Ripple queries are next key event for XRP lawsuit: “It’s the most important and it’s good”

Rick Steves

“It can’t point to an investment contract and instead is going to rely on statements and other murky half-promises made by Ripple”, said attorney Jeremy Hogan.

Ripple’s motion to compel better responses to its Interrogatories is the motion to look at out of all the recent motions, according to attorney Jeremy Hogan in a video. “It’s the most important, and it is good”.

Since interrogatories are submitted under oath – and therefore the answers are admissible to the Court – these are tools with which to whittle the opponent’s case down.

The Defendants will use this opportunity to hit hard on the SEC’s understanding of the Howie Test and how it applies to digital assets, particularly, XRP.

The motion to compel was filed on August 31, which was seen as a “This Is It” moment. The SEC has (unsurprisingly) opposed the motion and Ripple’s reply brief underscored the suspicion that “a truthful, sworn answer would reveal that no contractual provisions actually bear the weight the SEC intends to place on them.”

Why did Ethereum get a free pass and Ripple get sued? – Attorney close to XRP publishes memo

The Ripple’s motion will in large part be granted, attorney Jeremy Hogan believes, but “that’s not really the most important thing going on here”.

The focus will now go to the SEC’s ability to explain, under oath, how the Howie Test applies to XRP. The agency argues XRP was sold as an investment contract and that is precisely what Ripple is attacking in the interrogatory.

Interrogatory #2: “Specify the terms of Defendants contracts (if any) that the SEC contends created an expectation of profits.”

The SEC only referred to statements by Ripple outside of any contracts and by referring to Ripple’s sales contracts in general.

“The SEC is evidently having a problem properly laying out its case. It can’t point to an investment contract and instead is going to rely on statements and other murky half-promises made by Ripple. For example, the SEC is relying on a statement by Ripple that it would be a “good steward” of XRP to mean that there was an investment contract in place between Ripple and you – the XRP holder. That type of thing”, said Mr. Hogan.

“What is becoming clearer is that the SEC can’t articulate a solid “investment contract” argument and is even struggling with pointing out the “common enterprise” between Ripple and purchasers. And finally, the SEC can’t really say why or how Ripple’s efforts affected the price of XRP”, he continued. “And so this motion to compel is really Ripple nibbling away at the SEC’s ability to argue these key and vital issues other than through innuendo and suggestion”.

The attorney believes the judge will force the SEC to lock itself into its written positions on this and that will then be something Ripple can point to at summary judgment.

“And if that happens, and I think it will, the SEC’s case will be getting murkier and murkier. If it was a murder case, it would all be circumstantial evidence and although you can certainly win a case on circumstantial evidence, it surely is a tough row to hoe.”

Attorney Jeremy Hogan, in the same video, explained how a major shift in the SEC’s strategy is an admission of defeat.

In the meantime, Judge Sarah Netburn denied Ripple’s motion to gain access to the SEC employees’ XRP holdings, but the ruling still seems like a win for the blockchain firm as the SEC was ordered to prove its internal policy against holding XRP.

Are you up to date?

SEC v. Ripple: “Major shift in SEC strategy is admission of defeat” – Attorney Hogan

Why did Ethereum get a free pass and Ripple get sued? – Memo points fingers

Ripple scores win despite losing motion for SEC employees’ XRP holdings

Read this next

Industry News

Robinhood posts strong numbers amid growth in funded accounts

Robinhood, one of the largest trading platforms in the US, has announced the results of the third quarter which shows some robust growth even though the company did not push ahead with any major plans related to crypto.

Inside View

MetaTrader 4 – What Is It?

MetaTrader 4 is the most widely used Forex platform among brokers. What are the platform’s primary features?

Digital Assets

BlockBank launches DeFi application with Robo Advisor

BlockBank, a large mobile banking platform, has announced the launch of its DeFi application which will combine decentralized finance with AI-powered technology to help traders and investors make better trading decisions in the crypto market.

Digital Assets

eToro announces crypto staking and underlying assets for Australians

Australian users opening cryptoasset positions on eToro can now purchase the underlying asset. Soon eToro will enable coin transfers from the eToro platform to the eToro Wallet.

Digital Assets

EQONEX announces international sales team to show off digital asset offering

“It is time to show the world the quality of the EQONEX group offering, and I am excited to welcome such a high caliber group of salespeople to the organization”.

Retail FX

Webull donates 8,000 Brooklyn Nets tickets to New Yorkers

“The entire Webull team is thrilled that our first-ever sports partnership is with the Brooklyn Nets, who are only five subway stops from our headquarters in New York.”

Digital Assets

AEX integrates with fiat and crypto custodians Banxa and Xanpool

Spot trading, flexible savings, DeFi mining, are several ways AEX Global allows users to participate in the wider crypto space.

Technology

Barchart launches Microsoft Excell add-in

“Whether looking to perform their own analysis, add other data sources, build macros or anything else leveraging the powerful features of Excel, we now provide that ability.”

Retail FX

Inceptial expands Belarussian FX broker into China and Japan

“We are fully aware of the needs, customs, aspirations and limitations of the different markets of Asia, after careful research. We look forward to sharing our success with our new Asian partners on this journey.”

<