equities trend of Spacs – This could well be the new trend for electronic trading firms. We investigate how.

Industry News

SEC launches Climate and ESG Task Force

The task force will develop initiatives to identify ESG-related misconduct and use data analysis to mine and assess information across registrants, to identify potential violations.

Industry News

Mobile trading takes center stage: Is your brokerage doing what it takes?

Mobile trading has grown in popularity in recent years to the point it became indispensable for the trading industry. The lifestyle changes and mass retail adoption amid the COVID-19 pandemic made sure there is no going back.