After last week’s explosive argument about trade execution, what do retail brokers think?

RTS28 is a lot of paper and hot air….

regulation

Last week, FinanceFeeds reported in detail with regard to an unprecedented and explosive argument which erupted in the public domain between some of the institutional FX industry’s most renowned and respected figures.

Each had an important issue to bring forward with regard to trade execution, and how the European trade execution reporting requirement RTS28 fits into the FX industry’s remit, along with whether it is a futile regulation or a valuable one.

Clearly, trade execution among prime of prime brokerages is a contentious point, and following the diatribe involving several senior executives, FinanceFeeds discussed these issues in detail with each company involved in order to provide a full insight into what matters with regard to trade execution.

This has always been a sore point, as brokerages, liquidity providers and even banks are not required to disclose the method by which they executed their trades, they simply have to be able to demonstrate that they act according to the trader or end user’s interests under ‘best execution’ guidelines, which are vague a best, and being challenged by senior industry executives to the extent that regulators are even considering dropping such guidelines.

Since the implementation of MiFID II across the European Union, in which infrastructure requirements were standardized by the European regulatory authority ESMA, some complex procedures were put in place, namely RTS27 and RTS28, which FinanceFeeds has discussed at length with specialists in this procedure.

The furious tirade was ignited by Yuriy Maevskiy, an FX project manager who has spent the last ten years within Cyprus-based brokerages.

Mr Maevskiy’s comment sparked an unprecedented battle among some of the leaders of the FX industry, from IS Prime, Advanced Markets & Fortex, and INVAST Global, who interacted vigorously with each other.

Responding to a LinkedIn publication by Eduardo Delgado, Managing Partner of Fintexify, in which Mr Delgado responded to an RTS report by the regulators by observing “It shows the own broker/LP as the only trading venue where 100% of the flow is executed: This means that the FX broker/LP is internalizing all the orders’ flow it’s receiving, taking the counterpart to the trades are managing the risk internally. It shows different brokers or liquidity provider and an unknown company as execution venues where x% of the flow is executed: This most probably means that the broker is sending the flow they want to STP to the LPs, and the flow they want to b-book to the unknown company”, Mr Maevskiy put forward his viewpoint.

Once our esteemed professionals had argued this out, the full extent of which can be viewed here, it was considered of value to look at this from a retail brokerage perspective.

Indeed, retail FX brokers are the direct audience and customer base of prime of prime brokerages, and they are also subject to the same rulings under RTS28. The question is, is RTS28 of any value, or is it an impedance which has been implemented by regulators who do not understand trade execution properly (I think it’s certainly the latter – Ed).

FinanceFeeds spoke today to Natalia Zakharova, Business Development Manager at FXOpen, a brokerage with licenses in all of the regions in which FX brokerages are populous.

Ms Zakharova explained to FinanceFeeds “The only thing that counts is how the trade has been filled.”

“When retail clients trade with us they legally face us as a counterparty and it is our job as a broker to protect their interests and choose the liquidity providers and prime brokers” continued Ms Zakharova.

“Should there be some issues with execution, we are the ones at risk. Pointing the finger at some counterparty down the line might be rightfully correct, but ultimately pointless from then reputational standpoint. Therefore, as long as prime of prime brokerages act in good faith and their business practices are fair, it doesn’t really matter with whom the trade was executed” concluded Ms Zakharova.

This echoes the current rationale among many OTC derivatives firms when choosing which Tier 1 counterparty to face. XTX Markets, along with some of its non-bank market making competitors now litter the top 10 Tier 1 FX dealers by market share like a vagrant on a beach.

This is clearly because the OTC derivatives industry understands well that the Tier 1 banks do not prioritise FX brokers, even though Tier 1 FX dealing is the core business activity of most American and British investment banks adorning the water’s edge here at London’s Canary Wharf.

Instead of rejecting fills, operating a cherry-picking last-look execution policy, and castigating OTC derivatives firms as a potential default risk by applying huge capital adequacy requirements alongside the extremely risk averse execution policies, non-bank market makers understand the OTC industry well and give the brokers what they want, that being quick fills, no last look and no slippage.

In effect, no messing about which banks call normal practice, yet FX brokers would be up before a judge for participating in.

So yes, RTS28 is a lot of paper and hot air.

Read this next

Metaverse Gaming NFT

Despite crypto winter, Fastex grabs $23.2 million in Fasttoken token sale

Fasttoken, part of the Fastex web3 ecosystem, has secured $23.2 million in financing through the private and public token sales of its native cryptocurrency Fasttoken (FTN).

Digital Assets

Iran to repay Russian debts in gold-backed stablecoins

A high-ranking member of the Russian parliament confirmed reports that his country was in talks with Iran to create a stablecoin for foreign trade settlements, to replace the dollar, ruble and Iranian rial.

Digital Assets

SEC denies Cathie Wood’s bitcoin ETF for second time

The approval of a regulated crypto derivative is still looking far less likely, as the US regulators have once again denied Cathie Wood’s application for a long-awaited spot bitcoin exchange-traded fund (ETF).

Executive Moves

Pavel Spirin promoted to Scope Markets CEO following Rostro acquisition

Belize-based FX and CFDs brokerage Scope Markets has promoted Pavel Spirin to take on an expanded role as the company’s chief executive officer. He replaces the outgoing CEO Jacob Plattner, who has also been a major shareholder since he resigned his position as managing director at GKFX.

Retail FX

Public.com goes all-in on alternative investing, launches Rare Sneaker Portfolio

“The concept of curated Portfolios means that our members will be able to invest in categories like art, trading cards, royalties, and real estate without needing to become subject matter experts on individual assets.”

Industry News

State Street taps AWS and Microsoft for cloud and infrastructure solutions

“By standardizing and simplifying our technology operating model, we will be able to more quickly deploy client environments and launch new products and services, while continuing to enhance the resiliency of our technology environment and our business operations.”

Institutional FX

Bitpanda launches Investment-as-a-Service business for banks, fintechs, online platforms

“Financial institutions today have to ask themselves how they aim to cater the increasing demand for modern investing solutions. Building these Individually, means a high startup cost, and products that are often outdated before they are even launched.”

Institutional FX

Options expands market data feeds after partnership with Tools for Brokers

“Our integration with ACTIV Financial marked the beginning of a new era in market data availability and infrastructure. Our teams have come together to provide unparalleled, fully managed market data services alongside Options’ global connectivity and infrastructure.”

Industry News

Recruitment in financial services sector buoyant despite planned mass layoffs

“It remains to be seen what impact this will have on hiring levels within the financial services arena this quarter”, said APSCo, regarding the expected mass layoffs within the financial services sector in England & Wales. 

<