MiFID II: ESMA warns of ‘zero cost’ and ESG marketing

Rick Steves

ESMA’s investigation uncovered widespread use of “zero cost” marketing claims that misrepresent the true cost of financial services. The report also examines the marketing of sustainable investments, revealing a mixed landscape.

The European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA), the EU’s financial markets regulator and supervisor, has published a combined report on its 2023 Common Supervisory Action (CSA) and the accompanying Mystery Shopping Exercise (MSE) on marketing disclosure rules under MiFID II.

Marketing communications (including advertisements) were mostly found to comply with MiFID II requirements, and ESMA admitted that investment firms generally have procedures in place to ensure compliance with MiFID II of marketing materials, including during their development.

Local regulators, however, raised some concerns regarding sustainability claims in marketing communications, including advertisements.

ESMA highlighted that marketing communications must be identifiable as such, and to contain a clear and balanced presentation of risks and benefits. In cases where products and services are marketed as having ‘zero cost’, they should also include references to any additional fees, the European regulator added.

The financial watchdog added a list of other needed improvements:

  • The need for adequate approval and review processes for marketing communications, including advertisements, whether these are prepared by the firm or by third parties;
  • Ensuring compliance with legal requirements on the part of distributors for all marketing communications;
  • Implementation of adequate record-keeping measures for all marketing material including social media posts;
  • Involvement of control functions and senior management in internal processes and procedures related to development, design, and oversight of marketing materials

Misleading “Zero Cost” claims and ESG under scrutiny

ESMA’s investigation uncovered widespread use of “zero cost” marketing claims that misrepresent the true cost of financial services. Many firms advertised their services as free or having no associated costs but failed to disclose other applicable fees. This practice can create a false impression of affordability, potentially leading investors to make decisions based on incomplete information.

The report also examines the marketing of sustainable investments, revealing a mixed landscape. While some firms made commendable efforts to provide detailed and transparent information, many others fell short. Key findings include:

  • Limited Use of Sustainability Claims: Marketing materials referencing sustainability were often limited to funds with specific sustainability features. Green bonds and other sustainable instruments were less frequently mentioned, indicating a narrow focus in sustainability-related promotions.
  • Generic vs. Specific Claims: Many firms resorted to generic statements about environmental, social, and governance (ESG) aspects, lacking the detailed disclosures required under the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR). This lack of specificity can obscure the true nature of the investments being marketed.
  • Compliance Issues: The report highlights several instances where sustainability claims were not presented fairly, clearly, or non-misleadingly. Examples include vague references to ESG ratings without explanation, broad statements about a fund’s impact without precise details, and unsubstantiated claims of better performance or lower volatility for sustainable investments.
  • The report also critiques promotional practices that claim adherence to international sustainability standards, such as the UN Principles for Responsible Investment (UNPRI) and the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD). Without proper substantiation, these claims can mislead investors about the credibility of the sustainability practices being marketed.

However, the report does highlight positive examples where firms provided detailed disclosures about their sustainability objectives, adhered to international standards, and offered specific information on integrating sustainability into their investment services. These practices were characterized by comprehensive documentation and transparent communication, serving as models for the industry.

Read this next


BlockDAG Transforms Crypto Mining with X1 Beta App Launch, Raises $49.2M in Presale; SEI & BONK Developments

Uncover BlockDAG’s X1 app beta launch, reshaping mobile mining and propelling its presale to $49.2M, eclipsing BONK and SEI.

Digital Assets

Joe Biden’s campaign explores crypto donations via Coinbase

U.S. President Joe Biden’s campaign is in discussions with cryptocurrency industry players about accepting crypto donations through Coinbase Commerce, sources familiar with the matter told The Block.


VGX Foundation and Honeyland Partner to Offer VGX Rewards for Players

The VGX Foundation has announced a partnership with popular web3 game Honeyland, offering rewards utilizing the VGX token for their players.

Digital Assets

Terraform and Do Kwon fined $4.5 billion to settle with SEC

Terraform Labs and its co-founder Do Kwon have reached a final settlement with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) regarding a fraud case, according to a court filing on Wednesday.

Retail FX

Dukascopy broadens CFD offering with Italian stocks

Switzerland’s forex bank and broker, Dukascopy has just expanded its offering to include Italian stocks and the Italy 40 Index. The new additions allow clients to access a broader range of investment opportunities in the Italian market.

Fundamental Analysis, Market News, Tech and Fundamental

Global FX Market Summary: Federal Reserve Monetary Policy, US Inflation,Eurozone June 12 ,2024

The Fed meets today to decide on interest rates. A dovish shift (keeping rates steady or hinting at cuts) is expected, weakening the US dollar and potentially boosting gold prices.


BlockDAG Leads CoinSniper Ranking as Presale Surges to $49.2M While Cardano Shows Resilience & ApeCoin Surges

Explore BlockDAG’s #1 ranking on CoinSniper listing as presale booms to $49.2M. More on ADA’s resilience & ApeCoin’s surge.

Market News, Tech and Fundamental, Technical Analysis

Gold Technical Analysis Report 12 June, 2024

Gold can be expected to rise further toward the next resistance level 2385.00, which stopped the previous minor correction B at the start of June.